PDA

View Full Version : A Preventable Double Tragedy


willumau
27th Jan 2006, 06:09 AM
I am writing this from my broken heart to readers who may learn from a tragedy that should never have happened. On 16 October 2005, my mare Tomcats Peggy Sue (Q24025), gave birth to a beautiful chestnut Quarterhorse. We named him Lethal Tomahawk (Tom for short). Tom was a feisty little colt, incredibly nosey and full of beans. He grew very quickly and was a great show off with full of personality. He was bred to cut and showed the potential from his breeding when he would gallop around the paddock, ducking, weaving, spinning and stopping very quickly. We delayed registering him because of his developing colour on his legs.



On December 24 2005 (Christmas Eve) at 10 weeks old I found him in his paddock with a cut on his back fetlock and he was profoundly lame. I immediately called our vet who examined the wound to find that the cut had penetrated the synovial membrane through to his fetlock joint. The vet said it was a particularly nasty wound and gave me a choice of euthanasia him or give him a chance for recovery. There was a 30% chance he would fully recover and a 70% chance that he could be lame for the rest of his life when I would once again have to consider euthanasia. I did not hesitate, regardless of cost to give him a chance. We transported him and his mother to the vet’s facility where he underwent surgery to flush out the joint and dress the wound. Poor little fella was in a lot of pain, but was given painkillers and antibiotics. He was in for a long stay.



Meanwhile we searched his paddock to find where he could have sustained such a bad injury. We found a spot behind the shed where the rain had washed away part of the earth, exposing the sharp bottom edge of the wall of shed. He must have been laying down in the shade of the shed and stretched his leg into the gap under the shed. Realising his leg was trapped he obviously struggled to release himself, because he bent the bottom of the galvanised shed wall and in the process cut into the back of his fetlock. Now my husband and I thought we had created a safe environment for our baby – we built post and rail fencing, so there was no barbed wire or plain wire, we checked for sharp edges and ensured there was nothing the foal could hurt himself on.



Over the next 5 weeks Tom appeared to be doing quite well. His wound healed and was clean, but his joint was still sore. The vet felt the soreness was due to the fact he was still running around which aggravating the healing joint. He decided to put a plaster cast on the leg to slow him down and immobilise the joint to give it a chance to heal. Things seemed to improve, with the support of the plaster cast he was able to walk without any lameness.



Last night (26 January 2006) I received a phone call from my vet to say Tom was dead. The tears are flowing as I write about the final tragedy that befell my precious little Quarterhorse. The vet unfolded the story of what had happened. With Tom having to be handled every day, the vet left his halter on him. Tom and Peggy Sue were brought in at night and put into a day yard during the day; this was the routine for the last 5 weeks. During the day there was no one at the facility and when the vet returned that evening to put the horses in their stalls for the night and feed them, he found Tom dead by the gate to his yard with Peggy Sue standing near him. Apparently, Tom being his normal nosey self had poked his head through a gap between the gate and the fence post and caught his halter on the bolt of the gate. He must have struggled to break free, but the halter did not break. He died from asphyxiation – a particularly unpleasant way to die.



The stance of Peggy Sue and the mares in the neighbouring yard was that of sadness. With their heads hung low and a doleful look in their eyes they sensed Peggy Sue’s loss. Peggy Sue knew her baby was dead and not coming back – she has not called out for him.



I am writing about this tragedy in the hope that others may learn from my experience. Never leave a halter on a horse especially a foal unless someone is there to ensure he can come to no harm.



Tearfully yours



Lynda Harding

Ridgelands

Queensland

Dolly_Brat
27th Jan 2006, 06:14 AM
I have heard about the halters being dangerous and that your not supposed to tie them up either with them on... but a heartbreaking story like this demonstartes how dangerous they can be. My heart goes out to you and your mare.
Best wishes for the future... hopefully people will learn something from this and other lives will be saved!

CMR
27th Jan 2006, 06:14 AM
So sorry to hear about your loss:( The last foal my gelding had before he was gelded died like that. That is very irresponsible of the vet, I would be extremely upset with the practice. :mad:

xhorse_riderx
27th Jan 2006, 06:36 AM
sorry to hear your loss :(

Anna**
27th Jan 2006, 07:15 AM
My thoughts are with you at this very sad time :(

Jessey
27th Jan 2006, 08:26 AM
That is so sad, youngsters do have an incredible knack for getting into things they can't get out of and causing them selves harm :(
Halters can do so much damage when they get caught up, It is a lesson for us all. The new webbing ones seem to be the worst culprit, I generally use soft leather halters, hopefully that way the leather gives way before its too late, but even then, I never leave them on during turnout, but I know people who do.
My thoughts are with you.
J x

Mareish
27th Jan 2006, 03:46 PM
I am so sorry to hear your heartbraking tale :(

Unfortunately this is not the first I have heard of.

