A loading debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter vieshot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Humans hit each other too, so does that make it right for a horse to hti a human as well?

x

No cos humans are higher up the food (and brain) chain.. ;):rolleyes:

People.. lets not forget that WE are supposed to be king of this particular castle.. what horses do to each other is one thing but I'm not a horse .. I'm a human and my horses know this.. i.e "She's the one with the gun and the BBQ"..
 
Be aware everyone:

Vieshot - other people can read NFED and I see you have started this thread for a bit of trolling and you are referring to NR posters in your NFED post as the "poor whittle pony lot" and have put up a link to this thread encouraging your fellow neanderthals to laugh at the people here who are taking the time to reply to your thread.

Lovely.
 
I have had so many experts try! Monty Roberts & Kelly Marks for one. She has been at there demo and there 2 day loading course! A horse whisperer and i currently have a NH friend helping me he is the only one that has cracked it! He has a simple method and disagrees with Kelly marks and Monty Roberts techniques which after dealing with him so do i!
Sorry I don't mean to sound abrupt but this is a topic which affects me a lot. Angel is not a good traveller and because of this certainly isn't a good loader, I have had 4 years of battles with her only once been able to load her within 5 mins! a few weeks ago HORAHHHH!!!! I am limited to a horsebox only rear facing as she passed out in the trailer! Every horse is different. If I didn't have to travel her I wouldn't but she has to get used to it whether she likes it or not - i am sorry but if she has to go to the vets for an emergency then I can't have 2 hours of no thank you very much before hand. Horses do have to do things they don't like, thats life, as do we.
 
I'm sorry, but i think that is disgusting behaviour, and this is my personal opinion before anyone has a rant at me, but to use a cattle prod for loading a horse to me is beyond belief.
 
Be aware everyone:

Vieshot - other people can read NFED and I see you have started this thread for a bit of trolling and you are referring to NR posters in your NFED post as the "poor whittle pony lot" and have put up a link to this thread encouraging your fellow neanderthals to laugh at the people here who are taking the time to reply to your thread.

Lovely.

Whats your point?
 
Horses don't fear a fence because they have been zapped by it, do they?
I mean they don't actually FEAR it, they just respect it enough to not quite touch it when they lean over to savage the tarpaulin covering the fresh hay.

Daffy does actually. He got caught in one once (luckily I'd switched it off) and bolted into a wall, so although he does get used to them being on, I'd say it goes a bit further than just respect with him. Normal horses though, I completely agree. ;)

It's not a method I would've used, we use two lunge lines with Daffy, unfortunately I've never been in a position to really work on his loading, but if I was I'd use the clicker as I have had such good results with it elsewhere.

In a dangerous situation, where either myself or a horse were at serious risk of injury, then I would do what it takes, and if that meant a cattle prod to get forward movement, so be it.
 
Horses react to things, they don't sit down and think about them. And afterwards they don't analyse the event, they just learn what consequences their actions have, be them negative or positive.

If my boy decides to try and crush me against a wall (as he did the other day in a tantrum about having his feet picked) and as a consequence gets elbowed hard so he gets the hell off me. He doesn't think "that was mean, why did she do that" he thinks "when I did that it wasn't pleasant, I won't do that again".

When I moved him into the new herd he had the sh*t kicked out of him for the first few days, far worse than I would ever inflict on him - he was chased, bullied, excluded. He isn't afraid of any of the herd as a result, in fact now he is established in the herd he is happy and relaxed with all of the others and shows no fear or worry towards any of them.

Equally he isn't scared of me in the slightest, I also don't believe he see's me as a "friend" either though. Horses are horses at the end of the day, I am someone he trusts to feed and protect him and treat him with kindness. In return he knows he must 'play the game'. I don't think he sits up all night in his stable fretting over being reprimanded for trying to barge out his stable that morning.
 
Be aware everyone:

Vieshot - other people can read NFED and I see you have started this thread for a bit of trolling and you are referring to NR posters in your NFED post as the "poor whittle pony lot" and have put up a link to this thread encouraging your fellow neanderthals to laugh at the people here who are taking the time to reply to your thread.

Lovely.

Have I completely missed something?? :confused:

x
 
Yeh i think I have to Puzzles! Send us the link to then Vieshot so we can see other peoples replies?

The discussion is also on another link that has a link to this so they can see what the fwuffy pwony lot think
 
Lucy Angel, this is a subject that interests me a lot too, and I'm fully aware one size doesn't fit all, I'd be interested to know how your NH friend has helped with your particular horse :)
Incidentally although I know it was only in jest I wouldn't dream of trying to work with a horse with issues like yours :)

I'd be interested to read the NFED thread too, any chance of a link? On the other hand I can guess the content given the previous post, it's clear your starting this thread wasn't entirely in good faith if the purpose was merely to be able to mock people behind their back.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hehe, I would actually be up for a try, but you'd be better off getting someone who really knows what they're doing to show you :) Rio went from planting at the bottom of the ramp and running off backwards once on to being a reliable loader with the help of an RA :)


You are more than welcome to give it a shot - and I can probably guarantee by the end of it you will have him happily walking in! I can do that, without partitions, with partitions, its a few occasions down the line that the problems start!
I am not condoning beating horses, if that method worked with that horse thats fine with me. However I think I have learned alot fromo my horse when it comes to loading, I can feel I can read him so much better now! You can tell what mood he is in, and how he will react to certain things.
It really depends on the horse and the handlers relationship with the horse.
 
Oh I fully believe it is true Vieshot.
I just wanted other NRs to know that in taking time to put a reasoned response your comments (or at least those of you who don't think giving an electric shock is an appropriate method of helping your horse learn) are being made a laughing stock on another board.
Maybe others won't be bothered but I find it most unpleasant.
 
It's actually quite sad that someone feels the need to go to the trouble of mocking others' techniques and beliefs to make themselves feel better :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com