N
NZhorserider
Guest
I know this is a thread for those who generally like and practice Natural Horsemanship, but I have a few problems with it.
We have a 15hh chestnut arabian mare at Kishon who we brought from another stud. We were told that she's done natural horsemanship. At first, it didn't really raise any immediate issues wit me. I'd heard of how people love natural horsemaship, so I thought it must be alright.
Now I know there are different types and levels of natural horsemanship that can be applied. Please note that I'm not trying to offend any people who do use this
Now, this horse, Crystal, has major issues with natural horsemanship.
She has been taught to move away from pressure. I think this is the 'porcupine' game, where there are different levels of pressure applied to get the horse to move away.
We only have to lightly touch her, and she shoots off in the opposite direction to get away from the pressure! Can you imagine how hard it is to saddle her up!!!!!
Then, we had the horse dentist out. Being educated to natural horsemanship, she thinks that if she on a leadrope, that she should move to the end of it. She made it so difficult for the dentist, who is against natural horsemanship, to do her teeth when she was bolting backwards the whole time.
How can we punish a horse who thinks this is the thing she is being asked to do? I personally think that it would confuse the hell out of her.
I spent ages this morning trying to brush her, saddle her and mount her. I can't mount her by myself because the slightest pressure felt and she moves away.
I myself can't make any sense of natural horsemanship! If a horse is trained to move away from pressure, how are you meant to do any ground work with them? How are you meant to lead them if they think that they should be moving away from a leadrope?
I heard that many of the natural horsemanship people don't actually ride......... no wonder!!
I'm very sorry if I've offended anyone, this is just my very confused view. All I know is that we have a ruined horse who we struggle to do easy tasks with.
I would appreciate other peoples' views on this.
GRACE
We have a 15hh chestnut arabian mare at Kishon who we brought from another stud. We were told that she's done natural horsemanship. At first, it didn't really raise any immediate issues wit me. I'd heard of how people love natural horsemaship, so I thought it must be alright.
Now I know there are different types and levels of natural horsemanship that can be applied. Please note that I'm not trying to offend any people who do use this
Now, this horse, Crystal, has major issues with natural horsemanship.
She has been taught to move away from pressure. I think this is the 'porcupine' game, where there are different levels of pressure applied to get the horse to move away.
We only have to lightly touch her, and she shoots off in the opposite direction to get away from the pressure! Can you imagine how hard it is to saddle her up!!!!!
Then, we had the horse dentist out. Being educated to natural horsemanship, she thinks that if she on a leadrope, that she should move to the end of it. She made it so difficult for the dentist, who is against natural horsemanship, to do her teeth when she was bolting backwards the whole time.
How can we punish a horse who thinks this is the thing she is being asked to do? I personally think that it would confuse the hell out of her.
I spent ages this morning trying to brush her, saddle her and mount her. I can't mount her by myself because the slightest pressure felt and she moves away.
I myself can't make any sense of natural horsemanship! If a horse is trained to move away from pressure, how are you meant to do any ground work with them? How are you meant to lead them if they think that they should be moving away from a leadrope?
I heard that many of the natural horsemanship people don't actually ride......... no wonder!!
I'm very sorry if I've offended anyone, this is just my very confused view. All I know is that we have a ruined horse who we struggle to do easy tasks with.
I would appreciate other peoples' views on this.
GRACE