Laceyfreckle,
There is some often referred to video of pat parelli showing his float loading techniques on an Aussie lifestyle program. After many attempts that got more and more 'energetic', they cut to the host and he explains that the horse needed some 'training' that would take some time, so we will now take up the float loading after the training. pat asked the horse to enter the float and it did.....it looked magical to the average viewer, but any horse person could see that the trembling, sweat soaked horse would have backed up the truck, attached the float and driven home rather than even look at Pat.
Does the result justify the technique ?, in this case we will never know.
We can really only comment from our experiences in NH here in OZ, but we were interested from the very first visit by Pat Parelli & Monty Roberts so we have seen huge changes over the years.
It is impressive for a young horse to tolerate chainsaws, stock whips, hand guns and snow blowers after just an hours work, but does it produce a horse that can be handled the next day?
have a look at the 2nd & 3rd whisper challenges, Clinton Anderson floods the horses, chokes one with the Jeffery 'magic rope' and ends up with a horse that could only be ridden by someone with CA's riding/rodeo ability, then look at the calm horse Josh Lyons finished with...
As for the showman stunts performed by CA while other trainers were trying to work with their horses...this was inconsiderate and/or bad sportsmanship, especially when CA talked about kangaroo shooting from horseback, despite what may be commonly thought, all kangaroos in Australia are fully protected by the relevant Wildlife Acts in each state and has penalities of up to $100,000 and 10 years in jail for the illegal killing of kangaroos.
Still raving on...sorry about that.
We are no experts, far from it, but we work to teach our horses to give desired responses to specific cues, calmly and thoughtfully as we do not want reactive horses.
The best way to end up with a non reactive horse is not to teach it to react by flooding, force or pain.