Is Hay, soaked hay or haylage best?

Jessey

Well-Known Member
Dec 20, 2004
24,574
14,957
113
40
Suffolk, UK
This study had some really interesting charts even if you aren't into data, it just made it very visual on how feeding dry hay, soaked hay or haylage could have very different impacts, especially if you have a horse suffering with Insulin Dysregulation.

A snip for those not wanting to read all of it; 2 top charts are for an ID pony, bottom ones for a normal pony, showing GI response on the left charts and Insulin on the right ones.
Capture.PNG

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1090023318301011#tbl0010
Given the sample size its not really conclusive yet, but there is some interesting info there and visually descriptive of how a ID horse's reactions to the same stimulus are much greater.
 

Bodshi

Well-Known Member
Apr 23, 2009
7,243
4,253
113
Yorkshire
I haven't had time to read the article (will save for later) but presumably you want the chart lines to stay as level as possible, so it looks as though soaked hay is a clear winner? Although interesting that the GI index goes up slightly again for soaked hay when for dry and haylage it's going down. Can't wait to read the article now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey

Jessey

Well-Known Member
Dec 20, 2004
24,574
14,957
113
40
Suffolk, UK
The glucose level ideally should remain pretty stable (slow release foods do that best, called low GI in people food), as the body reacts to control glucose levels with insulin you can get a little up/down, its the spike that you want to be minimal. The bigger the spike, the harder crash after (why the black and green lines drop below the blue line). The more of a spike in glucose the more insulin the body kicks out to bring it back down and they (scientists) now think its insulin spikes that cause lami........
 
Last edited:

carthorse

Super Moderator
Staff member
Jan 6, 2006
9,525
5,448
113
I'd be interested to know what type of haylage & hay it was too, I bet that makes a heck of a difference. Interesting graphs though, and I'm sure the article will be an interesting read.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey

carthorse

Super Moderator
Staff member
Jan 6, 2006
9,525
5,448
113
I wonder what, if any, impact the fact that they were fasted first made? Presumably the fasting would also have a greater impact on the ID ponies? I understand it's the only way to get the readings in response to what they've fed, but I wonder if that also colours the response.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey and Bodshi

Jessey

Well-Known Member
Dec 20, 2004
24,574
14,957
113
40
Suffolk, UK
I agree, the types of hay/haylage would definitely be of interest. I wouldn't think fasting would increase the response, but a 'normal' baseline from when they are at grass etc would be an interesting comparison point, there is definitely scope for a lot more testing in this area, I hope someone has the money to do it!
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
chunky monkey Feeding soaked hay in the field Metabolic 9
Star the Fell Feeding soaked hay Metabolic 5
thoroughlybred1 laminitis - starvation paddock v soaked hay Metabolic 24
A Soaked Hay Horse Care 1
Jessey You couldn't make it up - blooming hay again Horse Care 19
Trewsers Another hay prices thread Horse Care 14
L The importance of testing hay Metabolic 8
Jane&Ziggy New hay shed! Cafe 11
Huggy Got our hay Cafe 3
Huggy Whats everyone paying for hay? Cafe 26
Jane&Ziggy Hay store Cafe 13
Ale The great Surrey hay shortage 2021 Cafe 15
Ale Short strand hay and looking tucked up Metabolic 7
Jessey Hay nets, muscles and teeth Horse Care 24
Trewsers Hay puzzle Horse Care 25
Trewsers Hay net recommendations Cafe 9
Jessey Hay problems - 🤞sorted Veterinary,Injuries and Therapies 70
Ale Slow feeding hay in the field Metabolic 16
Ale Feeding hay in winter Money Saving Ideas, Tips and Remedies 12
Jessey How much hay do you go through? Metabolic 16
Jessey How do you store your hay? Cafe 11
stigofthedump automatic hay dispensers Cafe 20
Star the Fell Large bales of hay Cafe 5
Ale Calcium in hay? Cafe 4
L Hay prices!!! Cafe 18
Mary Poppins Feeding hay on box rest Horse Care 29
Jessey Hay feeding Metabolic 8
Jessey Will we have a hay shortage? Cafe 24
Jessey Making Hay Metabolic 17
Jessey Finally decent hay! Horse Care 1
Jane&Ziggy Anyone use a hay ball feeder? Horse Care 5
Star the Fell Hay, straw, shavings and... Cafe 3
L Urgh Hay shortage!! Horse Care 12
Jessey Hay or is it her cushings???? Metabolic 38
MrC Hay feeding Cafe 27
chunky monkey Soaking hay Cafe 12
chunky monkey Hay bar Cafe 3
Jessey How do you define 'good' or 'dusty' hay? Metabolic 8
Lissie What type of hay do I need? Metabolic 8
N How do you feed your hay? Horse Care 27
Jessey Hay vs Haylage Metabolic 23
Joy Pregant or hay belly Horse Care 8
Jessey Tarping hay Cafe 9
Star the Fell Anyone feed Thunderbrook Hay Cobs? Metabolic 0
L The joys of soaking hay!!! Horse Care 3
Star the Fell hay ball Horse Care 7
KP nut Switching from hay to haylage Metabolic 10
Ale Field hay storage? Cafe 16
Jessey Hay/haylage nets Money Saving Ideas, Tips and Remedies 15
stigofthedump Pony won't eat wet hay Metabolic 12

Similar threads

newrider.com