horse_barn_bum
- are you riding western or hunt seat (classical, whatever you call it !) ?
- what sort of warm up do you do before you canter ?
- what sort of fitness level does your horse have ?
- how responsive is s/he to leg aids other than in canter ?
the style of riding will affect any choice of artificial aid - but of course it would be even better to fix it without this !
at 17 your horse may be starting to feel a bit of arthritis, so may more time to warm up and get supple. When you do use your legs to ask the horse to step up when cantering, what response do you get ? what happens if you do short canters with lots of transitions ? e.g. only canter for 10 strides, then trot for 4 or 5, then ask for canter again ?
I would also think a little about yourself - is your balance ok, are you applying the aids clearing, correctly ?
I realised I was being sloppy with my aids when I tried to ask for canter not at a corner - I had been relying on the corner to help my horse know what I was asking. It was easy to fix once I realised it and last weekend we even got counter canter (which is what I had asked for) at the right point and time !
So check that you are asking the right way and with the right emphasis. Also check that you are not leaning forward, or hanging on with the reins at all.
Especially with an arthritic horse, they need to a bit more room to get going without it hurting.
One exercise I used to do with my mum's fell pony was to canter him around practically at the buckle end of the rein, just using my legs and seat to keep him going. He used to wind my mum up and make out that he could not possibly canter for more than a few strides - so then the rider tends to try and hold the pony up a bit and help them. But actually this is counter productive as you want the horse to be in self-carriage, and not pulling your arm sockets out !
If you lunge at all, it might be worth trying a (gentle) lunge lesson. (a) without rider to check if the horse is genuinely having trouble then (b) with rider if the horse shows no problem cantering in part (a).