Position

Ill see if anyone is around tomorrow to get a photo of me in the impala, it will be just in the yard but may give you an idea seeing a shorter thigh length on it and what i feel as though im riding very short in.

Lottie is fab though, we may just need to shrink your legs :p
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie
Some more photos on other horses, I don’t think I look as bad? But I do think I look like I’ve got longer stirrups.
396779_450766651630189_265140865_n.jpg 1621962_741626269210891_1607856992_n234.jpg better position 1.png better position 2.png
 
Thanks @mystiquemalaika that would be really helpful. Everyone always says how lucky I am but I just find them a pain riding. Ahh Lottie is just the best, she is sound, perky and healing! Hopefully won't be too long and I take her for a potter although she doesn't potter anywhere lol.
 
I feel your pain! I got away with murder in terms of my seat pre Amber but she makes me feel like a beginner. Her movement is so big - I can't sit to her trot, let alone her canter. I am often behind the movement and my seat is so insecure I fell off her the other day for no reason other than she jumped massive and landed steeply as she flicked her back end up.

I am on a mission to improve my seat and have read widely/talked to instructors/ videoed myself (ouch). I think I sit a little like you - chair seat. I am absolutely no expert so feel free to totally disregard the following, but from what I have been told/ what I have read the trouble with chair seat is the tendency to be behind the movement and then to 'waterski'. Also to have the lower leg too far forward which means your centre of balance is pointing backwards when ideally it should be directed downwards. So whether you are in forward seat or not your centre of balance should be directed downwards underneath your hips or feet and over the horse's centre of balance which is directly under the twist of the saddle at the strongest point of his back. Also the horse is moving more the further away from their own centre of balance (under the twist of the saddle)you sit, so you get thrown around more if you are sitting too far back.

I have been told to think about what would happen if the horse underneath you disappeared? If you are sitting in chair seat, you'd land on your heels then fall on your ar$e. In a more classical 3 point dressage seat, you'd land lightly on your feet and remain balanced. So the ideal is to make sure you are in an athletic self-balanced position - which can be a classic dressage seat but equally applies to SJ, XC, racing or trail riding.

That looks to me like how the following people are riding: Ben Maher, Michael Jung, William Fox Pitt, Frankie Dettori & Buck Brannaman. Good luck.

benmaher_oscar.jpg


michi.jpg


Chilli-Morning-WFP-1-2.jpg


FrankieDettoriGrandera.jpg


marmite_1_orig.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie
X-posted with Joosie but she is also sitting like that - you can see it very clearly in the first picture. Her weight is over her feet and over the horse's centre of gravity. Her centre of gravity is downwards not backwards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie
@KP nut Yep totally understand what your saying I think I am behind the movement. Just hard finding how to improve, I only really jump hunting atm due to no light in the evenings and it's hard to think about when you're hurtling down to a rail, wall, gate, hedge lol. See William Fox Pitt has long thighs yet he's got it right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
Goodness knows where gravity's taking me atm but I wouldn't be landing on my feet that's for sure! So frustrating as I don't think I've ever been this bad before!
 
It's hard and I don't really know how I am going to improve either. But I can't jump unless I do so needs must... I am booking a lunge lesson on someone else's horse and am riding Max without stirrups. No way can I ride Amber without stirrups !
 
I don't know how to improve it either! I have been hacking in walk and bits of trot without stirrups but it's hard because of her movement and there's no way I could attempt canter! I can happily trot and canter other horses without stirrups though so going to have to pinch a friends horse I think for some practice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KP nut
Just thinking about what you said about her being a strong horse that you have to hold her, I think sometimes this, especially with a small rider can encourage the feet to jut forwards to give you something to 'brace' with so you don't pull yourself out of the front door, just thought I'd mention it as you said you feel your seat has got worse and wondered if perhaps lottie has encouraged this?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie
What buggers my position is my stirrups, i have to have them too short other wise i am way below his belly! (Meks it sound like i am riding a shetland haha) so i cant have my legs where they should be, they are more forward, if i could add length to the stirrups id be able to put them back to where they should be. This throws me off balance in trot, then he has this other trot he does and tries to pass off as canter and it's impossible to sit to or rise too! And doing without sturrips, well hes just so wide its like trying to ride a dining table! Anyone can advise me on anything, greatly appreciated (sorry for thread jacking)
 
Just thinking about what you said about her being a strong horse that you have to hold her, I think sometimes this, especially with a small rider can encourage the feet to jut forwards to give you something to 'brace' with so you don't pull yourself out of the front door, just thought I'd mention it as you said you feel your seat has got worse and wondered if perhaps lottie has encouraged this?

Could be yes, she is very onward bound and can get strong. So even though I've ridden strong before, my last horse was snaffle mouthed and very different.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
Yes the pulling leads to the water-skiing! That's us too. I am trying to re-discover my core in order to not just brace and pull.
 
Haha no can't brace against her, I found that out when I ended up almost horizontal leaning back trying to slow her out hunting once. I should have a strong core I can do 200 sit ups at once all properly, plank for ages etc. Just don't sit right :rolleyes:

Thanks for all the input everyone, I will try stirrups down and update. Not sure when I'll be back on her, she's sound though and happy on her walks so hopefully it won't be long. It'll just be hacking to start with but that will give me a good chance to get used to riding longer again.
 
Haha no can't brace against her, I found that out when I ended up almost horizontal leaning back trying to slow her out hunting once. I should have a strong core I can do 200 sit ups at once all properly, plank for ages etc. Just don't sit right :rolleyes:

Thanks for all the input everyone, I will try stirrups down and update. Not sure when I'll be back on her, she's sound though and happy on her walks so hopefully it won't be long. It'll just be hacking to start with but that will give me a good chance to get used to riding longer again.
200 situps!!! Christ, its hurtingme just reading it haha
 
totally understand your pain with this, i also sat in quite a hunt seat for many years, having learned to ride over 30 years ago :(

however, i would say for jumping what you have there is a nice safety seat, really, you want hip, shoulder and heel in line on the flat BUT go to any Mary King clinic and she will tell you leg forward and bum back over a fence. A secure lower leg over a fence isnt the same as on the flat. loads of examples-
mary king cross country

I found a huge help when I changed saddles. I have a BC Wexford for hacking and FW which helps me keep me in the right position but gives me room to move over a jump. For FW though I have had to switch to a dressage saddle.
 
Last edited:
That's interesting CA... You're right she is in chair seat a LOT over fences. And far be it for me to question Mary King's seat. BUT google Pippa Funnel or Emily King or Jeanette Brakewell and they do not sit like that often. I suspect on mahoosive XC fences you sometimes are moving your point of balance back and forth as you take off/ land so a snap shot is hard to see where the balances are but I do think the others look more balanced in the main. MK looks like she is being left behind! And not helping her horse as much. But really, what the hell do I know!!
 
Very interesting - just googled Mark Todd, as he has long thighs compared to his horses, and he seems to have a similar position to Mary King. I don't know who to attempt to emulate now! I quite like William Fox Pitt's position - think I might try riding with longer leathers too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
From a Telegraph sports article on Mary King...

"Zara Phillips (said Mary King was) unique. Mainly it was her style of riding, very backward in the saddle, long reins, but gets the job done."

So it seems less usual. But clearly works for her. Trouble is it doesn't work for me!!

Who is that show jumper whose legs fly out and up backwards when jumping? Sometimes top riders seem to break all the rules and get the job done anyway. But I am surprised she teaches that way. Her daughter didn't listen!!
 
newrider.com