HELP

There is something odd about the way the problem is presented. That the OP would not ask a professional trainer to ride a horse that he or she would not. I have been to many trainer demos over the years and it is clear that no good trainer ever gets on a horse until he has worked with the horse and is satisfied that it is ready to carry a rider safely. It is ground work first, and then very often for safety sake a dummy fabric rider.
Plus there is time scale. Maxwell was gifted a horse which he said took a whole year of ground work before he even considered riding.
Then you post that there is a history of problems with this horse and they have been overcome. But what the problems were and how they have been overcome (if indeed they have, since this sounds like escalation) is massively relevant to the horse using increased resistance.
You post that professionals you know as trainers cannot help you. But one thing I did learn from this forum is that there are many schools of thought on horse training. And professionals may disagree quite strongly. Your friends may well be hostile to other schools of thought, but it might be worth your going outside the comfort zone of their expertise and getting a further couple of opinions from trainers with a different approach. Michael Peace as KP suggests or Maxwell - but there are others.

But before approaching anyone I would suggest you list the reasons you like this horse so much.
And what you want to do with him in future?
I have noticed that some people always select difficult horses because it endorses their status as a rider. It is a perverse thing about riding skills that they only become evident at moments of failure. I am praised at moments when I have dealt with a problem. But I know that with better riding I should have anticipated and prevented the problem. It shouldnt have happened in the first place. The best riding on a nicely trained horse doesnt look hard -
However, if getting recognition for your riding skills involves competing at high levels, that demands more athleticism from the horse and possibly more pressure on the animal. But you need to explain to a trainer what you would like of this horse

Michael Peace's attitude is that both people and horses have to earn their keep. This Forum tends to favour behaviourist and gentle approaches. If you want more conventional UK expertise you could ask the same question on the Horse and Hound Forum.

No one on a forum can tell you that your task is possible, but equally (from what you posted) you havent yet got to the end of the road, either in medical checks or specialist training.
 
Omg really fokes I came on here open minded to ask for help because iam at the point where I don't no were to go!! no the trainers around here aren't great don't live in the best area for that also I don't have a load of money but what I do have has always gone on him I've make sure he has the best dentist who is a beva dentist the lady who does his back every six months or more if he doesn't feel right is also registered!!! He has had his tack checked I bought him a micklem bridle which did help for a bit I've never ever beaten a horse into what I want I've worked with them helped them and spent many years sorting out problems out of my own pocket so don't bash me I came on here asking for help!!! I work through all his issues with patience nothing more he is a big horse I never bought him to make my self look good or to make me look great fell for the horse and could see through his rude and agrassive behaviour and I dealt with his issues and he is now perfect to handle load clippers shoe etc he no longer lashes out when u walk past I've always had an issue with napping but I deal with it but he has upped his game and I simply came on here to see if someone might have a idea of how to help me because all iam getting is shoot him but I now no I made a mistake by asking for advice on here just full of nasty women who like to belittle people I've never in my years no make how silly the question every make someone feel like crap when genuinely asking for help!!! And yes my sense of humour is not to everyones taste but you no what I love the bloody thing and it's killing me coz I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO so thanks for your bitchy comments nut think I will go else were for advice
 
I don't think we are trying to belittle you. There are some forums like that, but not this one.

You sound panicky, as if you're saying everything all in one breath, and shouting, too. You seem really distressed by what is going on with your horse. It sounds as though you've dealt with a lot of his problems in the past but help us out here, we have to understand to help you.

The problem is his napping. Please tell us when it is at its worst - what's happening? What does he do, what do you do? And what have you tried to deal with it?

He's your horse, you can call him a knob all you like in my book! Give us a chance to help you think about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bigbayknob
Iam really really upset I've never had a horse I can't work with and I do love him with all my heart but in a minute someone is going to get hurt and just thought asking someone might just suggest something simply!!! Last time it got bad I would jump of and lead him have a lunge line attached to him and lead him for a bit but he won't let me do that he just goes and I really can't stop him my hands are shredded!! In the past I've sat a waited for hrs spin him 3 times then off let him run back wards into a ditch scaring himself I've growled given him a smack but it's all stopped working he does it every so often no real time of the yr doesn't even affect the time of the yr pr work he is doing anyone who has had anything to do with him has said he is a cheeky bugger give him an inch he will take a mile!!
 
