Lightweight rug

trieste

Active Member
Mar 5, 2004
1,258
5
38
Norfolk/Suffolk border on the coast
I need to get a new lightweight turnout for Panda, I'm looking at the Shires Stormbreaker or Weatherbeeta Landa Lite, have never had a Shires rug before, but they seem really good value.

So opinions please, I can get the shires rug for approx £40 but the Weatherbeeta is going to set me back approx £55.
I have always been pleased with the Weatherbeeta rugs, I have several Landa freestyles, 220gm,110gm and an old arion 360gm, but saving £15 and it seems to be a good spec rug, does appeal.

thanks
 
i have an old shires one for my donkeys, they are quite durable but basic.

on ebay someone is selling off all the old Fal stock, they had some good quality lightweights but the fit is more generous than weatherbeeta i would think.
 
Personnally don't like the weatherbeeta as don't fit my lad and have the range of Masta rugs, from rain coat to heavy weight, most of them now 2/3 years old and seem as tough as they come. Worth a look
 
Thanks all - I think, :unsure: quite confused now, she has got a slumberdown 40g and a rhino wug no fill at the moment, and although she wore the rhino last year without any problems she seems to be breaking the belly straps, has happened twice now, i wasn't there but fellow livery said she managed to get her leg caught the first time - straps too long and wouldn't go shorter, I repaired and received a text this morning to say same thing's happened again, going to see if it's my poor sewing or the other strap that's still too long (hadn't realised that was the problem or I'd have shortened it when I did the repair.
Ponies eh, who'd have them!
 
I haven't had a Shires turnout, but have their fleeces for our two, they do come up quite a small fit - not sure about the turnout rugs tho? I have a Weatherbeeta which Storm seems to fit well, tho it isn't a particularly lightweight one. I am on the hunt for a lightweight for her, for when the weather turns really nasty! She can't have anything too heavy as we are still dieting her - it is dropping off mind, slowly but surely!!!
 
I have the lightweight shires and the 100grm shire, i also have weatherbeeta landa lites, landa, arion.

I personally rate both brands and would buy them both again. I would probably buy the shire brand first as they are much of a much but the shires work out cheaper:dance:

i would rate these both over Masta but would rate them under mark todd, fals as they are much better quality but have a price tag too match
 
Thanks Nookster, don't really want to spend too much as somehow she manages to rip small holes in all her rugs, no idea on what as nothing in field, electric fencing all round. Now leaning towards the shires was going for the Stormbreaker at £40 but might go for the Tempest at £30.
 
I have mostly amigo or rhino rugs for my horses but Pip has got a shires middleweight with a neck and it is good quality but I do agree with the previous poster that they come up small. She is 5ft 9 for everything but her shires 5ft 9 is a close fit and if she has it on for any length of time it rubs her shoulders which the amigos never do on either of my horses. I like the horseware rugs as they don't have any darts or shaping and they seem to hang really nicely on both our girls. I did have some wetherbeetas for my TB but they never seemed to fit her quite right and caused rubs so I ahd them cleaned and sold them. I think alot depends on the shape of the horse. If you get it from a local tack shop you should be able to try it on over a sheet. We always do that and do up all the buckles then have a little fashion parade on a headcollar to see if the rug slips when thy move, if it is tight in places and to check the straps adjustment. We only do that as we learnt the hard (expensive!!) way.
The Amigo lightweight in red would look nice on Panda!
 
I have lightweight weatherbeetas and Mark Todds and like both of those. I agree with the comment that the shires come up fairly snug, I bought the Shires Tempest for my friend and it is a far closer fitting on her TB than the Weatherbeetas in the same size.
 
Err, just to upset the apple cart here:D - if you take out a years subscription to Horse and Rider magazine just now you get a free Amigo lightweight turnout:D:D.

I did it last year. I bought the mag anyway plus I needed a rug. Turned out I was cheaper with the subscription than the rug would have cost me so I won all round:D

Oh, and I vote for Amigo rugs - they are great!!
 
Right, just to add to the confusion, Panda is wearing a Slumberdown 40gm at the moment, I need to get a spare lightweight was looking at the no-fill as I stated but have heard some people don't like the no-fill, Panda was lovely and snug yesterday but another on our yard with a no-fill felt damp, rug is definately not leaking, so I'm now thinking i should be looking at another 40gm as a spare rather than a no-fill. :unsure:
Opinions please. :redface:
thanks
 
newrider.com