Hi Pirat, it may sound kind of funny, but I'll try to explain a little. I'd first like to state that I am not trying to convince you, I don't really care what you do (as long as you don't hurt your horse) to get him to do what you want. We’re all horse people here and we all do our thing differently, with hopefully the same result, an obedient horse!
Sometimes telling the horse something in a language it understands can make what you want more clear. You are very right in the problem with the pecking order, horses have something called linear dominance, which means there isn't just one leader and everyone obeys him. They each have a direct line from the leader to the second in command all the way down to the last horse. Having to argue and establish that isn't easy, nor is it something you can win because the horse outweighs you by quite a lot.
Fortunately for us humans, we are smarter then horses, and so if we choose we can speak their language, and if we don't choose they'll have to learn ours.
Most horses (yours could be different, I don’t know) don’t like to fight. They don’t like to hurt each other, because that will mean that they’d probably get hurt too. In the wild, an injury isn’t just something painful that you’ll have to put up for a couple of days, it’s a death penalty.
Instead they settle arguments by displays, pinning ears, squealing, pawing the ground, phantom kicks etc. only about 10% (or less, its in my equine science course somewhere but I don't feel like digging it up) actually become real fights. Since I've seen some of those "real" fights, I completely understand your unwillingness to start one

I wouldn't either!!!
In join up, the theory is if the foal gets too full of himself, sometimes one of the leaders will teach them a lesson. They will say “I don’t think you are really a horse. If you were a horse you wouldn’t act like this. You’d be good and quit challenging people for their well established roles. If you don’t think I’m the leader, then we’ll see what the wolves think about that.”
Then he or she will face that horse, pin its ears and drive him out of the herd. S/he will keep him out of the herd and won’t let him back. That is a serious threat, with out a herd a horse is finished. Eventually he’ll start giving signs that he doesn’t want to be bad anymore. He’ll lower his head and start making chewing motions, or lick his lips. This is trying to say “Hey, I eat grass just like the rest of you people!” He’s apologizing for his wrong doings, and if his ear is locked on you, he’s telling you that he respects you.
Since you are a horseman, I’m sure you know the values of respect. This is just an option on how to go about it. Its not magical or gypsy talk, its just taking advantage of something a horse recognizes and using it.
When your horse is willing to work for you, its just plain easier. He learns quicker, you don’t have as many fights, etc.
I personally don’t use the round pen for anything more then a class room. I already have Mears respect so I don’t do join up for her. Running in endless circles is not going to help her learn now that she’s past it. A lot of people I’ve noticed seem to feel that running a horse in a round pen is the answer to ALL problems. I’ve seen people rip their horses away from a farrier when the horse is misbehaving to take it directly into the round pen and run it for misbehaving, as if its going to understand and connect the two. Horses don’t work that way, and you know that as well as I do. I think that might be one of your sources of frustration.
An example not involving a round pen is this: Suppose that your horse decides to cross the line and do something he wouldn’t normally do, like give you a nip or step away from you. If you wait five minutes and then go “Bad girl for moving away five minutes ago!” The horse has no clue. If you correct immediately by a sharp reprimand etc. then you’ve done something the horse understands.
A horse in the wild would never even consider waiting to kick a horse that bit him 5 minutes ago. He would react immediately. This is horse language in a minor sense.
I hope that helped and I was a little more clear about what we mean. I know it all sounds like fancy talk, but as far as me and my horse, its worked so far. At least the bits we follow. I haven't done any of the Parelli stuff. Too complicated!