RIP little Tom and Hugs to all that knew him xx

Tootsie4U
27th Jan 2006, 05:13 PM
Im so incredibly sorry for your loss. Such a young boy, so much talent waiting to be tapped.... it brings tears to even my eye.

After hearing your story, its really hard for me to decipher which is the worst circumstance. I am one of those who leave the halters on my horses while they are turned out. And, truth be told, they're on their own for a few hours each day with no supervision.

This is a true story - and not a nice one - but it shows the opposite side of the coin. My husband and I were driving down a busy road (county highway) and saw a big black horse trotting on the opposite side's shoulder. A line of cars was trying to pass her. Suddenly, she decided to cross the road and came to our side. That was her first near miss. As she trotted toward our slowing vehicle, I asked hubby to stop the truck. She stopped right outside my window (there was a dead animals carcass that she stopped to smell). I took the opportunity to get out of the truck and attempt to grab her. I managed to get hold of her by the head and called for hubby to find some rope. She wasn't wearing a halter so when she tried to move off, I couldnt hold her. Hubby wasnt fast enough in getting the rope and she took off cantering up the road again. We got in the truck and drove a little farther down the road from where she was coming from since we knew there were two horse farms from where she could be belonging. In the time it took us to drive down and search for her owner (no luck), she had been struck by a man on a motorcylce. I do not know the fate of the man or horse. But the man was hauled away in an ambulance and the horse had severed her front leg. If she had been wearing a halter, I would have prevented all that....

Its such a shame for your accident and I truly feel for your loss. I dont know which is the lesser of two evils. Its a judgement call I guess as to whether keep halters on or off. I wish there was more that could be done.

horse__obsessed
27th Jan 2006, 05:42 PM
Oh, Im so sorry for you and little tom, and Peggy Sue. Headcollars... I find they are generally left on at the RS I go to, which saves a lot of time. When I get a horse, It will be turned out with no headcollar, unless it is really difficult to catch. (((BIG HUGS)))

Dina
27th Jan 2006, 06:16 PM
Thats so sad:(,
I am very sorry for your loss.((((((((((hugs))))))))))

Peace
27th Jan 2006, 07:52 PM
Oh, how awful.:( I just don't know what to say. I can't imagine how you must be feeling to lose him to something so preventable after what he'd come through.

Re the halter-or-not issue: I don't know if a foal would be strong enough to break the leather crownpiece, but I've seen a grown horse pop a safety halter with what seemed like no effort at all. My younger horse, Quanah, is required to wear a halter at all times - never mind why;) :rolleyes: - so I always make sure he has not one but two of them at all times. That way when he takes one off in the pasture the YO can just reach into my tackbox and put a safe replacement on him.

RustyMary
27th Jan 2006, 07:53 PM
Such a sad story - so sorry :(

Kalypso
27th Jan 2006, 11:07 PM
That's horrible. I'm so very sorry for your loss. Big hugs for you and Peggy Sue :(

re: the halters. Mia is almost always turned out with her halter, especially where she is at now with is by a main road - for the very reason Tootsie states. She does have a break-away halter though.

willumau
27th Jan 2006, 11:23 PM
I thank you all who have replied to my post. Up until this tragedy I had often left halters on my horses when they are in a small yard. Never in a large paddock (we have a lot of trees in our paddock with branches that can snag a halter). The halter that Tom was wearing was a robust nylon foal halter. I will never use a nylon halter on a foal again, it was just too robust to break. When the vet found him, the nose band of the halter had pulled down and clamped tightly over his soft muzzle closing his nostrils, and therefore preventing him from breathing. This occured when he struggled pulling back trying to free himself. The vet is very upset over the accident and no-one could have foreseen it happenng, as he said, Tom had been using this same yard with his mother for the last 5 weeks. The bolt that snagged the halter was the bolt that attaches the hinge to the wooden gate and it was on the outside of the gate. Tom had stuck his little head throught the bottom rail of the gate to reach some long green grass. When he went to pull his head back in the halter snagged onto the bolt that was protruding by about one inch. A million to one chance of it happening.

Thank you all for your kind words.

casey
27th Jan 2006, 11:54 PM
Oh gosh. I am so very sorry for your little Tom:( :(