Is it time to euthanize him?

BeachRiding

New Member
Aug 26, 2004
7,680
0
0
USA
How do I know when its time? DO you think its soon?...

Well, Willie is 24 now, and lost around 200 pounds this summer, I have been steadly putting it back on. It has become very expensive to keep his weight.
4-5 flakes of hay a day, and 15 pounds of grain. The vet says weightloss is due to pain,as his teeth are fine. His back leg is in a lot of pain, so I am putting him on devil's claw,at another $50 a month or so...:(

I saddled him up today, only to find that his saddle doesn't fit anymore, due to muscle wastage and a swaying back. I spent tons of money getting this saddle for him last year, now I need to sell it...

You might have read my thread about his heat stress problem, he is doing fine now, but that shows his age. I worry about the winter. Although I do have a heavy duty blanket.

He is fine at walk,very lame at trot,and dead lame at canter. So, I am not riding him, my sister can ride him at walk,as she wants him to ride occasionally. but now his saddle doesn't fit,and she is not secure bareback.

He still loves to go on short trail rides,although I noticed he was starting to breath hard after only 15 minutes at the walk, over flat land.

My sister LOVES him,so it will be very heat-breaking to put him down. He still loves his carrots,and attention very much.

So.....:( What do you think? If he was yours?
 
If he was mine, he would be retired. There is no way I would ever ride any of my horses if they were in any kind of pain at all.

I will let all of my horses continue on until they no longer seem to enjoy living. Just because they can no longer be ridden, doesn't mean their time is up.

I have never had to make the decision myself, but when I do, I have a trusted animal communicator whose reading will assist me in my decison.
 
why dont you just let him retire? theres a 31 year old horse at my yard and he is verry happy just doing nothing and just doing what he wants. i think you should just let him retire and dont ride him if it hurts him. just let him enjoy the life he has left, like cvreagzayn said just because they can no longer be ridden dosent mean their time is up. mabey you should get your vet out and ask him if his in to much pain and if it would be kinder to put him to sleep. mabey his just too hot at the moment and will start to fell better when it cools down? or dosent he handle winter very will either? if i where you i would have a talk with your vet and do whats best for willie. and if your vet thinks he will be ok just let him retire and be happy.
 
I'd just retire him out to pasture. Sounds like he is OK, just a bit of a hard keeper and not so sound any more for riding. Horses can get this way when they get older. 24 isn't young but it's not ancient; age is just a number anyway.

I personally wouldn't euthanize a horse just because he needs 15 lbs of grain a day. I've seem healthy, young warmbloods getting roughly that amount. I've also rehabbed thin rescues and they will need LOTS of food for a few months if they're a few hundred pounds underweight. He's got to catch up from the weight loss.

You might want to look at his feed to see why he's needing so much. Is it Senior? Is it a good name brand? I've seen firsthand where Person A keeps the same horse on far less grain than Person B becauase Person B uses the cheapest no-name sweetfeed. Some brands/kinds really are more nutrient dense than others. (Sorry for asking if you already covered this)

4-5 flakes of hay doesn't sound like much to me. When grass isn't growing, I'm giving my horses a full square bale+ for each horse each day. We don't know how much pasture grass he is getting or the quality of that grass. You may not be able to do this, but if he were mine I'd give him free choice hay 24-7 so he always has food in front of him.

Has your vet ruled out ulcers? This can cause weight loss and discomfort.

What about encysted parasites? A fecal sample may not seem so bad but that's only showing you what is shedding out of the horse, not what is inside. Unless a vet told me not to, I would give a horse like this a Panacur Powerpak (5-day intensive deworming). You probably know this, but it's important to also treat for Tapeworm. Regular ivermectin doesn't get all the bad bugs.

You say his back leg is in pain, but you're still letting people ride him so I'm assuming the back leg can't be that painful without a rider... so I'm thinking he's not in agony. You may want to talk to your vet about pain management for those really bad days.

