Need input please

Dori2021

Member
Oct 9, 2021
56
7
8
US, NH
I will try to make this brief and to the point although it is not easy. I have recently been using a vet who #1 likes to sell me a product or products every time he visits and #2 is insistent that a high percentage of horses have Cushing's and need to be on medication for it. My senior mare was retired a few years back and lost some topline from what I believe was lack of working, so I had started her up with a light work schedule again. Three weeks ago, she coliced. My vet could not get her to respond to treatment, so we brought her to hospital and she had colic surgery. This was successful and she has just recently come home and is doing very well in her rehabilitation. Previous to her colic my vet had been saying he was sure she had Cushing's and that she should be on Prascend. As far as testing, his own vet assistant had come out a couple years ago in January and given her a TRH Stim test (which they insisted she get) which turned out to be 80 which she said was in normal range. That fall this vet who insists 90% of all older horses have Cushing's, insisted on giving my horse another TRH Stim test around September/October. This was given during the seasonal fall months when the readings are not accurate. This test came out 773 according to him and he was insistent she be started on Prascend. At that point I had not had an ACTH baseline test done because he said they are worthless, and he refused to do one. Where she had tested normal with his assistant vet in January, I decided not to put her on medication at this time (which would be lifelong and have possible side effects) due to the test being done during the seasonal rise. I did not want to be pressured into something when I was not sure. This vet does not take no for an answer and continued to pressure me until I gave in and purchased the Prascend but I did not give it to her as I was not convinced. She had no other signs of Cushing's other than a loss of topline. She was feeling great, happy, eating well, sound, no issues. Fast forward to being at hospital for the last 2 weeks. She has been home 1 week now. While she was in hospital, she lost a lot of weight as she was on fluids and after surgery, they wanted to be sure she was cleaned out before starting her eating again. She had no food for about 5 days and was on fluids. Around day 5 they were happy with her progress and slowly started feeding her handfuls of hay again and then during the second week she was getting back to eating on a normal schedule again. They also provided me with special instructions and a new diet and feed 4X a day to help her gain her weight back. While we were at hospital I asked if they could do an ACTH test and get their opinion on if my horse had Cushing's and needed medicine or not. I thought this was the perfect time to get a second opinion to help resolve this issue. They did the ACTH baseline test on July 21. Her results were 28. They gave me a paper showing Seasonal interpretation of results by month. For July <15 PPID unlikely, 15-40 is the gray area Equivocal and >40 PPID likely. Now in August <20 PPID unlikely, 20-75 Equivocal, >75 PPID likely. She tested 28 and I would like to find a vet who would be willing to retest that again in the future but my current vet will not. The doctor at the hospital told me that there are 3 areas. The first one, the horse definitely does not have Cushing's, then there is Equivocal he considers the gray area where it is not known and you can do a TRH Stim or retest ACTH again if you want, then the third area is where the test confirms a number greater than the range and PPID is likely. He told me my horse's test was at the low end of Equivocal and he would NOT put her on medicine at this time in fact he said he would not put any horse on medicine unless they tested in the third grouping of PPID likely. I have this paperwork and felt I had the answer I needed for the moment. So now she is home and my regular vet who is very "pro Cushing's" (in fact some people on his site complained about this and the fact he was more concerned with saying their horse had Cushing's, than addressing the problem they called him for) came by today to remove her staples which he did and we both agreed she is doing very well. However he said she has Cushing's and she must be on medicine for it. He sited the test he took last fall which was around 773 and he did not care about the one his assistant did in January which was 80. Also when his assistant did the test, she said if you don't want your horse to have Cushing's, don't let them test her in the fall. My vet that came today, will only test in the fall months when there is seasonal rise. He told me today that ACTH tests are worthless and that the hospital doctors probably don't see a lot of Cushing's cases and that they don't know what they are doing. He said she needs to be on medicine and would not take no for an answer and sold me yet another medicine for this, cyproheptadine. I am following the hospital vets' diet for her and trying very hard to get her weight back on and was concerned Prascend would counter these efforts and possibly get her off her feed, so he sold me the cyproheptadine instead of Prascend. He said this helped appetite. I am not sure if I am going to give her this medicine or not. I have not given her any yet. I felt very pressured into buying this to the point of intimidation. I have now invested $650.00 in 2 medicine purchases to make this vet happy because he will not take no for an answer. He insists she has Cushing's and she must be on medicine. He was not impressed at all with the results the hospital vets gave me or their advice. He feels they do not know about Cushing's. The hospital vet who opened and runs this practice (the hospital is in his name) has been doing this for 50 plus years and is an excellent vet. I want to do what is right for my horse, that is the bottom line. I am trying very hard to advocate for her and do what is best for her. One more thing, her Glucose test and her Insulin test both came out in NORMAL range at the hospital. Again, her ACTH came out 28 and is in the very low end of the middle group or Equivocal range. I am not anxious to put her on a medicine that could have a lot of bad side effects and I am not convinced yet that she needs it. The vets at hospital said they would not put any horse with her results on medicine at this point in time. Meanwhile my regular vet feels they are not experienced with Cushing's and my horse must be on medicine. Also, I really don't like doing these TRH Stim tests so frequently as they suppress her thyroid and I have concerns about that. My current vet wants to only do the TRH Stim and only in the fall when there is a seasonal rise, and he totally refuses to do ACTH tests! I question this plan. In the past he also wanted to give my horse 2 different vaccines that were not core to our area and one was the dog vaccine for Lyme, which is not even equine approved, in fact it was disapproved and pulled from dogs due to problems. He pressured me into 2 vaccines I didn't want, and I finally got him to understand I did not want them and only wanted the core vaccines to my area, and he was not happy. He does seem to be quite a high-pressure type of salesman/vet. He has many good qualities but this high-pressure tactic I am not happy with to the point I am considering finding a new vet who I can work with more compatibly. I am really not sure what to do and I would really appreciate your feedback if you had any on which vet I should listen to and if you think my horse should be on Cushing's medicine or not. I will greatly appreciate any and all viewpoints given. Thank you so much.
 
