Question about hands

I too have that problem and I think if your legs are coming on and off as you say, then maybe you're a little unbalanced from time to time and compensate by fiddling with the reins in an attempt to regain balance. All I can say is that I hold the reins with my hands a little ways apart and try to concentrate on keeping them there , which is hard to do and keep a relaxed shoulder. If I concentrate on my legs and keep them softly about the sides of the horse and look directly ahead between the horses ears and also push my bellybutton that way when I rise, I find my balance doesn't come off as much and I'm much better at keeping my hands still. But it seems like I really, really have to keep my focus or as soon as i lose it, my hands start going everywhere again. i think it will just take alot of practise.

oh dear, I don't think that was much help!! its hard to put it into words. I just think that as balance and an independent seat get better than quieter hands will result, but its going to take a while for me, cause everytime I lose balance or the horse comes off the rail or something, the first thing I do is try to use my hands, which I know is wrong, but its just automatic.
 
im no expert but i know someone who does this very badly! i wudnt say nethin 2 her cos shed take it badly but i think it mite help to be lunged without reins. or even stirrups aswel? if u do jumping, jumping without reind and stirrups over small things is amazing for balance and confidence. probably not much help but i tried ;)
 
A good exercise is standing up in your stirrups and finding your true balance. Sitting trot is also a good exercise, but you can teach yourself to counter balance, by adapting your seat, many folk lean back.

Another good exercise is stand 6 strides, rise 6 strides, sit 6 strides. Doesn't really matter how many strides you choose to work on its your preferance.

Once you've mastered how to stay in tune with the trot, remain in balance without fiddling with the contact and use your legs at the same time - you'll be in a position to establish a rhythm.

Don't work in straight lines, figure of 8, serpentine, circle. If the stride is horrible, don't persevere. Drop back to walk, gain a relaxed, forward going stride and start again.

Lesley
 
that's it cochise...If i ever come to NZ or you ever get the the US i'm sticking a pole behind your back and one in your hands to keep them steady!!!!<~~~~~I HATE this btw...LOL, luckily i haven't had to do it in a long time!

LOL...I do the same thing, but usually my instructor yells to stop fidgeting so then i concentrate on keeping my hands still...:p
 
I think its lazy in behind horse syndrome, and rider worrying about where horses head is syndrome rather than lack of balance or relying on horses reins and mouth for balance. I have just gotten impatient and really really naughty in my flatwork over the years. My seat is independent, I just noticed the whole fiddling, and annoying my horse thing the other day, when I came to school and thought crossing my stirrups was a good idea. I looked down at my hands and concentrated on them, and I know the dont even rise and fall with me when I rise and fall. The leg on and off thing isnt helping Cheeky move forward into a constant contact. I am really nitpicking at my riding now lol
I think I should define what I mean by fiddling: Constant outside rein: good. Inside rein very naughty...check on Cheeky's rein, he isnt listening with that head of his and softening so I check more, then the jaw softens and I soften. But because I dont keep the leg constantly on in rising trot, his head comes up. But in sitting trot, he comes through from behind nicely, and he comes through onto the bit softly, because I am keeping my hands more still, and softer.
I think its my terrible impatience, with establishing a contact rather than balance.
The advice given is really good anyway, thanks! I just didnt describe myself very well!
Iris, I am scared!!:eek: hehe if you want to do the dressage on Cheeky, go for it, I will just do the hacking and jumping!;)
My horse is a saint!:D
 
hey i used 2 ave ** same prob. my balance has improved and id otn do it anymore.ask for a lunge lesson or ride with no reins then no stirupps then both.do it ova trotting poles asweel.put your arm striaght out to the side.also try and youch you toes. hope that helped pm me casue i got more
luv tasha xxxxxxxxxx
 
It's not a balance thing, or a saddle problem! It's a contact problem! I have the exact same problem and my instructor is always on at me about it:rolleyes:

It didn't help that I was riding a piggy horse who keeos snatching her head away from my contact. Before anyone jumps on me, she's had her teeth done, saddle checked etc!! Our horses are not mistreated! ;)
 
I'm not sureh ow much this will help, but try one handed riding. Tie your reins into a knot so they don't get in the way, and hold them with one hand. With your other hand, put it on your head, behind your back, on the horses neck, or straight out to the side, hold it up, try to write something in the air, etc etc whilst keeping the hand on the reins as still as you can. Then try with your other hand. Again, i'm not sure how much this will help, but it's fun!
 
