looking for informations

Status
Not open for further replies.
Will contact you - I will ask the people concerned if it is OK, they are still having to deal with the issues these horses now have.
 
While this might be interesting I don't see how you can get a balanced view. If you ask for negative anecdotes then that is what you get, but how will you know how true they are, or how well able the people were to judge what they were seeing? I took part in a demo lesson a couple of years ago where one person (out of 30 watching) decided I was scared of my pony, and my pony was also scared. Absolute rubbish, as the other 29 agreed... but if that one person contacted you with just their view of the truth, then what opinion would you have of what went on?
One trainer tapping the front leg of a horse gently with the toe of his boot, when the horse was attempting to walk all over his head... reported to me as "He's awful, he kicks horses!". I mean, how can you ensure that the anecdotes you collect are objective?
The idea about accident reporting is good in theory, but I worked at an NH yard for 6 months and not one accident in that time was reported to anyone. And there certainly were accidents to working and visiting students.
You mention that you are a future scientist, so can you come up with a fairer, more scientific way to compile your data?
I am not being defensive here, I could offer you a couple of first-hand observations of situations with well-known trainers where I think they damaged the horses, or used unecessary force, but I'm a bit uncomfortable about how they might be used.
As for the way France seem to be embracing Parelli - well, good luck to them! Seems pretty narrow minded to me. :)
 
Crystal Fire said:
While this might be interesting I don't see how you can get a balanced view. If you ask for negative anecdotes then that is what you get, but how will you know how true they are, or how well able the people were to judge what they were seeing? I took part in a demo lesson a couple of years ago where one person (out of 30 watching) decided I was scared of my pony, and my pony was also scared. Absolute rubbish, as the other 29 agreed... but if that one person contacted you with just their view of the truth, then what opinion would you have of what went on?
One trainer tapping the front leg of a horse gently with the toe of his boot, when the horse was attempting to walk all over his head... reported to me as "He's awful, he kicks horses!". I mean, how can you ensure that the anecdotes you collect are objective?
The idea about accident reporting is good in theory, but I worked at an NH yard for 6 months and not one accident in that time was reported to anyone. And there certainly were accidents to working and visiting students.
You mention that you are a future scientist, so can you come up with a fairer, more scientific way to compile your data?
I am not being defensive here, I could offer you a couple of first-hand observations of situations with well-known trainers where I think they damaged the horses, or used unecessary force, but I'm a bit uncomfortable about how they might be used.
As for the way France seem to be embracing Parelli - well, good luck to them! Seems pretty narrow minded to me. :)


Well, how fine it can work with some NH trainers is very well documendet.....I do look for the other side of the coin....sure that it will be only opinions that I will get concerning the negative sides of NH.....but it will be also just an opinion to get....if I do have ask for positive expiriences.....I do know that my little research is kind of tricky.....but anyway it will be just for a private use to see the whole picture of NH, with both sides of the coin.....I 'm afraid that you are right that the frenchies are narrow sided concerning Parelli....it looks like that he's the only one that counts realy for them....all the other NH trainers are not or very well unknown or in the french eyes "just crop".....maybe Parelli will apear one day even on a french poststamp....at least I will be not surprised about it....
 
LOL Horseback! Maybe it will be like it was here. A few years ago everyone thought NH = Parelli. Then a few different instructors got over who approached things from a different angle, and people found that was not the case.
I cringe at the thought that the BHS, for example, could be narrow minded enough to adopt only one approach to NH studies over here. It would be like going into a library and only reading the same book over and over again.
 
Crystal Fire said:
LOL Horseback! Maybe it will be like it was here. A few years ago everyone thought NH = Parelli. Then a few different instructors got over who approached things from a different angle, and people found that was not the case.
I cringe at the thought that the BHS, for example, could be narrow minded enough to adopt only one approach to NH studies over here. It would be like going into a library and only reading the same book over and over again.

how right you are....it's a real shame for the french federation to have done it....
 
I think one has to be rather careful in this. There may well be annecdotal cases of "negative" experiences or things that have not worked as planned for just about any trainer in any style - and it is important to keep in mind that the reports of these cases are generally based on the subjective opinion of onlookers, or second hand stories.

Natural horsemanship isn't a magic wand, or a box of pills that "works" or "doesn't work" - it's a whole approach to horses, and as it is based on using equine psychology to create a more harmonious relationship, if it is used properly, it cannot really have "negative" effects as such.

