A loading debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter vieshot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
ETA and I did watch the video and the man got what he deserved although i don't see how it relates to loading.
I'm not sure whether the electric shock delivered by a cattle prod tetanizes the muscle so as to prevent the horse from kicking out - I wouldn't like to bet on it! In fact, it seems entirely possible that such a shock could cause a horse instinctively to send a double-barrel kick towards the source of the pain. That's one reason I think it is reckless thing to do - and that's how it relates to loading using a cattle prod.
 
In my opinion if the horse that got jabbed with a cattle prob wasn't scared just refusing to walk on then it obviouls had no respect for the people round it. And now it's probs damn scared it's guna get hurt again!
 
In my opinion if the horse that got jabbed with a cattle prob wasn't scared just refusing to walk on then it obviouls had no respect for the people round it. And now it's probs damn scared it's guna get hurt again!


I agree with Kc and no wonder the horse has no respect for it's owners, i don't think i would if i was it either, i always believe horses never forget when pain is inflicked on them by a certain person, and as the saying goes "What goes around comes around"!!!!! The owners odviusly couldn't be bothered with the time of teaching a horse/pony that trailers aren't scary things! Everything takes time with horses, and scary them into submisson really isn't the way it should be done.
 
That depends on her view of 'scared' ...

x


he stood at the bottom, two feet on the ramp, asleep, occasionally gazing dreamily into the distance. Once in he stood munching his hay as though nothing had happened. Sounds like he was one petrified pony huh?
 
i like marmite...my horses do aswell, they have it on toast every morning :D
 
Personally I would be mortified if I had to use a cattle prod, my horses are better trained and have more respect for me than to have to resort to something like that.

In the same way sticking draw reins on a horse and booting it up the arse with spurs is no compensation for proper, correct training by a capable rider. Equally, if you're having to resort to electrifying your horse (or any other brute force method for that matter) to get it to comply to your requests then I'd suggest the horse needs some basic manners taught in the first place by someone more experienced.
 
he stood at the bottom, two feet on the ramp, asleep, occasionally gazing dreamily into the distance. Once in he stood munching his hay as though nothing had happened. Sounds like he was one petrified pony huh?

Im sure there is a name for this behaviour, some sort of unattachment to what is happening in the present that the animal is fearful of,

is it called displacment???

Maybe the pony was thinking about what was happening:)

Dont you think horses should be allowed to have a think now and again?
 
Yes displacement - it's usually attributed to when an animal is torn between fight or flight. They perform habitual or comforting activitites, it's why you often see obviously stressed horses grazing, they revert to an action they find 'normal' and reassuring. My boy used to do it out hacking, something would scare him and he would freeze, he would look calm as anything to passers by but he was actually frozen in a kind of mental shut-down because he couldn't mentally cope with the situation.
 
yes thats right, he couldnt mentally cope with the situation. Once forced in he had to stuff his face with hay to try and get himself to relax because of the extreme stress he was under. Yeah that must be it. It couldnt possibly be that he was being a monkey and trying it on because a trailer becomes soooo scary when you have already been in it hundreds of times before.......................:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
I was merely explaining what displacement is as Kirby asked about it. I never claimed it had any relevance to your situation which, in all honesty, I hadn't wasted my time thinking about since by your own admission you're not actually interested in any ideas outside of your own limited thinking. Really, don't worry yourself, I couldn't care less about what your friend does with their pony and I wish both the pony and it's owner the best of luck. It certainly sounds like they may need it :)
 
I was merely explaining what displacement is as Kirby asked about it. I never claimed it had any relevance to your situation which, in all honesty, I hadn't wasted my time thinking about since by your own admission you're not actually interested in any ideas outside of your own limited thinking. Really, don't worry yourself, I couldn't care less about what your friend does with their pony and I wish both the pony and it's owner the best of luck. It certainly sounds like they may need it :)

Sure i am, but i am sure the owner knows her pony well enough to know if he is scared or not so i see no need for anyone to question her ability to understand him.
 
...Really, don't worry yourself, I couldn't care less about what your friend does with their pony and I wish both the pony and it's owner the best of luck. It certainly sounds like they may need it :)

Ha ha, the horse def needs help, and the owner I think needs a different form of help.... I am sure the owner wouldn't want an electric cattle prod used on her if she merely couldn't be bothered to do something! I agree with angelofben. I couldn't care less. But when people question your friends’ ability with her horse, don't jump down peoples throats, I think you knew people would not be happy about what you posted... hence the ending of the title 'debate'. Everyone is very much entitled to their own opinion!
 
Personally I would be mortified if I had to use a cattle prod, my horses are better trained and have more respect for me than to have to resort to something like that.

In the same way sticking draw reins on a horse and booting it up the arse with spurs is no compensation for proper, correct training by a capable rider. Equally, if you're having to resort to electrifying your horse (or any other brute force method for that matter) to get it to comply to your requests then I'd suggest the horse needs some basic manners taught in the first place by someone more experienced.

That is a very generalised comment, its not always down to the horses manners & training. My horse is perfectly mannered & well trained, in fact you couldn't have an easier horse to handle on a day to day basis. I can also assure you that his reluctance to load is not fear related. In fact parelli lady some time ago was more than happy to agree with this.

Each situation is different, as is each horse & handler.
But then when my horse went through a stage of rearing & twisting I also didn't have a problem with sticking some draw reins on to prevent him from getting so high...or I could have let him get on with it & let him go so high he fell over backwards on me...
 
I don't think angelfben meant draw reins used in that context - rather the use of them to force a false outline. That's how I read it anyway.

vieshot, I wonder about your motive in posting this thread since you are absolutely adamant about your opinion on it and have actually failed to debate it at all.

Closing this now as I think it has reached a natural end and is degenerating into personal slights.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com