In my opinion, you're wasting your money on the Devils Claw. It's not been proven in a scientific study to cause improvement in horses. We also don't know what its toxic dosage is in a horse. For $50/month I'd talk to my vet about other medicines we could try to make an older horse more comfortable.

Is he on turnout? Could some of this be him stiffening up from being in a stall? If he were mine I'd put him on 24-7 turnout. I'd make sure his pasturemates aren't harassing him when nobody is around. One possible scenarion is an agressive pasturemate runs an older horse around for fun when nobody is there; the older horse is then stiff and lethargic and perhaps a bit stressed.

It's hard for us to nudge you in one direction or the other. There's so much we don't know about his situation. And even if I could see him in person, his owner would know more about him than I would since I can't see him each day.

If he were mine, I'd be keeping in regular touch with my vet about his progress. If she said "no way will he make it thorugh the winter", that would be a reason to consider it. Or if he was so uncomfortable he wasn't moving around, was laying down all the time, or stopped eating.
 
He is retired pretty much, I just wanted to see if I could have my sister ride him, so decided to get on him. He hasn't been ridden in 4 months. I have decided to never ride him again.

Vet ruled out ulcers,teeth problems,and parasites. He is out 24/7. He seemed very depressed the last couple of months, but this week he was very perked up, thus I decided to ride him.

I was told to put him on devils claw or bute by the vet.

I have also noticed, he cocks his right leg back most of the time, but never alternates with his other legs. He is stiff and arthritic.
 
mayS said:
In my opinion, you're wasting your money on the Devils Claw. It's not been proven in a scientific study to cause improvement in horses. We also don't know what its toxic dosage is in a horse. For $50/month I'd talk to my vet about other medicines we could try to make an older horse more comfortable.
mayS said:
*cough cough*

i did read the first part, "in my opinion" but willielove, please do not stop the devils claw, if nessercery, go and give him the bute, then soak the DC in water then give it to him in his food, water, or by hand. it is a natural remidy, and it does work from my experiance

my laminitic, had server laminits, and i fed him up on DC. obviously thats only the pain releaver, (and other stuff too:rolleyes: ). vet said PTS. i said no!!! week later, he was walking round and standing up, decidied to take him off DC. he went bad again. just to show it does work, so go ahead and use it.


do you use liquid or hard bits?
 
oh, well I haven't bought devil's claw,yet but was going to order it this week, now I am not sure...the asprin is a lot cheaper.
 
fataldream said:
mayS said:
In my opinion, you're wasting your money on the Devils Claw. It's not been proven in a scientific study to cause improvement in horses. We also don't know what its toxic dosage is in a horse. For $50/month I'd talk to my vet about other medicines we could try to make an older horse more comfortable.
mayS said:
*cough cough*

i did read the first part, "in my opinion" but willielove, please do not stop the devils claw, if nessercery, go and give him the bute, then soak the DC in water then give it to him in his food, water, or by hand. it is a natural remidy, and it does work from my experiance

my laminitic, had server laminits, and i fed him up on DC. obviously thats only the pain releaver, (and other stuff too:rolleyes: ). vet said PTS. i said no!!! week later, he was walking round and standing up, decidied to take him off DC. he went bad again. just to show it does work, so go ahead and use it.


i would agree with this i have seen great improvment in horses using DC including my own. something which did not happen using some of the TESTED and branded and very expensive medicines on the market. i use the granules.:)
 
i can definitely vouch for devils claw cos when my shetland had real bad episodes of laminitis I used this on her and it took heat away within 3 days
 
if he is in constant pain to the point where he is losing that much weight, then i do think something needs to be done. either permanent considerable pain relief - or it is time to say goodbye.
devils claw works on exactly the same principles as bute, but bute is regulated, tested for side effects, and you know exactly how strrong it is, which is not possible with DC supplements as they are not regulated. dosage varies, strength varies, while bute is always the same.

if he's not been ridden for 4 months and is still losing weight through pain, it doesn't sound like he would be any happier 'retired'.