Sorry to say but I gave up reading this post, it's not to the point.
If you are not happy change vet.
 
Last edited:
Get a new vet, you should never ever feel pressured into buying into any kind of treatment. Vets should be open to discussion on all matters, it's your horse and okay, you need guidance but that just sounds like high pressure sales - which is weird, I've never come across that with any vets I've used but there you go. Definitely register with a different practice.
 
Again, change vet. And for goodness sake stop buying expensive meds to shut him up when you have no intention of giving them. If for some reason it isn't practical to change vet then put on your big girl pants and tell him you will not be medicating for Cushings unless she is symptomatic and neither will you be having more TRH stim tests done.

Your vet shouldn't be pushing an agenda and meds like this, but at the same time it's you that pays him and your horse so you have the final say.
 
My horse fell into the ‘uncertain’ range in the Cushing tests done, so I talked this through with my vet, looked at the possible symptoms (he had none) and together we decided to wait and retest in a years time. Sadly a year never came round as he died of unrelated causes in the meantime. The point was that the decision was mine to make. My vet gave me the results, talked about pros and cons of treatment and left me to make my decision. If you feel bullied and pressurised by your vet, there is obviously a problem. My skeptical side wonders if he is making money from the medication if you are buying it from him?
 
Change vet.
Re the cushings, many older horses do have cushings and many only have one clinical symptom initially and the acth test is inferior to the TRH test, but either way to get the most accurate results they have to be done at the right time of year, if he doesn’t see that then stop using him.
 
@Dori2021 <sigh>. I am so sorry but I tried reading through your post three times and still couldn’t figure everything out.

