How to know how much to sell saddles for.


Well-Known Member
Feb 8, 2012
I've made the decision to sell ales saddle. He's a happy boy being unridden and I'm happy with that.

I had it made for him and was a lovely comfy saddle. Just been sat on a rack for a number of years now unused.

It's marked on the flaps and also has some slight cosmetic stitching that has frayed. Any clue how much I should ask? It's a silhouette. IMG_20210615_092807.jpg


Jane&Sid these days!
Apr 30, 2010
Surrey Hills
A good way to see is to do an eBay Advanced Search. Put in as close a description of your saddle as you can (Hand made Silhouette saddle for example) and a little way down the Advnaced Search page you'll see a little tick box marked "sold listings" . If you tick that box it will show you all the saddles like yours that have sold recently.

Here's a link to my result when I did the search:

It gives a very wide range of prices, but if you look at the descriptions of the sold saddles you should get a handle on what you might ask and how best to describe your saddle.

I'd try selling it on the Surrey horsey Facebook site first to avoid eBay fees. They are not cheap no more!


Well-Known Member
Oct 13, 2004
On an island
Good luck selling it Ale. I tried to sell Joe's saddle countless times to no avail. I had it on ebay and had nothing but odd / rude enquiries about it followed by people demanding to try it and return it if it didn't fit! Tried to sell through word of mouth locally too but that didn't work either. So now it's a lovely ornament in the tack room :) Or as Mr T says "one day we'll have another tb that it will be right for".
I kept Storm's saddle as very sentimentally attached to it. Sorry, none of that is helpful! Good luck - you could try advertising it on here too.


Well-Known Member
Apr 6, 2021
Selling saddles is a nightmare. You just get people asking “will it fit my horse”. I have sold a few but it has taken forever. Last one was sold locally via marketplace where she paid the full price and took it away to trial it. That was quite worrying for me but it worked out. They seem to sell for a fraction of their worth. There are a couple of companies that buy from you and sell on, but they don’t take all saddles and if they do they give you peanuts. You then have to try and sort of a big enough box to post them in.


Jane&Sid these days!
Apr 30, 2010
Surrey Hills
I sold Mattie's saddle, which was a Black Country made to measure, very gorgeous. I got good money for it, £500 or so as I recall, by selling on the Black Country Saddles website. But I did have it on eBay at the same time and had many bids. The trick is to provide really good measurements, describe the horse it was made for, and make it clear that the buyer is responsible for the fit!


Well-Known Member
Dec 20, 2004
Suffolk, UK
I check market prices on eBay and marketplace and see what similar saddles go for and price accordingly. Some saddle fitters will take saddles in to sell on normally for a percentage, might be worth asking local ones.

Mary Poppins

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2004
Visit site
I sold Ben's old saddle on Preloved. It was an old (and worn) working hunter saddle and I thought that it was worth very little. However, my saddler advised that I put it up for £500 and within days I had 2 people wanting to buy it. I provided lots of photos and measurements (and scrubbed it clean - tack cleaning has never been my strong point), and got the full asking price plus postage for it. My advice is to put a decent price tag on it. If it is too cheap, the people won't buy. I personally wouldn't have thought the saddle was worth more than £50, but obviously others disagreed.


Well-Known Member
Dec 21, 2003
I agree about searching e bay. I also look to see what an item would cost new.
One is unlikely to get more than two thirds of new price.
If an item is no longer produced and the item is in demand, then the price may rise as there is an added rarity value.
I have bid on ebay mostly while buying Lego. Prices on ebay should be cheaper than the average price from a dealer which one can discover on line.
One would similarly expect a second hand saddle to be cheaper on ebay than the price of that same saddle second hand from a dealer. But dealers also put stuff on ebay.

Your saddle looks qute worn Ale. Dont forget e bay is not just for fixed price but an auction for which one can set a reserve on items one wants to sell. Dealers will bid only to the trade price. I bought my father's posessions at auction by knowing their trade value and bidding just a tiny bit higher.

I would start by trying the local facebook horse group to be collected, or haffie owners group and see if there is interest.

chunky monkey

Well-Known Member
May 2, 2007
The saddle fitters only seem to want to sell you new ones round here. Both times when i have needed saddles theyve said they have nothing to fit so i would have to buy new. Chunky being quite wide i could understand but Billy is pretty narrow, i would have thought theyd have loads in his size.

Someone said trade in to saddler is 200 to 400. They will then mark up to 700 or 800. That was a few years ago mind.
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers


Well-Known Member
Mar 23, 2015
A couple of our local tack shops buy/sell saddles. Obviously you will get less money but its easy and generally successful. One buys outright, the other sells on commission.


Well-Known Member
Jun 4, 2014
I'd try an online agent too - Saddles Direct, I think is one. You get less money than selling it yourself , but also less hassle.

I'd still say there's a strong second hand market if they are priced accordingly.
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
rtk How much to sell for / pay to buy Cafe 7
LokiSofi How much should I sell it for? Tack & Saddlery 14
never again How much for this saddle, would it sell? Tack & Saddlery 13
horseluver2007 How Much Should I Sell My Horse For??? General 6
Missmandamoo How Much Should I Sell This For??? :) General 11
P how much would you sell for General 4
dwoodie How much to sell for? General 3
K How much would you sell him for? General 6
Doodle92 Too much bedding? Cafe 21
Doodle92 How much panicking would you do? Cafe 16
S Too much haylage?! Metabolic 4
Jane&Ziggy Much better Cafe 3
Doodle92 I tempted fate too much Cafe 25
Jessey How much space for 1/individual turnout Horse Care 8
Native Lover How blooming much Cafe 4
Jessey A little bit much Horse Care 21
staceyemma1986 Welsh d 3 years old disheartened he may not grow much more Breeds, Colouring and Genetics 10
Sunshine Is it too much for 1 day? Cafe 24
C So much for hardy native! Cafe 11
Trewsers I can't seem to find much on this.......... Veterinary,Injuries and Therapies 12
Jessey How much hay do you go through? Metabolic 16
Native Lover How much to offer Cafe 3
MrC When is ad lib too much?? Cafe 9
Huggy Anyone know much about calf mix for horses? Metabolic 7
Mary Poppins How much salt do you feed your horse? Metabolic 29
N How much does your horse think? Cafe 11
R no how much you think you know a horse they can still be unpredictable Cafe 9
DaisyAM How much? Cafe 6
Lissie You know you've done too much hunting when... Cafe 15
I How much weight can a fjord carry? First Timers 7
Jessey Hank update...doing much better Veterinary,Injuries and Therapies 30
N How much can you tell about a horse from just looking at them? Cafe 11
T how much for a lesson on your own horse First Timers 13
N How much do you do? Cafe 10
No_Angel How much would you pay? Transport and Travelling 2
HaloHoney Trotting poles of much excitement Cafe 2
H Grazing lieance? Meaning & metered water how much do you use? Cafe 6
Ale Why do I like being on my own so much? Cafe 49
Pigletsmum How much weight? Cafe 3
Ale How much can you do in one day? Cafe 6
Ale Might not look like much to anyone else Cafe 5
stigofthedump How much grass should a laminitis-prone shetland have? Metabolic 7
N So much for the new £5 notes Cafe 20
MrC So much fun!!! Cafe 16
X Welsh ponies... how much can they carry? Adults who ride Ponies 6
R The cold weather isn't doing much for weight loss ! Cafe 5
P How much would you budget for? Cafe 28
Dazzle Rubbish hack - but am I expecting too much? First Timers 22
L How much weight can my cob carry First Timers 16
chev So much for today's lesson *better!* Training of the Horse and Rider 16

Similar threads