help with hand position.

iloveshearer said:
Depends how you're pushing your trolley :p you could push it holding onto the side bits :p :D

i dont know if you mean what i'm thinking but the whole image of that in my head is totally hilarious..its been a long day.

sorry o/t i know.
xx
 
I've always been told thumbs up about 4 inches apart for english riding, for western I've always ridden one handed on the trails unless I need two hands for steering as Mister has not learned to neck rein completely..... and watch their ears for them listening to you.
 
I was just thinking noone had explained why. It is because there is suposed to be give and take in the riders hands.

The contact should be firm but have a spongy give to it not a fixed rigid hand position. I find this is the hardest part to explain to beginners when I'm teaching. Usually when you say to have a firm contact (then I show the by holding the other end of the reins) but soft hands they throw away their contact. But the reins ideally should never loop (go slack).

The actual reason for the thumbs on top rule is it allows our hands to give. It is due to the way our arms are constructed- the bones inside. If you have your knuckles on top you cant be soft. Ever seen a dressage horse going correctly on the bit and the rider has their knuckles on top?? I havent.
 
A previous instructor of mine broke her thumbs because she did not have the correct hand position when she was going over a jump. I can't remember the exact story because she told me this like six or seven years ago when I was still relatively new to riding.
 
Also, if you ever need to react quicky, having your thumbs on top allows you arm to bend upwards at the elbow MUCH quicker. Go ahead and try it, Thumbs up, and bend your elbow quick, now knuckles up and do the same. With me, its much faster and easier with my thumb on top.. perfect for having to shorten reins quickly if i let them slack, or pulling up horse when i get cut off in the riding ring by a 8 year old on a bucking pony, and perfect for sponging the reins and maintaining soft contact.
 
Just like Vimto & her book:
Here is an exerpt from Equine Canada's old rider level 1 booklet, which happens to be how I was introduced to english riding (before dressage):

"The reins are held in the palm of the hand by closing the thumb & index finger, not by gripping with the other fingers. The hands should be slightly inclined (approximatly 30 degrees) with the thumbs up & the ends of the reins passing through the hands up to the thumbs. The reins may be held under the little finger or may pass between the little finger & the ring finger. The latter is preferable as it gives a better hold on the reins."

I was introduced to having the hands more upright when dressage came into play.

So both these hand positions are correct but your friend's "piano" hands or "flat hands" are definitly not because they cause ineffective arms & the elbows point out.

To fix this, EC suggest to "Keep thumbs pointing towards horse's ears" and if you carry a whip/stick: "Keep stick resting on the middle of the thigh."
 
vimto92 said:
Well I have a book, right.:)

It says alternate hands should point to alternate ears, which I think is much neater and tidier... but thats my opinion. Is this the wrong way?:o
i read that too..was it sally swift?

made sense to me anyway, means your wrist doesn't lock, but stays round and soft
 
I found it easier to understand by instead of thinking that rien contact is between my hand and the horse's mouth, the contact begins at my shoulders, through my elbows, wrists and then my hands.

My chest should be open, and my arms should fall relaxed from my shoulders, I want a fluent contact that falls from my shoulders, through my elbow and wrist to the horses mouth.

Now if you sit and imagine you're holding you're riens with your thumbs up, you'll see that your contact is easily held between your thumb and pointer finger and the flow of contact is fluent between your elbow,wrist and hand.

But if you turn your thumbs in over you should see that you have blocked the flow from your upper arm and only have a contact between your hand and the horses mouth.

If you pretend your thumbs are gas taps, thumbs on top allow the gas to flow, thumbs together stops the flow and creates one pipe line between your hands and the horses mouth, which is restrictive to the rider and hard for the horse to decipher.
 
teabiscuit said:
i read that too..was it sally swift?

made sense to me anyway, means your wrist doesn't lock, but stays round and soft

Nope, Margaret Hickman, book called "Learning to Ride", 1973.;) My grandad passed it down to me.:)
 
Thanks everyone who replied to my interruption!:p

I just feel more softer and neater doing it that way.... instructer likes thumbs on top though...... :(
 
newrider.com