Catching problems (again!!)

If it were me and this was becoming a constant then he'd be going into a smaller paddock.

I don't agree with this. He isn't that extreme in that you can't catch him full stop, he is just difficult sometimes. I have always been able to apart from the last 2 days. And even if he was persistently difficult I would not want to take him away from the security and friendship he has found within his herd. They are a very happy group and they have excellent grazing (20 acres) and this is what I want for him. We will get through this, if he keeps being difficult to catch I will have to exhaust every single possibility before I remove him from the field. I have read about 100 different approaches and opinions over the last few days and if he gets worse instead of better I will just have to take the time to work through the options and find one that works. His happiness and well being is the most important thing to me, and having him in a small isolated paddock all alone is the absolute last resort for me.
 
Mine sometimes comes to call and a whistle.

To call mine in- mostly for feeding time if they are nowhere to be seen. I use a bell.It is really interesting to ring the bell and hear the "whinny" so I know they have heard it and then
see the thundering hooves coming over the top of the hill. If they are in sight I just call.
What is so interesting about the bell is to me it really does not sound any different from one of the bells the Train rings on the way into and out of the station.
I guess they are totally in tune to my bell is coming from one direction and the train station is across the street so that bell is coming from a different direction.

It never fails to make me smile when I use it!:D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers and Ruskii
I don't agree with this. He isn't that extreme in that you can't catch him full stop, he is just difficult sometimes. I have always been able to apart from the last 2 days. And even if he was persistently difficult I would not want to take him away from the security and friendship he has found within his herd. They are a very happy group and they have excellent grazing (20 acres) and this is what I want for him. We will get through this, if he keeps being difficult to catch I will have to exhaust every single possibility before I remove him from the field. I have read about 100 different approaches and opinions over the last few days and if he gets worse instead of better I will just have to take the time to work through the options and find one that works. His happiness and well being is the most important thing to me, and having him in a small isolated paddock all alone is the absolute last resort for me.

You can't have it all ways. You either want him brought in to get him off the grass or you want him kept in the herd in a massive field where catching him is difficult for anyone but you, even then he is being funny.

I never said have him a small paddock isolated either, I said put him in a smaller paddock and I never mentioned alone.
 
My mate used to run in quite a large herd, over 4 huge open fields, I used to have a big issue in catching her, she wouldn't let me anywhere near, if I reached out she would spin and run Sometimes it would take me 2 hours, I started by teaching her to catch herself, In her stable I would hold the head collar in front of her nose and say 'put your nose in' out of curiosity she would sniff it I then gave her a treat, I did this until I was confident that when I asked she would put her nose in, I then would put her in arena on a long lead line stand away from her hold out my hand and repeat put your nose in, she eventually walked up to me when ever I stood in that position, I then did it with out lead rope, but do not move from your spot it takes a lot of patience, but once she got in the mind frame of coming to me it was a lot easier, I then took head collar off and continued to stand hold out my hand and ask put your nose in, she was at the point of thinking oh if I go over there there's a treat in that hand (even no there was times there wasn't it got her to be curious enough to look) overt time she approached Id hang the collar just in front of her nose and when she put it in she then got the treat, I had now made myself approchable, when I go into the field I walk towards her until she looks up, I stand in the same position with my hand out, Nd call, she will now walk over to me I put head collar I front of her nose and ask her to put it in, I will not reach out to touch her, I will not follow her if she moves away I simply stand still until she does, this took a good 2 months of trial & error but it worked for me, I do alway give her 1 treat for putting her nose in & 1 treat after leaving the gate oh and she doesn't get any treats until then head collar is on, no matter what paddy she has thrown before hand, I now have a horse that will walk towards me as soon as I enter the field, oh ive recently just done the same with a friends horse who refused to get caught too and it worked on him too
 
Today he was perfect once more. I went into the field, stood 10 metres away from him and ate a polo. He came up to me begging to be caught!

I am hoping that this is just a blip with me catching him but I expect that he will still run away from the yard staff. I have learned lots over the last few days and will certainly never again take catching a horse for granted.
 
You taught him a good lesson. That's great. He may well try it on with you again, but dont take it personally. All horses sort of test and retest - but at the same time they remember. Just you remember to get out your fierce self if it is needed - You wont need to go so crazy with him next time, as the horses that know us do remember very well. Just as they remember herd members. Just they try and test the situation as horses get old or injured and lose their place in the hierarchy.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
Yesterday I lost my temper with cally for planting and today she allowed me to sit next to her while she was lying down then fell asleep as I stroked her. So she clearly does not either fear or resent me. Maybe getting fierce once in a while is actually reassuring for them?
 
How often do you go in there to get him while eating a "polo".What is a polo-I assume its a cookie or something?
If going in eating one works consistantly -with you just eating it and his "treat tooth" gets the best of
him and he comes to you on his own - I don't see much harm in doing that.
 
How often do you go in there to get him while eating a "polo".What is a polo-I assume its a cookie or something?
If going in eating one works consistantly -with you just eating it and his "treat tooth" gets the best of
him and he comes to you on his own - I don't see much harm in doing that.

Polo mints - they are small white sweets with a hole in the middle. Horses love 'em!
 
newrider.com