For starters, breaking that long dissertation into paragraphs would be a huge help in the reader comprehension department.

What I think I gather is that you have one vet who knows everything about cushings without running tests. Use another vet.

I don’t know what country you are in so can’t comment on test results you do have.

Any time I have had ACTH (I won’t permit TRH) done on my horses, I TELL the vet I want the tests read by Cornell University and that I want a copy of the test results since it’s my money. I prefer Cornell because they they have a column with the horse’s actual results right alongside a column showing the norm. A ten year old could read and understand the results.

Joker (RIP) was IR & Cushings. He was on half tablet of Prascend daily and it controlled the Cushings. A 160 pack of Prascend cost me $142, although I’m sure it’s gone up since Joker passed in February.

It sounds like your bottom line is to find another general vet that isn’t trying to push products on you without running tests first.

To reiterate, please break your posts into paragraphs — it makes for much easier reading making more folks inclined to want to offer suggestions🤠
 
@Dori2021 <sigh>. I am so sorry but I tried reading through your post three times and still couldn’t figure everything out.

For starters, breaking that long dissertation into paragraphs would be a huge help in the reader comprehension department.

What I think I gather is that you have one vet who knows everything about cushings without running tests. Use another vet.

I don’t know what country you are in so can’t comment on test results you do have.

Any time I have had ACTH (I won’t permit TRH) done on my horses, I TELL the vet I want the tests read by Cornell University and that I want a copy of the test results since it’s my money. I prefer Cornell because they they have a column with the horse’s actual results right alongside a column showing the norm. A ten year old could read and understand the results.

Joker (RIP) was IR & Cushings. He was on half tablet of Prascend daily and it controlled the Cushings. A 160 pack of Prascend cost me $142, although I’m sure it’s gone up since Joker passed in February.

It sounds like your bottom line is to find another general vet that isn’t trying to push products on you without running tests first.

To reiterate, please break your posts into paragraphs — it makes for much easier reading making more folks inclined to want to offer suggestions🤠
Thank you for your response. Can you tell me why you will not permit TRH done on your horses. Do you feel it harms them?
 
Change vet.
Re the cushings, many older horses do have cushings and many only have one clinical symptom initially and the acth test is inferior to the TRH test, but either way to get the most accurate results they have to be done at the right time of year, if he doesn’t see that then stop using him.
I cannot understand why he wants to do the TRH Stim in the fall as opposed to December through June. He just said this again yesterday. It is almost like he wants another high result so he can say she has to be on medicine for Cushing's. And he wants to come and give her rabies and EWT and West Nile all in 3 weeks after she has dropped so much weight during this ordeal. My mare is a senior and I feel like we are not seeing eye to eye on things with my at home vet. I am still looking at all my options and what to do. He is a great emergency vet and has a lot of good points, but he can also wear you down with his insistence when you don't agree with him. He says the TRH is more sensitive but even the makers of the test say not to give it during the seasonal rise. The ACTH test appears to be helpful also and my vet from hospital gave me a chart to interpret the results during each month of the year. The hospital vets were so helpful. Thank you for your response.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
Get a new vet, you should never ever feel pressured into buying into any kind of treatment. Vets should be open to discussion on all matters, it's your horse and okay, you need guidance but that just sounds like high pressure sales - which is weird, I've never come across that with any vets I've used but there you go. Definitely register with a different practice.
Thank you for your feedback. I read that selling medicines and medical creams etc... the vets depend on this extra income.
 