That's not to say things can't go wrong - but let's also bear in mind that NH trainers get a lot of "last resort" cases, and see more than their fair share of very extreme horses that everyone else has given up on. There are some horses that, for whatever reason, cannot be helped - and it is not really fair to blame the trainer who is probably doing the best he/she can to make things better, even if it is in vain.

Let's take the Parelli case mentioned earlier of the horse that colicked and died after a trailer training with Parelli himself. It sounds awful - but there's a lot of background missing. A horse that is this stressed by the trailer almost certainly has other issues - possibly physical. Did the horse suffer regular colics anyway? (Maybe this was why it ws important for it to load - to get it to a vet. clinic in an emergency? Maybe it was usually loaded when suffering a colic and therefore afraid of the trailer?) What was its history? What else happened around the event? Whilst I use a slightly different trailering method from Parelli myself, I know his method and I can't imagine that a healthy, otherwise normal horse would suffer undue stress with his method. Hence, I would be reluctant to blame the man or the method and look at the surrounding circumstances. Parelli may be a smart business man, and a lot of other things in the commerical connection - but I've met him (if only briefly) and know people who know him much better, and I am sure he would not intentionally put a horse in danger.

Added to that, we should not confuse the philosophy and principles of NH with the individual practitioners. That's like saying if a doctor makes a mistake, medical science is at fault. Anyone can make a mistake, or a mis-judgement, but that's not to say that the underlying principles are wrong - just that they were wrongly or inappropriately applied in a particular case.

Does's help much with the specific examples, Horseback, but perhaps it's something worth mentioning! ;)
 
I agree with Kate, especially on a internet forum where so many of the ' facts' can be missing or misinterpreted by generalising or translation.
Honesty is great, but seems to also attract sarcasm rather than help or useful advise, looking for the positive way forward. I once voiced my concerns about a horse at a NH demo.But a fact everyone missed was that he had a heavy winter coat,small wonder he was sweating profusely,I'm a lot wiser now about the methods being used,but will always think the horse should have been pardoned from any more demo work , was this abuse?. or maybe I'm to soft.

I expect everyone has off days too, horses do, its knowing when to stop before you need to stop. For cases of abuse, I personally would hope the justice system would be relied on to prove guilt rather than public forums, infact I think things would be better if people used their energy positively, SCREAMING AND SHOUTING ABUSE,DOSN'T HELP THE VICTIM.Of course I do understand research is not a bad thing given all the facts.

Anyone who has really worked with or ridden a strong willed horse {and with issues about training too} will know just how tough and dangerous things can be,a little learning can be a dangerous thing, but learning can be safe with the right help and planning ahead, this doesn't mean for one moment the trainer has a macho attitude, be they male or female.
I have worked with two horses that have reputations for injuring people, no way would you injure them back, both have wonderful temperaments in my mind/eyes {i think the world of these two}and its not rocket science to find there better side and encourage it {if someone doesn't know already,they will find out, that for all the allegations that this or that training method is dominance or Alpha based, this just doesn't work,but some work may indeed be tough, the horse always tells the truth, but you need to know all the facts too } in a ideal world everything would be perfect.
Slow, timing, understanding and when to reward work wonders, but even that can't fix everything if you don't give a horse time, that seems to me, the real issue.
 
Fred, have you read Be With Your Horse by Tom Widdecombe? I think you would like it, along with the Rashid stuff of course :)
 
hi Yann, I know nothing of Tom Widdecombe:o , I have looked at the Rashid web site and like his style very much,its where to start. I'm real choosey,{horses tend to teach me,} hence have few books{lots of breed and type books :) }.Love Dorrance and Desmond book, read that one lots and EE.
And Im always looking for one that clicks with me,so one to look out for:)
Im limited with friends who love horse, bring me Motorhead/ ozzy DVDs and bike stuff:o .
Have you seen the loading DVD yet?
 
(Got your email Yann, will reply in a day or so :) )
I know of an incident where an NH trainer (I won't say which label he had attached), loaded a horse on a clinic. Next day horse collapsed at the foot of the ramp hyperventilating when owner was loading it, and the vet had to be called. Terrible eh?
Now for the background. Owner arrived on 2 day intro course with horse in trailer. Needed help with loading, the horse had been doped to load to come. Trainer did a little session on the first evening. Next day owner announced that they needed to leave - now - because of high winds coming up and having to travel on the motorway. Also, the horse was already booked to go to the vet the following day and would have to travel in the trailer again...! Trainer in a bit of a fix, with a clinic of people to teach... Luckily had an experienced student watching, so set the clinic up with various tasks which the student then helped with, and loaded the horse. He didn't use high levels of pressure, but was persistent. Gave the horses rests in between being in the trailer. But eventually the ramp had to go up and the horse had to leave.
So what should he have done? Told owner "your problem" maybe and then had to bear people saying that xyz couldn't load my horse. Dunno.
 
