Position

I was looking back at your photo's to try to get a better idea and I wondered the same as @Ale - if you're tensing up? as sometimes you leg/stirrup length look fine and others your stirrups look too short or you're sitting too far back or both:confused: Could you try lengthening you're stirrups even just by one whole on a session when she's not too turbo to see if it brings your seat forward a bit?
Oddly over here the saddle is fitted to the rider first and then the horse, so for example my bums a 17" and as far as the French are concerned thats the size saddle I have to have and thats that:confused::confused: I couldn't possibly fit into a 16,5":eek: and I'm 5'4" too with a 146cm Connemara & 17" monoflap - sports now I'm really confusedo_O:p:p
 
Yes @orbvalley I think the stirrups are too short which is sitting me too far back. I don't feel like I'm tensing up, she's not the sort of horse you can be tense on, it wouldn't end well. I think I'm going to have to go for longer stirrups and work on my legs being secure. I wish I could have a 17.5"! I rode her in my 17.5 stubben before the ideal and didn't have this problem, loved that saddle!
 
I have the same problem and it drives me nuts too. RI is trying to train me out of it but in truth I don't feel half as secure in the saddle if I ride in a more correct position. I also have the same issue in that my saddle doesn't really accommodate my leg length if I want to ride short enough to be able to touch Raf's sides, but Raf can't take a bigger saddle. Although I agree you can't use it as a total excuse for bad position, I do look much better when I ride OH's big bodied 16.2 in his big saddle - my legs can rest against his sides which feels much more stable.

I do wonder how important a really correct position is for a leisure rider like me though. Plus when you see the old-school hunting folk riding out in their hunt (chair) seat it makes you wonder if it's just fashion that has changed. They seem to cope perfectly well in their hunting position and if it's good enough for them who am I to argue lol.

In fact I have to admit my main desire to have a lovely position is that so I look good in the photos :p

I think it is only important for your own posture the hunt seat has a collapsed spine some of the old pictures actually looked hunched which is not good for your back. but if that is what is comfortable for you and you feel secure why change it as long as the horse can work correctly underneath you.

@Lissie I do think your stirups are too short which is making your legs swing forward, which is turn makes you push your bum back so you can get forward out the seat to jump the fences in what to you feels like a safe position. Again nothing wrong with it if your feel safe. I for one ride very long and still long when jumping as this is my safe position.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bodshi and Lissie
I'd say predominantly saddle from the photos you've posted, though maybe if you tried not pushing your heels down so hard then your leg wouldn't be pushed so far forward? Another thought, and I don't know if anything can be done about it, but could the stirrup bar be moved back so your leg was more under you & you weren't pushed so far back in the seat?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie
@OwnedbyChanter I don't feel safe so I think I'm going to try dropping the stirrups and seeing what difference that makes. I thin maybe I'm thinking I need to put them up when I actually don't.

@carthorse I am going to get a saddler out at some point when she's back in full work and will mention that. Yep looks like I am pushing too hard down in heels but instructor shouts at me to sit up/back/weight in heels so I think I'm doing this too much. She's not an easy ride though, lovely, fun and I wouldn't change one thing about her but when you first get on her if you don't know her you think god this is a lot of horse to ride. I don't think she'd take on the stuff she does if she rode "normally though" got to be a little bit crazy to jump what she does so boldly.
 
I know your saddle well and have a good idea of how it feels, you look how the owner of one of the horses at work who has the saddle looks when he goes XC. He has super short stirrups but is very tall and alot of that is thigh length and ideally he needs an 18" but horse could only take a 17.5. When he does dressage he rides longer and doesnt have this problem at all. I know you find the shorter stirrups help when she is in super charge mode but im inclined to say they look too short even for that and id work on trying to get down a couple holes if you can.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie
@OwnedbyChanter I don't feel safe so I think I'm going to try dropping the stirrups and seeing what difference that makes. I thin maybe I'm thinking I need to put them up when I actually don't.

@carthorse I am going to get a saddler out at some point when she's back in full work and will mention that. Yep looks like I am pushing too hard down in heels but instructor shouts at me to sit up/back/weight in heels so I think I'm doing this too much. She's not an easy ride though, lovely, fun and I wouldn't change one thing about her but when you first get on her if you don't know her you think god this is a lot of horse to ride. I don't think she'd take on the stuff she does if she rode "normally though" got to be a little bit crazy to jump what she does so boldly.


There is a big difference from weight in heals and forcing your heels down which is what it looks like you are doing. Plus the heals down comments works when then strip length is correct as the action of putting your weight in your heals should make sure they stay under you on the jump not swinging in front of the movement or swinging up the quarters.