My horse fell into the ‘uncertain’ range in the Cushing tests done, so I talked this through with my vet, looked at the possible symptoms (he had none) and together we decided to wait and retest in a years time. Sadly a year never came round as he died of unrelated causes in the meantime. The point was that the decision was mine to make. My vet gave me the results, talked about pros and cons of treatment and left me to make my decision. If you feel bullied and pressurised by your vet, there is obviously a problem. My skeptical side wonders if he is making money from the medication if you are buying it from him?
I am so sorry for the loss of your horse. That is so unbelievably hard to go through. I like your idea of a retest in a years time since he was in the uncertain range. I really like that idea. That would give her time to recover from her colic surgery and hopefully gain weight back and get stronger. My vet definitely pressures me to buy things. And he wears me down pushing things until I give in to get him to stop. I have never been this pressured by a vet before in all my life. I have to really be ready to say NO to him and stand by it and psych myself up for this before he arrives on the next visit. He also has a lot of good points but I was very surprised on how he criticized the hospital vets because they did not agree with him. It leaves me wondering who to trust.
 
Again, change vet. And for goodness sake stop buying expensive meds to shut him up when you have no intention of giving them. If for some reason it isn't practical to change vet then put on your big girl pants and tell him you will not be medicating for Cushings unless she is symptomatic and neither will you be having more TRH stim tests done.

Your vet shouldn't be pushing an agenda and meds like this, but at the same time it's you that pays him and your horse so you have the final say.
Excellent advice. Thank you. She lost a lot of weight during this last colic and hospitalization. She was on fluids only for a week and not allowed to eat and she really dropped a lot of weight. I think he is attributing this to Cushing's. We joke that he wears Cushing's glasses because he believes that most older horses and some younger horses have Cushings. I have had so many different results. I don't want to have these constant TRH Stim tests done. Do you think that harms her by having them so often. I am not comfortable with this. Thank you again for your response.
 
Sorry to say but I gave up reading this post, it's not to the point.
If you are not happy change vet.
Sorry about that. I was so tired I didn't even think I could write it and there were so many details to this. I tried to get in as much as I could but yes it was rambling. Thank you for your response.
 
Again, change vet. And for goodness sake stop buying expensive meds to shut him up when you have no intention of giving them. If for some reason it isn't practical to change vet then put on your big girl pants and tell him you will not be medicating for Cushings unless she is symptomatic and neither will you be having more TRH stim tests done.

Your vet shouldn't be pushing an agenda and meds like this, but at the same time it's you that pays him and your horse so you have the final say.
Thank you for reminding me of that. I have never had this problem with a vet before. He was so helpful in arranging her to go to hospital and also in emergency visits before hospital but he constantly pushes Cushing's medicine and wants to take TRH STim tests during the seasonal rise which really, really surprises me. I am trying to decide what to do. Thank you very much for your input and for your response.
 
Get a new vet, you should never ever feel pressured into buying into any kind of treatment. Vets should be open to discussion on all matters, it's your horse and okay, you need guidance but that just sounds like high pressure sales - which is weird, I've never come across that with any vets I've used but there you go. Definitely register with a different practice.
Thank you for your response. It is a difficult situation for sure.
 
@Dori2021 <sigh>. I am so sorry but I tried reading through your post three times and still couldn’t figure everything out.

For starters, breaking that long dissertation into paragraphs would be a huge help in the reader comprehension department.

What I think I gather is that you have one vet who knows everything about cushings without running tests. Use another vet.

I don’t know what country you are in so can’t comment on test results you do have.

Any time I have had ACTH (I won’t permit TRH) done on my horses, I TELL the vet I want the tests read by Cornell University and that I want a copy of the test results since it’s my money. I prefer Cornell because they they have a column with the horse’s actual results right alongside a column showing the norm. A ten year old could read and understand the results.

Joker (RIP) was IR & Cushings. He was on half tablet of Prascend daily and it controlled the Cushings. A 160 pack of Prascend cost me $142, although I’m sure it’s gone up since Joker passed in February.

It sounds like your bottom line is to find another general vet that isn’t trying to push products on you without running tests first.

