Question about space.

Status
Not open for further replies.
my friend used to have a stable with about the same amount of land, but the horse and its companion (i think it was either a shetland or a goat :rolleyes: ) were both turned out to a MUCH bigger field for tunrout for about 12 ish hours a day

its not fair to the horse, and i agree with bay mare, i think that it would be selfish to keep a horse in those conditions it would get very stressed
 
firstly, i find it rather insulting to be a) accused of ''winding up'' and b) treated like i know nothing about horses.
I was simply asking opinions. and no, i do not intend keeping my horse in a backyard, i live in the country, i just dont have much land available.

in my personal opinion (and experience) a horse does well, even if he isn't kept to textbook regulations.
 
if you already answered your question (ie you think theres nothing wrong with keeping a single horse in a tiny plot of land with gravel on it ...), then why did you ask for opinions? sorry im not having a go at you or anything, i was just wondering.

Julia
x
 
My garden is about 3/4 of an acre and unfortunately is too small for a horse. In 1/4 of an acre there would be no rotation of grazing, no time for the ground to rest - it would quickly become very boggy, just like all fields do around the gates where horses stand a lot.
Im not going to jump down your throat or anything, I appreciate how annoying it must be to not be able to keep your horse at livery, or get adequate land to keep it on. I dont think you are going to get any different answers here unfortunately though - one of the problems of asking questions here is that sometimes you dont get the answer you want!
Horses can do well when not kept to textbook regulations, but not necessarily as well as they would do when they are kept to those textbook regulations. Tethered horses survive, tied alone in small fields on poor grass, but they will never have the condition of horses kept, say, at livery with plenty of turnout.
My yard has 38 horses and 38 acres, and in winter we have a small struggle with the land getting worn out, so it is sectioned off into roughly 2 acre paddocks with 2 horses in, a bit at a time to try and regrow the grass and let it recover.

I have a feeling that 6 months in your horse would just be knee deep in mud - with all the potential problems that brings (mud fever, strained tendons etc).


xxx
 
notpoodle said:
if you already answered your question (ie you think theres nothing wrong with keeping a single horse in a tiny plot of land with gravel on it ...), then why did you ask for opinions? sorry im not having a go at you or anything, i was just wondering.

Julia
x

its all grass, except for a small area of gravel.
 
Well basically it would end up a constant pit of mud with little grass in the summer as it would be ruined by the horse standing in it in the winter so you would be feeding all year round. 1/4 acre is just a big stable really but it would be a big muddy stable. Im sorry but I cant think of anything worse than seeing a horse in an over grazed over wet small field, its what gives horse owners a bad image to farmers!
 
StormArion said:
Are you even ALLOWED to have a horse on 1/4 acre? Here you'd be fined and the horse taken away. Legally, we cannot put a horse on a property unless it has a minimum of 3 acres...

Blimey what a good idea, irishdq- I have to agree with the others. I have kept my two short term on tow acres and it was not big enough, the ground id now totally poached.
I moved back to their ten acres and boy did they love it, they took off round and round the field, they loved the space.
And out of interest where did you get the idea that horses are happy being stabled?
 
in my personal opinion (and experience) a horse does well, even if he isn't kept to textbook regulations.

What? Always? I don't think so.

3/4 hours a day of a person's company is no substitute for equine company, and what about the other 20 hours? Horses don't just get socialisation from being around others, they get security as well. If you keep your horse alone for 6 months to a year then introduce it to others you might even set yourself up with more problems, as horses that have been isolated can get very strange when they get back with friends.

Sometimes people have to move their horse to less than ideal conditions and manage. Horses cope with less than ideal all the time.
In this case it's different, you haven't got a horse yet. So when you say that you have no choice about keeping a horse alone and in restricted conditions then my opinion is that you do have a choice. Don't get a horse.
You've asked for opinions, but each time someone explains why this isn't a good idea you say you know better. Well then, if you know best just get on with it.
 
My (small cob-type) horse was kept in a paddock of about 1/3 of an acre with no other horses within sight, smell or calling distance, before I bought him. And he was stressy and spooky and desparate to make friends when I brought him to my first (small, private) yard. He did chill out some, but has chilled out beyond recognition now that we are on a busy RS yard, where he can play and hooley around with a *whole herd* of other horses.

I've lived in places with a garden bigger than 1/4 acre and even with only human traffic (BBQs in summer etc), the ground quickly became tired. I wouldn't have thought that 1/4 acre would be able to provide the nutritional requirements for a horse, even with scrupulous paddock management.

