A loading debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter vieshot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
V

vieshot

Guest
A pony who is not scared to load, is just being a prat wont load. Owner used an electric cattle prod on his ass and now he loads every time. So what do you all think of that?
 
not a great deal, but hey id say one short sharp poke is better than hours of various people lossing tempers, horse rearing flipping over etc.
 
would we be up in arms if a cattle prod were used on cattle? Humm not my prefered method, however if all other options were exhaused then fine. As long as it wasn't abused.
 
Would not be my preffered choice but having a mare that used to take 2 hours minimum to load, as long as it wasn't mis-used. I wouldn't have it used on Angel though - it would wind her up more!
 
Knowing the "loading methods" commonly practised here in Italy, I can't say I have a problem with a cattle prod!
 
I think the owner is quite lucky the pony will load after that. All the difficult loaders I've had would probably never have even gone near the box again!
 
No denying it works, but I think the problem with using pain or fear of pain in this sort of situation is that you never know when the worm will turn and then you're back at square one or worse. I'd rather have a horse that loads because it's confident about it and trusts their handler.
 
I am personally shocked!

I would never ever, ever use a cattle rod to laod a horse - especially having experienced the longer term effects on cattle. There are so many better ways than making a horse do something out of fear of you ... I think the person ought to be ashamed of themselves.

x
 
Agree with jaydevon - better that than endless flapping around, particularly when the horse is just pratting about, and isn't scared. After all, a cattle prod was designed to get large animals moving where you want them to.

Frankly, it's great to hear a story of an owner who just took firm decisive action and has fixed a problem. No soul-searching, no agonising, no endless analysis while the pony gleefully takes the mick - just a horse that no loads, with no dramas and no side-effects. Very refreshing!

(I'm not advocating horse-beating, before anyone gets concerned!)
 
I'm afraid I've heard of other instances of cattle prods being used, IMHO it demonstrates how little some people understand their horses :(
 
I would not use one, as I dont think forcing an animal to do something using pain is the right way to do things. It's us (humans in general) who have taken animals out of their natural environment and made them do things to please us; they have little choice in the matter, so I think we should try to understand them and make their lives as pain-free as possible while we have them.
And in response to mikh's question, I dont think it's right to use one on cattle either.
xx
 
I would not use one, as I dont think forcing an animal to do something using pain is the right way to do things. It's us (humans in general) who have taken animals out of their natural environment and made them do things to please us; they have little choice in the matter, so I think we should try to understand them and make their lives as pain-free as possible while we have them.
And in response to mikh's question, I dont think it's right to use one on cattle either.
xx

Seriously, you can't spend hours teachin a herd of 100 cattle join up!! Sometimes it is necessary to use such things - can you think of a better way of moving a stubborn cow who weighs a tonne & would happily kick the monkies out of you?!
 
I would not use one, as I dont think forcing an animal to do something using pain is the right way to do things. It's us (humans in general) who have taken animals out of their natural environment and made them do things to please us; they have little choice in the matter, so I think we should try to understand them and make their lives as pain-free as possible while we have them.
And in response to mikh's question, I dont think it's right to use one on cattle either.
xx

Ditto.

The issue has probably not been solved as the horse will now probably fear cattle rods and will consider travelling as been an even more negative issue than beforehand.
Horses don't behave 'naughtily' (as many on here will know :p I don't believe in horses being deliberately 'bad') without good reason.
It is a very unnatural thing to do, walking into a dark, noisy, small space alone and often at speed, having to balance. The horse has every reason not to want to go in - "prat", honestly! :-/

x
 
particularly when the horse is just pratting about

Horses don't just 'prat about', they only know how to act like horses and live in the moment. Half the time bad loaders are created by the handler's actions, impatience and inattendance, so it's a little unfair to say the least to reward that with a sharp infliction of pain as a result:rolleyes:
 
Well I guess I am off the school who does believe my horse has the capacity to take the mickey out of me, I think he is quite intelligent actually. He will stand for hours not wanting to load, not showing an ounce of fear, and once he has finally been persuaded to load into the horrid airy light roomy trailer, he happily munches a hay net & nods off! I do not believe my horse is scared of travelling more prefers to avoid the activity that usually occurs once travelled!
 
no doubt the pony was too :D

Horses don't fear a fence because they have been zapped by it, do they?
I mean they don't actually FEAR it, they just respect it enough to not quite touch it when they lean over to savage the tarpaulin covering the fresh hay.

A good sharp shock is what many children need when they're being naughty, be it a cattle prod or an electric fence I don't see the difference when a boundary is being deliberately ignored *runs & hides* ...
 
more prefers to avoid the activity that usually occurs once travelled!

Perhaps it would be an idea to travel him to do something he really enjoys now and again in that case? :)
 
Horses don't fear a fence because they have been zapped by it, do they?
I mean they don't actually FEAR it, they just respect it enough to not quite touch it when they lean over to savage the tarpaulin covering the fresh hay.

A good sharp shock is what many children need when they're being naughty, be it a cattle prod or an electric fence I don't see the difference when a boundary is being deliberately ignored *runs & hides* ...

I agree..**hides with soot**
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com