you may find that bute won't do enough for the pain to make him completely comfortable, just like in humans aspirin can only take away a certain amount of pain. it's a good drug but it can't work miracles.
i would say bute is worth a try, discuss with your vet about dosage, how long to show an improvement and when to call it a day. IMO losing weight through pain is a pretty good indicator that the horse is in constant distress and something needs to be done as a matter of some urgency.

it is an awful thing to have to face up to, but it has to be done - if he can't be made comfortable on bute then i would think it is time to let him go.

probably best to discuss it with your sister now, so she has time to get used to the idea and realises it is in his best interests if it has to happen.

i think if it were me i'd sit down with the vet, and discuss a timescale by which time if he hadn't started to gain weight and was field-sound ion walk and trot, we'd call it a day. then give him a coupe of days really dosed up so he is high as a kite and feeling no pain at all, spoil him rotten and then let him go.
 
i know that soya oil is good for weight gain it might be worth a try. you put a splodge in with his food every mealtime. you could also give him a bit of cod liver oil too. good luck x
 
I recently had a pony put down which was really hard but we made sure she had a month to enjoy herself and then we gave her a shot of green dream, she was very artritic, skin and bone and could only walk, she loved company though and had been working for RDA for years we gave her loads of hugs and kisses and let her retire for good without pain. She was a 29 yr old welsh. We really miss her but nowing she was happy when she went to pony heven we were happy!
 
Forgive me if I am speaking out of turn here but if I am honest it reads as though your main concern is money??!!! :confused:

As everyone says he should be retired and deffinatley not ridden if he is already in pain without a rider.

If you gave him something to stop the the pain then you shouldn't have the weight loss problems associated with it.
 
To put it bluntly, yes I can't afford to spend tons of money to keep his weight,and tons of money on pain realiver. The amount of grain,hay,and the cost of pain medication is pretty big per month. Say he is kept out of pain,yet His weight still is difficult to keep, it cost alot to keep putting weight on him, he needs 100 pounds on him right now, and I don't know how much food I can give him without giving him colic to put it on,and keep it on!

He was on a pain reliever, and lost 200 pounds. If a stronger pain reliever doesn't work, than this seems like an impossible battle.

Edited to say: money is not my main concern, but it is a concern!
 
Last edited:
If he is in permanent pain, then I would say that his quality of life is probably pretty low - this is obviously a call that can't be made in an internet conversation - you need to know the horse. But if that is the case, I would opt for euthanasia.

Ross
 
Yeah,I don't think I made it clear enough that he is in permanent pain, and always will be without drugs. he has tendonitis and arthritis really bad in one leg.
 
i think anyone who can say that money is never going to be a consideration is very lucky indeed. not all of us can get access to unlimited cash - at at some stage however much money you throw at a horse, it is still going ot be the end.

i know i'd do what i could for the old git if he were in this situation, but eventually my income would run out.
 
if it's a financial issue, then give him to someone else as a companion horse / field ornament. If it's a pain and illness issue, speak to your vet - if people don't know the animal it's a big question to ask
 
I wouldnt tell anyone what to do with their horses but maybe it is time to let him go. Sure your sister will be upset but it would be crueller to him to keep in pain just so not to upset her. I felt awful when vet pts but also felt relief cos she wasnt in anymore pain.
My daughter was devastated when had to put her pony to sleep last week but had explained to her why rosie was to get put to sleep and altho was very very sad it wouldnt be nice to have her in lots of pain, I didnt tell her that morning when she was getting pts I told her later on the day - yes she was mad with me when told her but wouldnt have wanted her to be there. Rosie just went for a long sleep and I know in my heart I have done the right thing altho miss the little critter.
Last winter rosie sneaked into my friends store and ate one bite out of every apple on the tray but didnt eat 1 whole apple, this always make me smile when think of it and when tell other people it makes them smile this is just the kind of cheeky thing she would do, so I am going to plant an apple tree in memory of her because when I see the apple tree and remember why I planted it - will make me smile, she brought me so much joy and this way remembering her will make me think of good times of which were so many
Maybe when time comes you can think of something of willie that makes you smile and do something similar - then when you see it you have good memories not bad memories.
 
newrider.com