Lovely horse
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie
@OwnedbyChanter yes I think your right I think I'm hearing heels down and pushing them down too much with stirrups too long which is rising my seat up. Thank you, she is my pride and joy, I'm very lucky to have her.

@mystiquemalaika I was hoping you'd comment as know you've ridden in an impala. Yes I would of preferred the 17.5" but at 15hh with a short back she can't take longer. Stirrups are going down and I'll just cling on for dear life :p
 
For the future, a good saddler can normally take 1/2" out of the gusset in the back of the panel, to make a 17.5" seat saddle, fit the horses back like a 17" saddle :) they often do this for native ponies, or it is one of the features of native pony saddles.
 
For the future, a good saddler can normally take 1/2" out of the gusset in the back of the panel, to make a 17.5" seat saddle, fit the horses back like a 17" saddle :) they often do this for native ponies, or it is one of the features of native pony saddles.

I had a 17.5 made shorter because it was just a tad longer for ginger.

@Lissie I have the impala jump as well and love it. I will see if I can find a jump picture
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie
For the future, a good saddler can normally take 1/2" out of the gusset in the back of the panel, to make a 17.5" seat saddle, fit the horses back like a 17" saddle :) they often do this for native ponies, or it is one of the features of native pony saddles.

Very useful to know, thanks for the tip.
 
@Lissie yes he has the very same problem as you, the extra 1/2" would have made just enough difference for him. Im 5'4" same as you but shorter in the thigh, my knee joint when riding short sits further forward than yours under the thigh block so i think judging by you and the lad who rides Bally it is your thigh length causing some issues.Bally really can take a heck of a pull and has a power jump and was in the past somewhat of a rodeo, i cant get away with a neck strap i feel you have to lean forward to reach it which in turn sets my arse backwards :rolleyes: i got a lovely rolled leather strap for him that attaches to the front D rings, its very comfy in the hand and positioned there it doesnt put you into a more forward seat position it lets you sit up straight or even back when needed and keep a better shoulder,hip, knee position but gives a bloody good anchor when needed.
The stirrups bar on the impala is set more forward as alot of event/jump saddles are but not so far forward as the black country event we have at work so you will always have a degree of fighting to get your leg further under you than you would in a dressage but id say its still not so far forward that you cant do a decent dressage test in it. Id get some photos of you with your stirrups 1 hole and 2 holes down to compare and i think you will see alot of difference, its then a case of training yourself to ride her a little different with a longer stirrups.
@Jessey the Impala is actually one of the shortest footprints compared to seat size, Lottie must be like Bally in just how compact she is as he is 16.1 and cant go beyond the 17.5 in the impala, we sturggled with 17" in nearly all other makes, 16.5" been the better in most. Gotta love a short backed beastie when it comes to saddles :p
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey and Lissie
The saddle is definitely not helping your position but I do think that dropping your stirrups a couple of holes and working on getting a more secure position with your leg more beneath you may be the way forward. The thing is that stirrup length is very much a personal thing and sometimes what other people think you "should" be doing isn't actually what will work best for you as an individual. My boss was always telling me my stirrups should be shorter for jumping, but like you I am long in the thigh (though not tall!) and always found that - whatever saddle I was in - putting them up to a length that should have been correct didn't actually suit me at all. As you can see from the pics I always jump with a longer leg than is "traditional" but I find it just suits me better. In all of these pics I was in GP saddles, I just can't get the hang of jumping in jumping saddles as my thigh length always becomes an issue! Especially on Annie, we have the same issue as you regarding the size of saddle she can take.

18341959_10155038697700935_8412995711554312581_n.jpg 11391384_10153246240595935_886070386655936634_n.jpg 11129552_10153097804230935_4069289522373035922_n.jpg 10464339_10152420931555935_3397286784888173791_n.jpg
 
@OwnedbyChanter fab photos! You both look great, he gives those plenty of room. Love all your rosettes too :)

@mystiquemalaika Damm having long legs! Yes she's just so forward, can be quite strong. I still remember her old owner when I tried her saying "You have to hold on!" I sometimes hold my breastplate which is in front of the saddle, I pull on that when I want to slow down too, it saves getting in her face too much.

Yes I think the Impala is quite big seat for length as in other saddles I was looking at a 16.5" and there's no way my daddy long legs would fit!
 
@joosie thanks for photos, always good to look at how I should be doing it! I can see you're long in the thigh too, I'm not tall either. I am definitely going to try dropping the stirrups and see how I feel, I'm sure it will take a bit of getting used to I think I might find it better than current set up.
 
newrider.com