Napping: 1-1 draw

Jane&Ziggy

Jane&Sid these days!
Apr 30, 2010
22,074
10,564
113
66
Surrey Hills
Sid was trimmed on Tuesday, and as the ground is so hard I thought I would walk him in hand today. A chance, I thought, to take him down to the scary railway bridge and work on getting him across it.

Well, I think I made some errors of judgement. He was reluctant to go down to the bridge, but once we got there he walked over happily enough. Wahey, I thought, and took him back for another go. Oh no, he couldn't see the point of that. And once I did get him over a second time, he made it clear that since we had turned around once the point of our mission was obviously to cross the bridge, and we had done that, so now it was time to Go Home.

I didn't like that message so walked him down to the main road. No problem. Then another error of judgement: I thought since we were there, we could walk around the loop instead of going straight back up the hill. This meant a section of pavement walking, which I know he strongly dislikes.

On this one he defeated me. He just would not go forward, not with an aid, not with a growl, not with a whirl of the 12ft rope or even a smart smack on the bum with my horseman's stick. He wasn't lathered or wild-eyed, just stubborn. Instead of taking a forward step he turned his back end around on the pavement until it was drifting into the road - he prefers the road - and a very nice police patrol man passing by in his car stopped to ask me if I could take him by another route, since he feared for Sid's safety if he spilled into the carriageway.

So I backed him up the four steps or so he had taken from the bridlepath, then made him take a step in every direction and back up in every direction before we walked back up to the bridge, Sid bright eyed and perky eared, me with my tail between my legs.

However, I then did get him to cross the bridge softly, by walking to the end of the lead rope and asking him to come to me. The first time I needed to apply a lot of pressure and he leaned back, but in the end he gave in and came softly forward. This worked to get him right over the bridge. The last time he walked right up to me and put his head on my chest for a rub, and I decided to quit while we were both still calm and pleased with each other.

Walking home he was a lamb, so much so that I clipped the ends of the 12ft rope to his halter beside a bench and hopped on bareback just for 12 strides. It would have been lovely to stay on - he is wide and warm and soft, so comfortable - but I didn't have my hat on, so decided to be sensible. We stopped to be admired by all and sundry - well. they admire Sid, not me - and got home calm and collected.

Not sure what I will do about the napping, but I think he needs a purpose and is very sensitive to what that purpose is. Perhaps I need to develop a stronger sense of purpose.
 
I'd say if you've done a problem area such as the bridge don't repeat it or look for another problem to fix, instead say thank you very much and leave it there. By repeating something you've done in an acceptable fashion you risk either confusing or annoying him because all of a sudden doing what you ask isn't good enough. I also wouldn't go out looking to fix napping, instead go out for a ride and deal with what comes. You say he's sensitive to purpose so to him maybe it feels like you're picking a fight?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lollykay
Hmm, not quite the exercise you planned, napping can be so difficult to over come.

I don't have many rules when I go out, but 1 is I never double back unless absolutely unavoidable, the temptation to repeat something like a bridge crossing a few times is high, but it's rarely helpful unless you can do a loop back to it IME. Niko's little tantrum the other week was all because I broke this rule, every few years I have to relearn it 😣

My other general rule, and one I am whole heartedly guilty of breaking, is never to do more than planned - I find if my thoughts include 'we did it, yay, lets just try.....' then in reality it means my horse is going to make me regret it, like they know what the intent was and when you push past it they suddenly feel offended and need to make a point!

Having said all that, you did well to end the sesh on a good note with both of you happy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
Mine is the no purpose no point. I know that, done it. Seem it, done it. And she's also got an inbuilt no, nope, no way.

It reads as you crossed the bridge and I expected you to carry on and do something with that, but you wanted to turn back, so that's then going to take me back home. Session completed.
But you then added on an another area that he's not keen on, and ended up going back to the bridge again.
It's possible that some of what you are doing is upsetting him and then it comes over as a nap because he's confused?
I do turn mine round, that's no big deal, you never know when you may come across something in front of you that you cant negotiate. But generally all the routes are some sort of loop and that can include a circle round a tree, road sign, car, something.
 