I don;t think anyone is wanting to belittle you. And actually you are being given advice: you just don;t think any of it is helpful but people are trying to help. You seem to think a trainer will just jump on and sort him out. Whereas as @Skib says you need a trainer to actually understand why the horse is behaving the way he does. Sure, you can call your horse a Knob if you like. I've called mine worse from time to time.,... But in the thread you also say he is BEING a knob when he behaves dangerously. Whereas @chev and others have been saying that his behaviour is communication and you aren't hearing him. His ultimate 'communication' is to withdraw his consent from being ridden, handled etc. And once a horse has done that he is very dangerous. As you have discovered he can run home, jumping anything in his way, or he can rear and go over or he can throw himself on the floor. Any of those could kill you. No-one apart from a skilled trainer working directly with the horse can work out why he has withdrawn consent: possibly he's in pain and will get you off his back whatever it takes. Maybe he is afraid and feels the need to defend himself. Or maybe he resents you. That is not to say you've mistreated him but horses will have an opinion about their handling or their ridden work whether we like it or not and some are far less tolerant and will reach 'NO!' far sooner than others.
 
Coz right now I would rather call him a knob than dangerous coz I no that is what he is but right now I want to fix this rather than put scary words like dangerous!! I've never ever bullied this horse ever he is always great in the school field etc he follows me around like a dog I lay on him in the field he adores my little girl does that really sound like I mistreat him does it!!??
 
When I hack I would also like to say this horse is 100% in traffic etc I am a real believe reward is worth a million smacks with the stick I have always allowed my horses to look Explorer and touch where possible always praised them I always start with a pat lose rein never ever have any of my horses been pushed out of thier comfort zone to be scared or so I can be oh masterful! Every animal I owed is because they have issues and I've worked with them and had loads of fun
 
Well just like to say thank to those that have genuinely been kind but iam not going to be told my horse resents me etc when you don't no me or the work I've put into these amazing animals when so many had been giving up on I also keep on touch with most of the owners to but that must be coz iam so a nasty person oh well I will hopefully find some people that have an understanding of what Iam saying my horse has the best of the best!!
 
All your replies just confirm the very first bit of advice: Without knowing you or the horse or seeing see the behavior or the context, no-one can say anything useful. Your horse won't let you ride, is aggressive in the field so can't be a companion, is too dangerous for trainers to ride and your friends are telling you to shoot him! Sounds pretty extreme to me so the idea that a 'simple suggestion' might sort this out is unrealistic. Some horses resent being ridden or being made to leave the yard/their friends however well they are treated. Some horses are in pain without it being obvious where it is coming from. Some horses are fearful even if they have never been harmed. I made it clear that I was not saying you mistreated him but that horses have opinions on what they are asked to do. Pain, fear or resentment are common reasons for horses becoming aggressive or evasive. They were simply suggestions as to what might be going on as you are out of ideas and were asking for some. But the only advice really is get a trainer out to help you understand the root causes of your horse's behaviour so you can sort the problem out. Either that or just school him and forget about hacking if he's great in the school and hacking is the only problem.
 
No but u have done is have a go ive asked for help but it's ok just spoke to a non horsey friend who has come up with some ideas funny where the best advice comes from so tomorrow I try again I love my horse just think it's sad you have decided to have a go when I've been really really upset about this and have asked on here as a last resort also I've now talk to 3 trainers in my area who have just said they don't feel they could help with the problem and no I don't expect someone to jump on sort him the problem is between me and him and I will get us through this I will let everyone no how much fun we will be having hacking again in a minute :)
 
If you really believe that what @KP nut said was "having a go" then you are as hard to help as your horse. She didn't accuse you of anything, she just laid out the situation. We understand that you're in a difficult position, but If you're not prepared to take the trouble to understand what people say who are trying to help you without flying off the handle, then it's difficult to know what we can do.

I hope you are soon hacking out with your boy again without trouble.
 
Well when I've been told my horse resents me and I only got something to show off on basically I bully him I don't listen to him I've over faced him then yeah sorry iam going to get defensive!!!
 
