Good evening, another fellow from Devon here.
I haven’t really digested all the replies, but am just going on what you have been saying. The bit that stands out like a lighthouse beacon is the size,
16.2hh. We are not talking about a little pony here.
My thinking is and I hate to quote Mr P here but "If you do what you've always done, you get what you've always got"
If what you are doing is not working, stop.
If what you are doing is not helping, stop.
I would not even be attempting to take this horse out right now. I'm coming from personal experience of re-educating a halter bolter. She took off on the roads causing the rider I was with to come off, her to plough through a fence and months and I mean months of confidence building. It took about 18 months before she actually went off the yard, the spot where she run from took her about a year to settle.
You are an accident waiting to happen if your horse is running. I don't want to read about you in the news.
I had an instructor at the time who made it quite clear that I was grounded on the yard for a minimum of six months. She was also able to assist me in the initial confidence building, the rest was down to me.
Strangely enough we took up dressage since we couldn't hack out.
If you want to know the how, I can look back and find the reference.
Good luck