Interesting and what a dilemma, Crystal Fire,
Personally I absolutely forbid the ramp to be closed until I could be as sure as possible our horse was going to remain calm.There's no total guarantee.But I planned it taking a week or as long as needed.

Seen a Terrible incident loading, had children with me and managed to divert their minds/eyes away from what just happened,they asked what's up with my eyes, had no idea about how bad the loading accident was, terrible, and people cursed a vet who had the hardest job of all, to cap the whole tragedy off,a voice comes over the assembly area speakers, will rider xxxx and horse xxxx please please hurry up, causing a delay.

Has any one ever noticed the sides of the steel boxes on some Hunt transporters{no Im not saying all, honest} clearly horses have seriously freaked out while inside.
 
So ....it's looke like that everything is nice and fine under the sun in Parelli-Land.....?!!! Good to know that they are absolutly no clouds at all on the horizon....!
Or is the sun shinnig so bright....that everybody is blinded by the light ?
 
No it isn't, an nor is it with any trainer horseback :)
Fred, I really felt for him. I felt he had been backed into a corner on this one and couldn't win. The horse was calm when they put the ramp up and drove off, but obviously it had been too much for her and flooded her. However, as the owner had brought her 100 odd miles from home, and wanted to take her back that day... and the trainer was leaving that day... It was a bad situation.
 
Crystal Fire said:
Fred, I really felt for him. I felt he had been backed into a corner on this one and couldn't win. The horse was calm when they put the ramp up and drove off, but obviously it had been too much for her and flooded her.

I wouldn't even be too sure of that. If the horse had been sedated to travel one day - travelled 100 miles (so probably 2 and a half hours or so) - then clinic, then the same journey back - it might have been the travelling that was too much - not the trailer training. Travelling a sedated horse has its risks too, and most vets are reluctant to sedate before travelling unless it is a real emergency.

What was wrong with the horse that she had to go to the vets the next day? Could an existing condition have been something to do with it?
 
I know that my request is extremly hazardous.... so please don't get me wrong ....my attention is not to start a war about diffient opinions....



Im sure I would go and watch Pat Parelli here in the UK, but he seems busy and never here.

:)
 
I thought PP had no intentions of returning to the UK for some time.
Kate, I'm trying to remember what the horse had to go to the vet's for... but I can't. As you say, it could have been the travelling that caused her collapse the following day. Particularly as the owner was deciding to head off early because of warnings of high winds on the motorways. However, the owner is of course telling everyone she ever meets who mentions this trainer or the system that he follows about how the whole thing causes trauma to horses and how traumatised her horse was... I think that demonstrates why asking for anecdotes doesn't give a particularly effective study of any approach to horsemanship.
... and I'm not defending PNH, I'm not a great fan myself. But I know why, and it's based on my own personal experience and observations, not second-hand opinions.
 
Exactly - Crystal Fire!! ;)

"Blame the system/trainer for my own mistakes/misjudgements/accidents" is common in all areas of life, not just NH.

I think it's related to "blame the government for everything from the weather to road accidents" - something happened I didn't want - so it must be somebody else's fault! :D
 
horseback said:
So ....it's looke like that everything is nice and fine under the sun in Parelli-Land.....?!!! Good to know that they are absolutly no clouds at all on the horizon....!
Or is the sun shinnig so bright....that everybody is blinded by the light ?

horseback

this seems a very odd thing to say. the Newrider board is not affiliated to any particular trainer - we will discuss all and sundry and have views both for and against most approaches represented here.

But the board is friendly and constructive and tends not to support malignant gossip or unfounded mud-slinging (on ANY subject). We also tend to be quite a challenging bunch and don't just accept "the sun shines out of..." type comments without good evidence behind them ;) (photos of the sun, and the person concerned ;) )

This balanced view is one of the reasons most of us are still here and posting, despite our differing points of view.

We HAVE suggested ways you might collect the data you are looking for. So I don't see why you posted that comment ?
 
Well put CVB, we have been around in pointless circles before about A is better than B which usually seems to degenerate into a mud slinging match.

A contact email has been left for those who wish to send any comments but I am closing this thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com