She didn't say he resents you, she said "maybe he resents you". We don't know, we haven't seen him. We're speculating on why he might be doing what he is doing. Understanding what is causing it is the best way to fix it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Keren@serendipity
You have been extremely rude to KP and other serious horse- people here, myself included. You dont read the posts nor provide the information people are asking you for.
What strikes me is that you see this as personal. It isnt. It is all about horse psychology. May be you have managed till now without a detailed understanding of how horses learn behaviours and how they can be trained to behave differently. People like KP and me who have brought up children, or people who have trained dogs, have some understanding of what is loosely known as behaviourism - There is a good explanation of how Behaviourism can be applied to horse training in the book Perfect Manners by Kelly Marks. The sub title is How to behave so your horse does too -
Kely Marks is a student and associate of Monty Roberts the celebrated American Horse trainer and tho neither KP nor I are ardent followers of his methods, one can learn a lot from watching a whole range of people who handle and correct horses with behaviour that is dangerous. If you are in the UK . Kelly Marks 0prganisation Intelligent Horsemanship (IH) has many local advisers who will come out and help people wit their horses, particularly with leading problems which you seem to have had.
Now I will get personal. Because although one can say that the bad or unhappy reaction of a horse is not personal, they do behave differently with different people. Again no criticism of yourself. But a dear friend of mine had problems with a horse she intended to compete - sent him to a trainer at a competition yard. The young horse returned apprarently sorted out and the first ride, he had his owner off - The trainer liked him so much he took the horse back and into his yard for possible sale.
So there is an example of one rider who didnt get on with a horse that she dearly loved and in the end preferred to let him have a happy existence with other riders.

I and my friends have answered you with courtesy. However, I do not actually believe this thread is genuine because vital information has been with held and none of the questions people have asked about you and your horse have been answered. You have read so fast and carelessly that you misread my own questions. I did not say you used your horse to show off. I asked you to list the things you wanted to do with your horse in future. You have provided none of the information any of us asked you for. So it has been a waste of time our writing.

There is not enough basic understanding of horse behaviour here to convince me that you have the equestrian experience you claim.
However, I can only repeat: I have never been to a yard where a horse was shot, unless on medical grounds. The first step is always to turn to a professional and your arguments against doing that suggest that you have no idea how to choose a professional nor how they work with problem horses. We have tried to explain that to you. You seem to be hinting at some points that you yourself are a trainer of problem horses and have fun with them. Well one expert can ask the help of another trainer if they are stuck.

Your answer seems to be that you are too poor to pay a trainer or too remote - or both. To that there is no easy answer. Keeping a horse is an expensive hobby - But distance is not a problem. The horses who go for training from our local yards are boxed up and driven to the trainers own yard.

There is another thing that happens on the net - Someone posts questions and then turns down every suggestion they are given. You seem to fall into that pattern and then blame people who have replied to you. I can assure you that I myself came to NR years ago - in great trouble and that I was helped by good and careful people some of whom have given their time to try and help you.

You conclude by saying that tho local trainers have declined to help you, a non horsey friend has been brilliant and you are about to hack happilly once more on a horse whom your initial description made to sound truly dangerous, indeed so dangerous that a professional could not ride him and you had been told to have him shot.
If you are happy to ride this horse that is fine. It is your own decision. It is your horse and you can do as you like. (Unless you are a teenager on school holiday which may well be the case.) But please note that none of your posts indicated that the horse was safe for you to ride. We on New Rider forum set a priority on safety.
We are all volunteers. All we do is read the text typed in here. And wait for the OP to read the responses and provide more information.

Sometimes we can help and sometimes not - but whatever the case, at least you should have the courtesy to be grateful instead of going off the deep end about how horrible we all are. It doesnt matter what you do in life, whether is is cooking from a recipe, or riding, or learning to ride a bike, if something isnt working (as per you and the horse) one needs to change something. If one continues as before one is always likely to get the same results. Changing the behaviour of any horse always involves asking why it is behaving that way and trying something a tiny bit different -

So yes it does mean looking at your own strategies - and the sensible reaction is not to get defensive - these are not your personal failings. But if you want to change something in the habitual behaviour of your horse, you need to change something in your behaviour too. If you ride him in exactly the same way, on the same diet and in the same tack, he is quite likely to bolt for home again. What is going to stop him? Just look at your language.

he has taken to galloping home with me every time I take a pull he fly bucks and goes faster we jumped the gate back into the yard!! Then I spent 45 mins trying to get him out the yard with him going up right to the point of going backwards then finally throwing himself on the floor. :)
"take a pull", "fly bucks" Fly bucks while going fast? That isnt my experience of a bolting horse.
"we jumped the gate into the yard." We? Or did he jump in spite of your attempts to stop or turn him? What did you do to stop or slow him by the way? When he gallops for home how far away does he start?
45 minutes to fail to teach your own dearly loved horse to lead properly? Just one lesson in leading and ground work should have got that sorted years ago. BHS Stage 1.
And there are things that dont make sense in your later posts like keeping in touch with the owners. What owners?
And why did your local trainers say they could not help? No details given.

