Position

See I don't think Mark Todd does look like MK... Most of the time he is balanced over his feet and over the horse's centre of balance...

upload_2018-2-6_19-14-43.jpeg


upload_2018-2-6_19-14-29.jpeg

upload_2018-2-6_19-15-8.jpeg

Maybe too much so!!! An MK seat might have saved him here.....

Mark-Todd-Badminton-20161.jpg
 
@KP it is a well know ‘mary king safety seat’ ;) she is most definitely not being left behind, she’s in complete balance. It is very well known that lower leg forward over a fence = secure. At the least, your leg should stay on the girth as your bum moves back. The only way you are going to achieve a FW heel-hip-shoulder line like this over a fence is if your lower leg swings back, which is absolutely what you dont want.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
See I don't think Mark Todd does look like MK... Most of the time he is balanced over his feet and over the horse's centre of balance...

No I see what you mean. His position certainly isn't as extreme but in those I looked at he seemed to be in the chair seat. However looking at his SJ position it's totally different, so maybe the XC position is totally usual - I know nothing!

images9SZTF9W5.jpg imagesCOU8Y9QS.jpg imagesSIQYXGZC.jpg untitled.png
 
@KP it is a well know ‘mary king safety seat’ ;) she is most definitely not being left behind, she’s in complete balance. It is very well known that lower leg forward over a fence = secure. At the least, your leg should stay on the girth as your bum moves back. The only way you are going to achieve a FW heel-hip-shoulder line like this over a fence is if your lower leg swings back, which is absolutely what you dont want.

My old RI taught me to 'show the fence the soles of your feet' - not that I ever seemed to be able to achieve it.
 
See William Fox Pitt has long thighs yet he's got it right.
Find out what saddle it is. To me it doesn't look to have huge knee rolls. Yours could be a hindrance becayse it doesn't look as if you can actually go forwards with your seat as your leg will be over the rolls.
I can move / change mine and that makes so much difference.
 
The RI said that my saddle ( in use in that day) hindered the hunt seat that he wanted me in.
I did manage to get that shoulder hip and heel classical seat though. :D:p


32702-1279047402-8f1f89ef86f25dfea276aaf5ac297305.jpg 32699-1279047298-d4fb3740b5ea7d877b6de183496e26b9.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie
Mary still manages a sweet FW position :)
5ma6OLo.jpg


i worked so much on my jumping position a few years back (before MiniCA really), never did have it right really! Now Im working more on getting that hip-shoulder-heel line on the flat and it’s even harder but less chance of hitting the deck trying :D :D

in the first pic my lower leg has swung back a bit, it could have done with being on the girth - given the amount of times I fell off, perhaps a bit forward even and thus a more defensive seat haha
4DZo1sK.jpg


i got it a better here though, the hands just needed to follow through a bit more but he had the nastiest stop in him and if i even *thought* about dropping him before a fence I was toast, so it was a hard balance to find
q6TR6JT.jpg


and on my mini 13hh hander a couple of years ago - different saddle obviously and it suited me really well, i found it gave me a good position on the flat as well, it was a GFS event
82dCeaN.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
My RI always tells me (its a French saying) "Better taking a taxi" (getting left behind) "than a georgette" (going ahead of the jump)

How on earth William fox stays in the saddle with the thighs I've never known:eek::D
 
No I see what you mean. His position certainly isn't as extreme but in those I looked at he seemed to be in the chair seat. However looking at his SJ position it's totally different, so maybe the XC position is totally usual - I know nothing!

View attachment 91381 View attachment 91382 View attachment 91383 View attachment 91384
The chair seat I see as the hunt seat/ defense for xc as normal.
Xc is unlevel ground, the landing higher or lower than your take off.
I tend to sit up before I need to but that's after riding something that bucked, so needed to be back in the saddle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CharliesAngel
I guess the key is how secure you feel in whichever seat. The further back you sit the more movement you need to cope with. And there is a tendency to balance on your reins and hollow the horse which may not help him jump. On the other hand gripping with knees while legs go back is going to lead you to toppled off the front! So I think you can be balanced/secure in different positions. I am not secure in my current position so am working on changing it. If I felt secure I'd leave well alone.

Katie falls off a lot less often now that she has a secure seat, balanced over her feet.

21984966_2029856900579033_643048490741530624_n(1).jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie
That's how I feel @KP nut I don't feel secure in my position so need to change it if I felt secure I wouldn't be so bothered. I think my main problem might be I've hitched my stirrups up thinking I need to ride short but actually need to be longer to accommodate my long thighs. I'm then pushing too hard down in my heels which is lifting my bum up slightly instead of sitting deeply. I don't mind a slight chair seat as all I do now is hunt, hack and cross county school, fun ride. But I need to be in balance and secure for when it goes wrong.

Really interesting looking at the pro's positions, off to google to some more and see if I can find videos.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
@Lissie, just a thought, do you think you put your weight into your feet? Try getting more weight onto your seat bones and yes ride longer, in fact can you go without stirrups more ?
 
I would say that saddle isn't fitting you at this length. You look to be already over the knee roll?
Fine for stationery but the minute that horse moves you have no way to move with it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
@CharliesAngel could be yes. I take my feet out stirrups a lot hacking, I mainly do walk but have tried trotting and I can sit to her but she's incredibly bouncy and fast so it's hard. I have to be careful because I don't want to fall off on the road. Not sure if she or I would cope without stirrups in the school.
 
I would say that saddle isn't fitting you at this length. You look to be already over the knee roll?
Fine for stationery but the minute that horse moves you have no way to move with it.

So it's not just I'm an awful rider it doesn't feel right then lol.
Here's another photo from another angle.
face2.jpg
 
I would say it almost looks to be making you slouch and feet are forwards already before you even start.

It's about feel though, and how you feel not what you look like. The are so many variables with our build and their build and movement that text book positions don't always work. If you don't feel secure you will ride more braced.
Nothing wrong with you as a rider if I sat on Lottie I will fall straight off the back if she trotted. I get flung sometimes with mine :D
 
newrider.com