A loading debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter vieshot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh I fully believe it is true Vieshot.
I just wanted other NRs to know that in taking time to put a reasoned response your comments (or at least those of you who don't think giving an electric shock is an appropriate method of helping your horse learn) are being made a laughing stock on another board.
Maybe others won't be bothered but I find it most unpleasant.

wouldnt say that, its all down to what people think and believe is right or wrong. There are hundreds of people on that forum, i very much doubt they all have the same views on using a cattle prod
 
Which forum?

Well, to be honest, f**k them as - perhaps unintended on their behalf - we're all having a ball! :p What fulfilling, righteous and worthwhile lives they do lead :D

x
 
It really depends on the horse and the handlers relationship with the horse.

Definitely, and the horse's history and previous experiences too. Like I said before I'm in no position to make any judgement about you and your horse, and wouldn't dream of doing so :)

Thank you flump1967 for making us aware.

Yep.
 
In the horse world, no matter what your views there will be others who mock you for holding them. It doesn't really matter if this thread was started with an unsavoury motive (although if that's true it's a bit of a odd thing to bother doing); if we hold views we should be prepared to defend them no matter who is watching. In any case, I've really enjoyed this thread; it's been a great debate (so far?) and in the main it's been extremely civilised and grown up - as they all should be!
 
In the horse world, no matter what your views there will be others who mock you for holding them. It doesn't really matter if this thread was started with an unsavoury motive (although if that's true it's a bit of a odd thing to bother doing); if we hold views we should be prepared to defend them no matter who is watching. In any case, I've really enjoyed this thread; it's been a great debate (so far?) and in the main it's been extremely civilised and grown up - as they all should be!

Here here! :D By all means let's continue the debate!

x
 
Which forum?

Well, to be honest, f**k them as - perhaps unintended on their behalf - we're all having a ball! :p What fulfilling, righteous and worthwhile lives they do lead :D

x

LOL! Yes, I'm well aware of that forum and it's a haven for the equestrian knuckledragger by all accounts:D
 
In the horse world, no matter what your views there will be others who mock you for holding them. It doesn't really matter if this thread was started with an unsavoury motive (although if that's true it's a bit of a odd thing to bother doing); if we hold views we should be prepared to defend them no matter who is watching. In any case, I've really enjoyed this thread; it's been a great debate (so far?) and in the main it's been extremely civilised and grown up - as they all should be!


well said theocat :D

ps can we get back to the electrocuting children debate now? :D:D:D
 
In the horse world, no matter what your views there will be others who mock you for holding them. It doesn't really matter if this thread was started with an unsavoury motive (although if that's true it's a bit of a odd thing to bother doing); if we hold views we should be prepared to defend them no matter who is watching. In any case, I've really enjoyed this thread; it's been a great debate (so far?) and in the main it's been extremely civilised and grown up - as they all should be!


The person whose horse it is started a thread on NFED, its only fair they have a link to see what everyone on here thinks, i knew all to well there would be plenty of people thinking it was cruel and inhumane on this forum judging by past replies and would make for fantastic reading. I do think some, certainly not all people who post on here are IMHO 'fwuffy pwony' people, meaning they humanise their horses and think they understand them as their best mate/soul mate or whatever. I stick by that and i openly admit i do find some of those types of replies very funny and enjoy having a good giggle.
 
The person whose horse it is started a thread on NFED, its only fair they have a link to see what everyone on here thinks, i knew all to well there would be plenty of people thinking it was cruel and inhumane on this forum judging by past replies and would make for fantastic reading. I do think some, certainly not all people who post on here are IMHO 'fwuffy pwony' people, meaning they humanise their horses and think they understand them as their best mate/soul mate or whatever. I stick by that and i openly admit i do find some of those types of replies very funny and enjoy having a good giggle.

I presume that means me ... ?

x
 
A pony who is not scared to load, is just being a prat wont load. Owner used an electric cattle prod on his ass and now he loads every time. So what do you all think of that?

Fantastic, where do I get one??

In all seriousness if it was used once, had the desired effect and has not been necessary to use it since it seems like a no brainer to me.
 
Horses feel pain and have feelings. I really dont see why taking that into account when dealing with them is something to laugh about :confused:
 
i openly admit i do find some of those types of replies very funny and enjoy having a good giggle.

How nice for you:rolleyes: Unfortunately it's abundantly clear you don't have a clue about how 'fluffy wuffy' people actually relate to their horses. They certainly don't give them human attributes like the nice person with the cattleprod's horse that was 'taking the mick'.
 
The person whose horse it is started a thread on NFED, its only fair they have a link to see what everyone on here thinks, i knew all to well there would be plenty of people thinking it was cruel and inhumane on this forum judging by past replies and would make for fantastic reading. I do think some, certainly not all people who post on here are IMHO 'fwuffy pwony' people, meaning they humanise their horses and think they understand them as their best mate/soul mate or whatever. I stick by that and i openly admit i do find some of those types of replies very funny and enjoy having a good giggle.

I don't really have a problem with any of that. :) I'd even go so far as to agree that some people who post on here treat their horse more like a human in a way that I personally find uncomfortable. However, a) that's the horse world generally, not just NR, and b) there's a big difference between those who use (for want of a better phrase) "alternative" techniques (most of which work very well in the right hands), and those whose refusal to see their horse as a horse is, frankly, dangerous.

But I bet the other forum, and you, were surprised how many people on this thread apparently AREN'T "fwuffy"!
 
I don't really have a problem with any of that. :) I'd even go so far as to agree that some people who post on here treat their horse more like a human in a way that I personally find uncomfortable. However, a) that's the horse world generally, not just NR, and b) there's a big difference between those who use (for want of a better phrase) "alternative" techniques (most of which work very well in the right hands), and those whose refusal to see their horse as a horse is, frankly, dangerous.

But I bet the other forum, and you, were surprised how many people on this thread apparently AREN'T "fwuffy"!

Nah as ive said, its only really a small amount that seem fwuffy. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com