A loading debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter vieshot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
would we be up in arms if a cattle prod were used on cattle?

Well said. Most people - even those with horses - have little real experience of large animal management and what it periodically may involve, especially in open range systems.
 
I am not saying that i agree with the cattle prod BUT when inferior horse doesnt obey superior horse he gets kicked or bitten and quickly learns to do as he/she is asked.

My sister has had many horses and has never had a problem with loading. I asked her how she did it and her reply? They only take the p**s once.
 
Horses don't behave 'naughtily' (as many on here will know :p I don't believe in horses being deliberately 'bad') without good reason.

Yes, but sometimes the horse's good reason is "I don't want to". It isn't necessarily because they're frightened or in pain - they might be feeling lazy, or simply testing you out.

If the horse is in pain, or frightened, of course you treat them accordingly. But horses can and do take the mick. :D
 
the pony in question once in munched hay so cant have been to much of a stressfull experience!
 
Yes, but sometimes the horse's good reason is "I don't want to". It isn't necessarily because they're frightened or in pain - they might be feeling lazy, or simply testing you out.

If the horse is in pain, or frightened, of course you treat them accordingly. But horses can and do take the mick. :D

Perhaps so, but my point is it never gives the owner/handler the right to say/do: "Well, I see no reason for it which means I have every right to force him to do it, in whichever way is 'necessary'".
And if the horse is lazy (unlikely) or 'testing you out' then it is the handler's respionsibility to establish and prove - if not already then there and then - their deserving leadership in a calm, confident manner that the horse understands and gains confidence from, so that s/he is willing to load having learned to trust the handler.

x
 
A good sharp shock is what many children need when they're being naughty, be it a cattle prod or an electric fence I don't see the difference when a boundary is being deliberately ignored

An electric fence punishes the horse with perfect timing, it's actions are completely neutral otherwise. A cattle prod on the other hand is a different matter, especially if the loading is being badly presented, or the horse is actually trying to take the decision to go on.

I wasn't aware it was standard practice to zap children with electricity to get them to behave either :D
 
and if more people realised this and adressed the problem they would have far fewer issues. How often do you hear " i don't do such and such a thing because my horse doesn't like it" ?

Personally I would much prefer to do something that my horse enjoys as well as me!
 
A lot of horses would load far more easily if their handlers actually had full control of them on the ground. 'Mick taking' is often an indication of a gap in the horse's training, not a personality defect.
 
I wasn't aware it was standard practice to zap children with electricity to get them to behave either :D
It may not be, "up north", but we southerners find it quite an effective means of getting them in their cage. :)
 
Personally I would much prefer to do something that my horse enjoys as well as me!

Ditto! You wouldn't deliberately annoy your friend just because you think it's petty that she is annoyed, or because you don't want to feel you have 'given in' to him/her, would you?. So why would anyone your horse? It's part of being a living bthing!

A lot of horses would load far more easily if their handlers actually had full control of them on the ground. 'Mick taking' is often an indication of a gap in the horse's training, not a personality defect.

... Or a gap in the handler's training and personality ...

x
 
I wasn't aware it was standard practice to zap children with electricity to get them to behave either :D

lol:D I sometimes wish it were (runs and hides now:o) Ah, imagine slightly electrified shelves in supermarkets where kids aren't supposed to be grabbing things........:D:D
 
Agree with Yann. Horses only "take the mick" because of gaps in their training, or, dare I say it, gaps in their handlers competencies. A happy, confident, well trained horse will do most things that are asked of it.

However, that said, sometimes it is necessary to use "not-so-nice" methods to load horses. For instance, if they need to get to the vets urgently and their life depends on it, then you use whatever methods you need to to get the horse on the trailer. In all other circumstances, a bit of patience, skill and training are all that is needed.

I stable my horse on a competition yard and the amount of times people struggle to load their horses is unbelievable. One lady was even trying to load her horse by tugging on a chifney and wondering why the horse wouldn't move forwards... Surprisingly enough, the horse loaded once the pressure from the chifney was removed and the headcollar used instead....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com