To reiterate, please break your posts into paragraphs — it makes for much easier reading making more folks inclined to want to offer suggestions🤠
Good information about Cornell. I believe my vet uses Cornell but I will have to double check. He wanted to start my senior mare on 1 tablet Prascend daily, not a half or a quarter and work up. My mare's glucose and insulin are normal. It is just her ACTH that was taken July 21 that was 28 which is at the low end of the middle or equivocal range. And taken in July it is possible that was elevated a bit. I am in the United States. I am seriously considering finding a new vet.
 
I thought you might be in the U.S. by the words you use🤠

1. Things may have changed since my horse was diagnosed with IR in 2012 and foundered. I won’t allow any tests that involve injecting anything for fear it could bring on founder in an already compromised horse. That’s the way it was back then, things may have changed.

The ACTH test has always been accurate and is another reason I have always insisted on Cornell doing the testing. Labs read differently, so comparing the numbers from different labs could be confusing.

I always tried to have the ACTH done in the same month in the spring, however studies have come a long way since 2012 and a baseline has also been established for testing in the Fall, when a horse is starting to store fat for the winter.

In 2012, I had three Tennessee Walkers, which are high on the list for being predisposed to metabolic issues. Two of them had metabolic issues, one did not. Back then the University of Michigan was conducting studies on metabolic horses and was asking for volunteers. Since my three were all registered TWH’s, I enrolled them; my geneural vet who went on to do mostly lameness issues had a foundered IR mare and was ecstatic to help. He bent over backward to help when MSU asked for blood draws by a certain date.

MSU allowed me to opt out of dosing my horses with a large amount of kayro syrup to see if it would affect their insulin. Joker was already severely rotated from founder and I wasn’t risking it.

It cost me quite a bit to do that but it was my hope the results would be helpful in publishing facts to help owners manage their IR horses.

My two metabolic TWH’s passed eight years apart, when they were both 27, and both to a big unexpected colic. The TWH that was the healthy “Control” horse is still with me and turned 28 in April.

His last ACTH was in 2019 and had crept to the high/normal range. I had planned to do an ACTH this past spring but I lost Joker in February , was trying to find a companion for Rusty who was now alone, and my usually organized self unthreaded for a few months. I believe Rusty might need a small dose of Prascend but his very early symptoms are not causing him grief, so I‘m waiting until next spring to have him retested.

I can say that, IMHO, your vet is nuts and needs to retire from veterinary practice. PLEASE find another clinic that is not associated with this guy.

Horses whose Cortisol level is barely past the high/normal do NOT need one pill daily. The pills are 1mg and can easily be cut in half and fed 1/2 pill daily. Prascend is some potent stuff when one realizes the job it does at only 1mg.

If your horse has lost a lot of weight, there are other things to consider and could be a mix of any or several, including the age of the horse:

1. Dental issues.
2. Complete diet overhaul.
3. Worms.
4. ULCERS.
5. Cancer.

I know there are many areas in the U.S. (I’m in Middle Tennessee) that are a desert when it comes to vets and farrier’s. Hopefully you live in area where you have a choice of clinics. My biggest issue is an equine dentist. The vet/dentist I use that really knows her stuff is 40 miles away and it’s not an easy 40 miles. She charges per mile whatever the IRS allows, so it’s $140 just to get her to my barn🤯. This Fall I need to have her look at Rusty and his new companion who is a long 26, so I’m looking at $300-$400 dollars <— another reason I’m waiting until next spring for an ACTH test on Rusty.

*******

If you care to lay out your horse’s current diet regimen, including pasture & hay, whether she is boarded and will they help you if you change her feed regimen, we can try to offer some input but PLEASE find another vet before your current vet does serious health damage to your horse:).
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
Do vets make money on prescriptions?


Most human drugs are purchased at pharmacies, but the nation's 90,000 veterinarians sell most of the nation's pet medicines. And they make money on every prescription they dispense. About 58 percent of all pet-medicine sales take place at veterinary clinics, according to market researcher Packaged Facts.Dec 18, 2014

Drug companies' loose purse strings court vets - IndyStar​

 
newrider.com