That sounds good. But no, one is not supposed to be bareback on a public high way, You are supposed to use saddle and bridle. And in theory, the horse should not be on the pavement. It is classified as a vehicle. We always led the horses on the left hand side of the road.
 
Yes indeed, @carthorse, @newforest, @Jessey, I have learned from this. I never usually do an out-and-back, only a loop, and on this occasion I think I confused myself because having crossed the bridge and turned back he felt that he had finished and was to go home, and then I got a bee in my bonnet about not going out and back and that in fact we should do a loop and so tried to add on. Just not a good session plan all together.

As a matter of interest, if I had led him 50m or so from the bridge and then turned round and gone back (as was my original plan), might he learn from that that that's where we stop on this route? It's awkward when the route you are on doesn't have a lot of options around a tricky spot.

@Skib I was leading him on the halter with long rope and stick for all except 12 strides of walk on the heath, many hundreds of metres from a road. In our area pavements are often multi purpose, for bikes and horses as well a people, and the pavement we were on is one. The policeman's concern was that if he slipped from the pavement he could cause an RTA, which is right, of course.
 
@Jane&Ziggy if you have a route where you have to turn round I think it's useful to vary where you turn. I have some short circular loops and some days Luka will try to take the shortest one if he thinks I'm not paying attention, yet if I'm focused on carrying on past that turn he doesn't argue about it (well not nowadays, he did to begin with!).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
That sounds good. But no, one is not supposed to be bareback on a public high way, You are supposed to use saddle and bridle. And in theory, the horse should not be on the pavement. It is classified as a vehicle. We always led the horses on the left hand side of the road.
This comment tells me that you've never had to make any decisions for yourself based on what's in front of you. You only ever go by right and wrong without any discretion.
It's so easy to sit at a computer and tell someone they shouldn't be on the pavement.
In fact it's a civil offence and not a criminal one and I ride on the pavements around here. The reason for that is because in summer it's actually safer to step her up to allow traffic to pass, we also use a path as a cut through to avoid a really busy junction that most who ride use.
I had the same attitude as you when I saw riders cutting through the bus lane-that's wrong I wouldn't do that, guess what riding the same road, in the same traffic, that's exactly what we do!! Because it's safer.
 
Yes indeed, @carthorse, @newforest, @Jessey, I have learned from this. I never usually do an out-and-back, only a loop, and on this occasion I think I confused myself because having crossed the bridge and turned back he felt that he had finished and was to go home, and then I got a bee in my bonnet about not going out and back and that in fact we should do a loop and so tried to add on. Just not a good session plan all together.

As a matter of interest, if I had led him 50m or so from the bridge and then turned round and gone back (as was my original plan), might he learn from that that that's where we stop on this route? It's awkward when the route you are on doesn't have a lot of options around a tricky spot.

@Skib I was leading him on the halter with long rope and stick for all except 12 strides of walk on the heath, many hundreds of metres from a road. In our area pavements are often multi purpose, for bikes and horses as well a people, and the pavement we were on is one. The policeman's concern was that if he slipped from the pavement he could cause an RTA, which is right, of course.
He probably won't assume that you always turn at a certain spot, dressage horses don't assume that going down the centre line always means halt at x.
But, you know your cob, if he's that type vary it.
 
He probably won't assume that you always turn at a certain spot, dressage horses don't assume that going down the centre line always means halt at x.
But, you know your cob, if he's that type vary it.

I know many dressage riders who won't ever run through a test more than once at home because the horse starts to anticipate it. I remember a friend who's horse had just got his one time tempi changes and was so pleased with himself that a particular turn would set them off regardless of what he was being asked for - lesson learnt was don't use a repeated pattern to teach a horse something new if it's the sort that's very keen to please! I know hacking is different but I do think some quickly get set in their ways and so turning round at the same spot can create a problem if one day you want to go further.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey and Huggy
All horses are different too, Jess I could afford to change my requirements of because although she likes to please she's not too worried if she doesn't, Niko on the other hand is so completely obsessed with pleasing that he learns a thing very quickly and will constantly offer it up and then get very upset if it's not what you were after, he'll get better as he gets older/more experience, but for now I have to mindful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy and carthorse
newrider.com