A loading debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter vieshot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Interesting discussion.

Without getting too personal, I think people need to go out and find some way of loading horses effectively. By effectively, I mean a method that works with more than the 80% of horses that just go 'okay, a cattle prob, I'll load'. I mean find a way of loading the other 20% that will give you a piece of their mind if you go about it ineffectively.

As the master Ray Hunt said (quote unquote),

'If you get bitten, kicked, run over, HA, you deserve it!'

That includes the people on the other forum having a laugh at other people's ineffectiveness/effectiveness, and of course includes me and all other New Riders.

Interesting debate though, and use as many cattle prods as you like, hopefully one day everyone will get to meet one of those horses that gives you the birdie and teaches the person to think again.
 
Interesting discussion.

Without getting too personal, I think people need to go out and find some way of loading horses effectively. By effectively, I mean a method that works with more than the 80% of horses that just go 'okay, a cattle prob, I'll load'. I mean find a way of loading the other 20% that will give you a piece of their mind if you go about it ineffectively.

As the master Ray Hunt said (quote unquote),

'If you get bitten, kicked, run over, HA, you deserve it!'

That includes the people on the other forum having a laugh at other people's ineffectiveness/effectiveness, and of course includes me and all other New Riders.

Interesting debate though, and use as many cattle prods as you like, hopefully one day everyone will get to meet one of those horses that gives you the birdie and teaches the person to think again.


Do you load 100% effectively with 100% of all horses then?
 
Do you load 100% effectively with 100% of all horses then?

Hello,

Can't say I do, but i will say its always the human - me, you, or whoever is on the end of the lead rope thats causing the problem. Its up to the person to endeavor to become part of the solution for the horse, either that or give up. I haven't given up yet.
 
I take it that those that disapprove of this loading method would not use electric fencing
 
Hello,

Can't say I do, but i will say its always the human - me, you, or whoever is on the end of the lead rope thats causing the problem. Its up to the person to endeavor to become part of the solution for the horse, either that or give up. I haven't given up yet.

I have to say i do agree with that.

I don't really see how a horse that is scared to load should be scared even more than that so that it would rather load! :eek:
 
I have to say i do agree with that.

I don't really see how a horse that is scared to load should be scared even more than that so that it would rather load! :eek:

But the OP made it clear that the pony in question was not scared....
 
I take it that those that disapprove of this loading method would not use electric fencing

The two cannot be compared.
The electric fence gives an instant 'message' which is not in the slightest bit related to the presence or otherwise of a human, and even less related to any human emotions or actions at the time the 'message' is received from the electric fence.

There are certainly many much better and less controversial methods of getting a horse to load, than the use of a cattle prod. However, very, very occasionally, desperate circumstances require desperate measures. A non-loading horse who needs to go urgently to the vet is just one circumstance where desperate measures would be perfectly justified; there are several others I can think of, too.
 
I take it that those that disapprove of this loading method would not use electric fencing

I wouldn't use a cattle prod on my horse but I do use electric fencing. I wonder if you have experienced the use of a cattle prod? We keep a large herd of cattle at home and due to kind and consistent handling they would never need to be 'encouraged' to move with a cattle prod (we don't even own one!), on the contrary we would have a rebellion if we tried! They do not tolerate harsh methods of handling and it's not funny to have 50 odd cattle making a run for it. I have seen a prod use several times at cattle markets and it looks very harsh, I have seen cattle leap off the ground bellowing, when it is used. Not nice. I once saw someone use one on a pony, she was a little mare who would regularly put her nose on the electric fence to see if it was on. If it was on she would merely shake her head a bit and wander off. If it was off she'd climb through and end up on owners lawn :) This person waited until she touched the fence and put the prod on her neck :eek: She took off like something possessed and galloped and bucked round the field for several laps, she did not come near the fence for about a week! No one could convince me that it was not a deeply unpleasant experience for her. Not like touching an electric fence at all.

