And The Strangles Saga Continues....

KP nut

I'd rather be riding.
Dec 22, 2008
6,539
5,379
113
So having got my horses through strangles, having got clear scopes, I brought them back onto the yard. Which was - allegedly - clear. And now there are 2 new cases. Ones my horses had direct contact with. Arrrrgggghhhh. My vet has recommended I get my horses off there asap as their immunity won't last forever. I can't go straight from here to anywhere else where horses are, but I have found a friendly farmer with a field on private land in the middle of nowhere. AND he has a field shelter used years ago by his now grown-up kids' ponies. So they are going there today. And moving onto a new yard in 3 weeks. Vet has had lengthy discussions with me and the new yard owner about the transfer and the 3 week isolation plan isn't really necessary as my horses are very low risk (far more so than random horses you might meet out and about) but this is necessary to reduce everyone's anxiety. Especially mine as frankly if I was blamed for another outbreak it would finish me off! Even if it wasn't actually me!! My vet reckons there are carriers on the yard and Amber probably DIDN'T bring it with her as if she was a carrier that would have appeared on the scope. Either she got strangles just before leaving her yard, or in transit (though she was travelled alone) or she got it from the yard after arrival. She was not in isolation at the dealer's yard but was with another very expensive horse for sale. So if they had cases up there and she was exposed I'd have thought they would have kept her by herself. Their livelihood depends on it really, as @Bodshi said when I was ranting about the bl00dy dealer selling me a sick horse after selling me a 3 legged one!

Vet said new horses are always blamed for outbreaks on yards but so often when YOs finally get a proper screening plan together they find horses who have had it for YEARS who have never been ill. They found an elderly shetland recently with FIFTY chondroids (hardened pus pockets in the guttural pouch) who had not left the yard for about 15 years and had never been ill!

Anyway I have a plan....., Only downside is said field is an hour from home!! But still it is only 3 weeks.

Thanks for all the advice on the other thread. I know you all said stay and I do take your lovely advice on-board. But actually these new cases are the final straw. Especially as it involves horses who were initially exposed back in January but then never got blood tested to make sure they were safe. So it was totally preventable and totally predictable and I am frankly furious! So I need to go a) to protect my horses, b) for my sanity and c) to preserve friendships as I know all the owners from pony club and school too and don't want to fall out with anyone over this even though I am hopping mad.
 
Yeah I can totally see why you are going at this point, the threat of another possible outbreak is very different to an actual outbreak. It's very annoying given it was totally preventable, this disease could probably be totally eradicated if more people attacked it the way you did when the first symptoms appeared AND yards made everyone follow through.
 
Yeah I can totally see why you are going at this point, the threat of another possible outbreak is very different to an actual outbreak. It's very annoying given it was totally preventable, this disease could probably be totally eradicated if more people attacked it the way you did when the first symptoms appeared AND yards made everyone follow through.

Yes I agree with the completely. But unfortunately this would lead to some horses being put to sleep to prevent the carriers passing it on. The guttural pouch flush doesn't always work and the alternative is then surgery which is risky and expensive. I do understand that some horse owners would rather not know. Out of interest I wonder how many NR horses have had a blood test for strangles? If I hadn't been forced to by my yard, I would never have thought to have one done, and I would never have known that Ben was a carrier. He could have given it to my whole yard and could well have been responsible for a previous outbreak on his old yard.

@KP nut - good luck on the moves. What is your new yard like? It is a shame that you have to move but you are doing the right thing for you. x
 
I haven't done mine admittedly, mostly because its not commonly tested for and the exposure risks are so high, so knowing they are clear today wouldn't help much in a week/month/year. If I had a hint of concern or any known exposure I wouldn't hesitate to test though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
I guess the issue is that you don't know what your horse may have been exposed to before you got them? Not speaking about your horses here @Jessey , just talking generally. Carriers can often never show any symptoms at all so they are impossible to identify without a blood test.

I am always struck with how careless some people are at shows. I was at one in-hand horse agility show on a boiling hot day a few years ago. There was a water trough on the yard and I saw several (at least 5) people allow and encourage their horses to drink from it. I take my horse out lots and am obsessive about making sure that he doesn't touch anything, anyone or any other horses. I don't allow other people to feed him treats and he only drinks out of his own water bucket.

Strangles is not air-born, the horse has to come into direct contact with an infected horse, person or area. You therefore can significantly reduce the risks of exposure by being very careful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KP nut and Jessey
I have known a friends horse catch strangles from transport, he tested clear at vetting and came down with it after arrival, the only thing they could come up with was the previous horse in the lorry must have had it and spread it inside. Its so easily spread, but as you say the treat can be easily minimised too.
 
I used to be in the rather-not-know camp too but in this case horses who had direct contact with a confirmed case were not tested or isolated which is crazy. That's the problem. I accept it can happen anywhere, the question is what is the response when it does. With strict isolation and vigilance it can be quite easy to contain but it just hasn't been addressed here. And people are still saying they are refusing to test theirs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
Mine have both been tested for strangles (and given the all-clear). Roxy has been tested twice now. Angel came from KP Nut's yard - she was neither a carrier or infected, not that that means anything as I got her in October and the outbreak at KP Nut's yard was more recent.

It sounds like there's a carrier on your yard that's NOT one of yours, KP Nut. I wondered at the time why everyone was so sure that Amber was responsible. I'd say it was more likely that a dealer WOULDN'T keep, let alone sell on, a horse with strangles.
 