Thanks Freedom Star, but I know that its me being naughty and nagging his head down. But I was trying to figure out why I only nagged in rising trot, and not in sitting. He will soften his jaw without me nagging at all when I am sitting. But I am just super naughty at rising trot. I have been working really hard on not nagging while rising and I have a happier horse now :)
 
hey :D, Only read the first post, but then i got really excited and wanted to relpy :D

Ok, I have the same thing!!!, I would rather ride with no stirrups. lol.

I was eventing Charlie once, and we were on the showjumping part, I got half way around the course and he tryed to stop at a huge fence, I lost both my stirrups and my reins but made him go over it without touching a rail or it counting as a refusal :D. So anyways i grabbed my reins but didn't worry bout my stirrups as i had a jump 2 stride away, so I got over that, then turned him to the next jump, Now I never walked the course, I just stood on the side and looked at the numbers (bad habit but it was only 95cm) So I got to the next jump and relised it was a bounce, i still didn't have my reins right and still no stirrups. But got through it all fine. I got out and my friends run over and say fantasic round, you better jump like that on cross country or I will be taking away your stirrups next time :D.

I like the contact with the horse better when sitting to the trot, I feel it gives them more drive in there hindquarters to they round up more, I always like to do some sitting trot when i get on a new horse, to see how there back moves and how round they will go by themselves.

Looks like you have already sorted out the problem, but you are not alone and I better start paying more attention to what im doing when I rise :D.

My biggest problem is my rein length it is shocking, about twice the normal length for every pace. Im forever being told to shorten up but i never remember ahh. lol Also my habit of dropping my reins isn't at all gud :S. I finish doing something and I drop them competely eg: end of showhunter cantering around in the finish circle and i drop them competletly then half a circle later pick them up by the buckle.

Cochise, horse season is starting here so we better brush up the riding aye :D
 
Cochise...just looking at this from another viewpoint...maybe your horse just goes in a better outline and is easier to get on the bit in sitting trot, because you can ride him more forward, and more coming through from his hind quarters in sitting trot? Then you don't feel the need to fiddle as much in sitting trot as you do in rising trot. I only say this because this is the case with my horse.
 
Karen, I think I said that somewhere up there ^^^:)
I know I keep my leg a lot more constant and stronger in sitting trot than in rising trot.
He is becoming a lot happier in rising trot now too, as I am making myself leave his mouth alone and really riding through with my legs. I was just nit picking at my riding when I first posted this....putting it into words helped me to see what I was doing, and make me conscious of it. Thanks anyway :)
 
hello!

I think Ros is onto a good thing. If you can do sitting trot with Cheeky happy and working through then you seat must be ok. If you ride without your feet in the stirrups but with the stirups hanging down, are they a long way infront of your feet? If so when you do rsing trot you are having to pull yourself a long way forward to get out of the saddle as the stirrup bar is too far forwards.

Have you got a Heather Seatbone saver? that may well help you as it puts you in a better place in the saddle with relation to the stirrup bars.

bye!
 
Just wanted to share my experience from Heather's seminar in the Equisimulator, where we were lucky enough to try the Freedom saddle prototype and compare to a regular, high quality GP saddle.

The difference caused by the different stirrup bar positions was amazing! First everyone tried the Freedom saddle. One participant had only had one or two riding lessons in her life, and she posted the trot effortlessly as if she'd been doing it for years. Same with the rest of us.
But when Heather changed to a normal saddle everyone started pulling on the strap in the D loops or reins to get up when rising due to the fact that it had the stirrup bars fitted further forward (like most saddles).

The more experienced riders readjusted quite quickly until they didn't have pull themselves up anymore, while the rest of us took longer or didn't quite manage without pulling a tiny bit.
But everyone agreed that posting was far easier on Heather's saddle due to the stirrup bars being a bit further back.

Not trying to sound like I'm on commission from Heather here, just wanted to point out that the stirrup bar position has immence effect on the efforts needed to post and the balance you get. But I guess it actually has to be experienced.... :rolleyes:
 
newrider.com