I'm not 'fluffy' at all. I have a kind and well mannered pony who knows that the easiest way for him to behave is to do as he's asked. This is because he has set 'rules' and knows, full well, that if he says 'no' he still have to do it eventually so it is easier to do it straight off (most of the time :)) He has never been beaten or cruelly treated in any way, he trusts that I won't ask him to do anything he can't manage to do or that would hurt him. Also, he always gets bored of arguing before me :)
 
The person whose horse it is started a thread on NFED, its only fair they have a link to see what everyone on here thinks, i knew all to well there would be plenty of people thinking it was cruel and inhumane on this forum judging by past replies and would make for fantastic reading. I do think some, certainly not all people who post on here are IMHO 'fwuffy pwony' people, meaning they humanise their horses and think they understand them as their best mate/soul mate or whatever. I stick by that and i openly admit i do find some of those types of replies very funny and enjoy having a good giggle.

I'm not quite sure why they would need a link to this at all if you hadnt chosen to start it. If its only fair for them to see what we are writing, surely the reverse applies? Oh, but we cant can we - hmmn, sounds really fair to me:)

Personally I'm not for a cattle prod. Not least because I know my timing isnt accurate enough for it. But I do agree that sometimes a short sharp shock (although not a cattle proddy sort of shock) can be extremely effective.

My youngster had got very very above himself which culminated in him attacking my friends mare while we were hacking. He had been showing some signs of this and I had "fluffy bunnied" about mainly due to my nervousness. The straw that broke the camels back was the attack on her horse. As he finished rearing I managed to get him turned up the hill and sent him off at high speed while walloping his fat furry butt repeatedly (and roaring and using lots of nasty sweary words). The problem has never reoccured:). I think I was just lucky that day that I reacted at just the right time and had the desired result.

There you go, another bunny undone for your other forum to laugh at.

Oh, and with regard to electrocuting children, I loooove children - just couldnt eat a whole one! Could we possibly try a microwave?;)
 
How when doing something like that can you know (for an absolute fact) they aren't scared? Personally i don't think whether it was scared or not poking it with a cattle prod is something i would do... each to their own i spose.


Because he was stood with two feet on the ramp, perfectly still, just gazing around half asleep. Once in he happily munched away at a haynet like nothing has happened. Hes been in a box tonnes of times before. He is not a scared horse.
 
I'm not quite sure why they would need a link to this at all if you hadnt chosen to start it. If its only fair for them to see what we are writing, surely the reverse applies? Oh, but we cant can we - hmmn, sounds really fair to me:)


You can join the forum and will probably be accepted within 24hours and then you can read it. Its not a secret club..........although if im honest there is not really alot to read. I thin there is possibley three or four responses that relate to new rider and the rest are generally about using a cattle prod.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Because he was stood with two feet on the ramp, perfectly still, just gazing around half asleep. Once in he happily munched away at a haynet like nothing has happened. Hes been in a box tonnes of times before. He is not a scared horse.

I think that says more about the owner's loading technique than the pony.
 
Perhaps it does. Sounds like it would be well worth the owner's while to get a 'fluffy' NH trainer in to give them some tips if the horse changes its mind at any point in the future :)
 
I think its best to remember that the pony in question wasnt scared of loading or travelling. In this instance it didnt do any harm but Im certainly not advocating it as a way of normal loading!

A horse thats truly scared is another thing altogether and as a responsible horse owner (fluffy or not) its your responsibility to ensure he/she has been given the correct training to load and travel safely (laugh away knuckle draggers!)

Thanks Flump for letting us know whats behind all this. Shame some members come on here to cause trouble :rolleyes:
 
Horses don't fear a fence because they have been zapped by it, do they?
I mean they don't actually FEAR it, they just respect it enough to not quite touch it when they lean over to savage the tarpaulin covering the fresh hay.

A good sharp shock is what many children need when they're being naughty, be it a cattle prod or an electric fence I don't see the difference when a boundary is being deliberately ignored *runs & hides* ...


lol :D;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com