I have known a friends horse catch strangles from transport, he tested clear at vetting and came down with it after arrival, the only thing they could come up with was the previous horse in the lorry must have had it and spread it inside. Its so easily spread, but as you say the treat can be easily minimised too.

Yes, it can be spread from fences and stables as well - any surface that the horse has touched.

Although perhaps I have not been so careful as I thought I had, because I have previously transported a couple of friends horses in my lorry and have not disinfected afterwards. Ben was not in there at the time, but I did use the lorry the next day. Something for me to think about in future.

I am also going to camp in a few weeks (SO EXCITED) and will be renting a stable for 2 nights. How do I know the previous horse who used it did not have strangles?

In reality, Ben is probably immune for life because of his previous exposure, but while he is unlikely to get it and show symptoms, can he be re-infected as a carrier from any new exposure? @KP nut - do you know this?
 
I used to be in the rather-not-know camp too but in this case horses who had direct contact with a confirmed case were not tested or isolated which is crazy. That's the problem. I accept it can happen anywhere, the question is what is the response when it does. With strict isolation and vigilance it can be quite easy to contain but it just hasn't been addressed here. And people are still saying they are refusing to test theirs.

I can't imagine why an owner wouldn't immediately put their horse in isolation if they know it had been in direct contact with a horse who had strangles? Surely this is the responsibility of the yard owner to enforce?
 
Hope everything goes okay for the next three weeks in the field - lots of vibes for it working okay for you. As you say its only for a short while. I read your other thread and also said stay, but it really does look like you have no option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skib
Yeah, I can also see your point in leaving now. Looks like strangles will just bounce around and around until ALL the horses have been tested and treated accordingly.
 
My boys where tested but actually to me that result means nothing now as Ginger and I out out most weekends and stay at different yards all round the country. We can't get a blood test every month!!!

There is really no answer.

I feel for you. I read the original thread and did think that the dealer would not sell a sick horse plus he had that horse a quite a while if she had been sick he would of seen it and dealt with it as this would kill his business.
 
Unfortunately you cannot escape strangles, it is just part and parcel of being a horse owner. The last thing we want is it being made a notifiable disease. Then we would see the government swinging into action which with a large enough outbreak means culling. After foot and mouth the last thing I want is to see is horse pyres.

Kia would probably pop a positive reaction on a test, he's 26 after all and been here there and everywhere, don't see the point in worrying about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii
I can't imagine why an owner wouldn't immediately put their horse in isolation if they know it had been in direct contact with a horse who had strangles? Surely this is the responsibility of the yard owner to enforce?
I borrowed a trailer for the New Years Day parade, I got a can of Dettol spray and doused it before and after use, its obviously not a 100% approach but disinfecting felt like the sensible thing as I didn't know the owner personally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
I can't imagine why an owner wouldn't immediately put their horse in isolation if they know it had been in direct contact with a horse who had strangles? Surely this is the responsibility of the yard owner to enforce?

The YO has been operating there for 35 years and over that time the understanding of an management of strangles has totally changed. She is very old-school. Very 'well they all get it at some point'. There are a lot of liveries there who have been there 20+years and never leave the yard anyway anymore. Horses who are companions etc. These owners think testing is unnecessary. There is no benefit individually for them. Their horses aren't ill and they aren't being restricted from competing, travelling to clinics etc as they don't do that anyway. In fact they are saying it's the people that go out and about who are the problem, not them even though for all we know one of their horses is a carrier and the source of the infection.

But in my view it is about proportionate, sensible risk. You can't reduce the risk to zero, but the small possibility of your horse contracting it out and about pales into insignificance compared to the huge risk of your horse getting it when it has shared a field/water trough/hay pile with an ill horse. So the YO needs to make testing mandatory and hopefully she will now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GaryB and Jessey
What is your new yard like? It is a shame that you have to move but you are doing the right thing for you. x

It's lovely but I can't really afford it..... It has large indoor and outdoor schools, nice big stables, year round turn out on decent grazing. A large storage area for feed/kit etc for each livery. Trailer parking. Locked tack room. Horse wash bays. Large brew room. Assisted livery and holiday livery available very flexibly. YO onsite. External trainers welcome to teach there. I can carry on EAT there. My 3 would be in their own barn and paddocks so I could manage their turn out to suit. A local pony club and a local BRC often have events there so there is a lot going on. And great hacking straight off the yard. 9 minutes drive from home when I went to view. So it seems great.

Problems:

1) No-one wants me there as I come from a strangles yard but hopefully everyone will get over it and calm down once I am actually there.
2) It is very expensive!!! So need to either earn more or find savings elsewhere.....
 
Can see why your going now although I was another that said stay on your other thread.
New yard sounds good, hope it all goes to plan. At least the clocks will have changed by the time you move.
 
Hopping mad probably wouldn't cover it for me.
If mine had been in direct contact she would have been tested. I just can't see why you wouldn't. Then treat accordingly.

I can see the you can't escape it, but actually you can if horses were tested on arrival to a new yard and kept in isolation until then?

The owner being old school means nothing, the vet with a back bone is required here.
On my yard mine went unwell. She was the second horse to go unwell. The vet actually had words and the yard was locked down.
The other horse died. That's scary knowing the other didn't make it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
'Old school' was the wrong term to use. Sorry it is - on reflection - a totally inappropriate and quite judgemental phrase! I meant she is very stuck in her ways and is very casual about this kind of thing. The whole family have been working with horses forever and they are all like that but I can see that this has nothing to do with their years of experience and is just the way they are.
 
newrider.com