Would it not be possible to get grass livery close to your house? Maybe speak to the local farmers to see if you could rent a field (of at least 1.5 acres)?
 
IrishDQ,

1/4 of an acre isn't at all ideal for keeping a horse on. I have just over an acre for turning out my 2 on whilst i'm waiting for fencing/contracts to be sorted out for my new 3 acre field. Its not ideal and has become very poached even with mine being kept in overnight. Is there any chance you could negociate some more land so you could keep a horse and a companion for it?

I'm not sure putting the horse into livery would solve this turnout/space issue. Most yards i know of keep 5-10 horses on 1-2 acres so things aren't always done 'by the book' so to speak. Most local yards by me have horrifically muddy fields, the one down the road from me has even banned turnout just now. My friend has 1 horse and 2 diddy ponies on about 1.5 acres and its hard work but you have to be very, very diligent about pasture care. Ideally you need enough to split, and leave 1 side to rest/fertilise whilst grazing the other side.

I have to say mine have flourished despite my limited grazing over the past year. I've been told they have never looked healthier. But really, 1/4 of an acre wouldn't be enough. if i were you i'd wait and negociate some more land before taking the plunge into pony ownership :)
 
It seems to me no matter what you are going to go ahead and do whatever anyway. The land may not seem boggy now but its surprising what a horse can turf up. Are there many people around because if you were to get the field and the horse you would no doubt have the RSPCA on your back!
 
IrishDQ said:
firstly, i find it rather insulting to be a) accused of ''winding up'' and b) treated like i know nothing about horses.
I was simply asking opinions. and no, i do not intend keeping my horse in a backyard, i live in the country, i just dont have much land available.

in my personal opinion (and experience) a horse does well, even if he isn't kept to textbook regulations.

The poster referring to a 'backyard' is from the US, over there their backyards are not like our backyards (ie a small concreted yard like we have behind terraced houses) they are referring to small plots of land.

I really think 1/4 acre would get so poached during the winter that the horse would be knee deep in mud, sorry.
 
I would not recommend keeping a horse alone in the situation you describe. I kept my horse on her own for a few years and she has no social skills with other horses. She is a real loner in the field, but gets separation anxiety when the horses are taken away. I can hack her out on her own, but I feel sorry that she has never had a horsy friend. I will never do that to a horse again.

Whereabouts do you live? If you do find diy livery you would be looking after the horse yourself and wouldnt have to worry about other people handling him/her. Its also not that expensive. I can afford it and I am making no money at all (not even entitled to the dole). It could also be possible to rent a field. Do try to exhaust all possibilities.

Good luck
 
Sorry, have to agree with the others too. :(

Our only exception is my cousin's pony who is laminitic, and she, in spring, is kept in a 1/4 acre fenced off section during the day only

She has friends nearby, and is let into the field at night (which is 3 acres for 3 small ponies, and still gets churned up horribly in winter)

Even during spring and summer, with only an 11hh pony in it, the area just turns into a dirt patch, which is not ideal but it is far better than laminitis.

I'm sorry, it must be hard to hear that you cannot keep a horse, but please try and find somewhere more suitable. Many farmers will rent you a small area if asked nicely. Someone approached my Grandad and asked him to rent a small piece of land. He wasn't looking to rent it, but because they asked, he did :)

Good luck with sorting something out :)
 
By all means go ahead and ignore every opinion that doesn't agree with yours - why did you bother asking if you don't want to hear anything other than your own opinion?

And just for the record a family I knew locally did the self same thing - bought a shetland pony and kept it on 1/4 acre - after the RSPCA had been called for the fourth time by locals complaining that it wasn't enough and the sight of this pony on it's on on the sea of mud that the 1/4 acre turned into in the winter, the owner finally saw sense and thought about the pony's needs and wants rather than their own....a local charity came and took the pony away.

However I'm sure all will be perfect in your little scenario...after all you know best, obviously :rolleyes:

Trip trap troll...back under the bridge with you.
 
I will also of course try and rent a field, but if i can't, then the one i have will have to do. i've kept ponies on small plots before and they have thrived. not forgetting i MAY have a shelter built (depending on whether or not I can get planning permission) so more than likely the horse will be in at night.
 
I sometimes think that some people would take more care over providing a good home for a guinea pig than they would a horse.
This whole thread is pointless. You didn't want advice, you know it all anyway and nothing anyone can say to try to persuade you to give your horse the best life it could have will change your mind.
 
why do you have to get a hose right now? surely it would be kinder (to the horse) to wait until you can accomadate its needs. Its really not fair to the horse, and I'm sorry, but i do think that it would be a little selfish
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com