Jump back on your horse for a lovely hack on a lovely loose rein since that is apparently how you choose to ride but no one on NR is going to believe that you didnt get the best advice here.
 
What exactly were expecting as an answer?

I suggested using a chiffney to try and keep you both safe until you can get him to put his trust in you. I have a pony who was called dangerous. Whatever I asked of him he threw his dummy out the pram. I called him the one-eyed git. Because he was, tongue in cheek. He was totally unpredictable out hacking. I tried a happy mouth snaffle on him to keep things soft but he just ran through it.

So I upped the game. I put him in a. Waterford for ridden hacking and made it near enough impossible for him to set his jaw and tank off. For groundwork he went back into his happy mouth and a chiffney which only came into use when he threatened to either run or rear.

These were short term fixes. It gave me the upper hand just to put me back in control again. The true answer was weeks of working with a damaged pony to build up the relationship with people. The idea was that when he was in danger he could turn to me for leadership rather than taking charge for himself. He came from a fair in Ireland where ever was being used for pony rides for adults and kids. He was 12.2hh and two years old. He also had a horrific eye injury where someone had hit him. He lost the eye.

I don't know what you expected to get in the way of answers but I suggest you read @KP nut and @Skib replies. Both make for good constructive advice.
 
I am probably more safety conscious than most, but his behaviour sounds very dangerous. It isn't just your own safety you have to consider, what about other people who he may run into when he is bolting for home? You could hurt walkers, children, cylists and car drivers. An out of control horse can do a lot of damage.

If he were mine, I simply would give up hacking him completely as his behaviour sounds too extreme to be able to do anything with. If he is happy working in the arena, could he have a career as a dressage or showjumping horse? As EML stated, some horses just find hacking very stressful. I know of a few horses who are absolutely superstars in the dressage ring, but turn into monsters hacking. There are lots of other ways to enjoy your horse without risking life and limb. Why do it at all?
 
No one said that and you have been very rude to people that have offered advice. This forum is excellent at supporting people through problems and issues.

I suggested a vet check up which you have not commented on. This was also mentioned by someone else.

If one of my boys behaviour changed so rapidly I would be looking at the reason why and first off is back person no matter If they were checked only three months before and as a very active sports person I know who quickly a little niggle can turn in to pill blown pain. Also I would be getting my saddler back out. Then the dentist then blood tests. As well as doing all this I would be leading out in hand with a another horse etc etc.

Again I am repeating what others have said yet you have no commented on but picked words and used them out of contexts
 
And this is what iam talking about every response is undermining!!! I ask for help and yes iam to poor to spend loads of money on expensive trainers sorry that iam not rich!!! I never said I was leading him for 45 mins I was sat on him!! Asking him to leave the yard!! Also he galloped off down the main Rd everytime I took a pull on one rein he fly bucked and pulled his head down pulling the reins out of my hands hence why my hands are ripped to shreds sorry didn't measure the distance but it was a fair way u have to turn in to the gate I asked him to stop so I could open it he decided to jump it to take me off down the drive!! I tell u what any of you can and take him out and tell me what u experts think!! Also I've sold him three times he got sent back as to dangerous I've owned him for over 5 yrs all I want to do right now is go for a ride down the Rd nothing much hack to the beach my friend did come up with something ie the spring grass could he be lacking in anything mmm magnasim that can make them a little crazy!! Also has offered to walk with us with her dog nice of her also yes I have the vet coming Friday!!!
 
@Skib wrote "However, I do not actually believe this thread is genuine because vital information has been with held and none of the questions people have asked about you and your horse have been answered. You have read so fast and carelessly that you misread my own questions"

I agree. The whole thread makes no sense. So I think we need some....

258troll_spray.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Keren@serendipity
newrider.com