i would also recommend g2's. i have a pair on dawn. she has 5.5inch wide feet if i remember correctly - i'm sure she's in size 4's but would have to check... i used a vernier scale to mearsure
and it was the biggest the scale would go
you say you have good quality horse but not much growth - i had this problem with dawn so turned to shoes (year 2006) but had to give up on them as her feet weren't keeping up with how often the shoes needed changing
so bought boots and her feet grew more once the shoes were off and then they stopped growing again
this year my farrier (different to year 2006 farrier) recommended i use seaweed as a supplement and there has definately been more hoof growth and its not weakened the horn etc, there's just more of it. may be worth a try.
you say you have good quality horse but not much growth - i had this problem with dawn so turned to shoes (year 2006) but had to give up on them as her feet weren't keeping up with how often the shoes needed changing