Refusing at very last minute

Jul 15, 2005
536
0
16
Essex
I have been having a few problems lately with my horse stopping at fences - more so when out competing than at home. However, luckily she did it during a lesson with my instructor on Saturday. Unluckily in one respect as it was absolutely at the last minute and my body was committed to taking off ... so we parted company!

At the beginning of the lesson when I was explaining the stopping to my instructor, she felt it was a bit of nappiness. Mainly because my girl had jumped fine towards the collecting ring, but stopped at fences facing away.

We had been doing some lovely work with canter poles and then one fence, two canter poles and another fence, but then we did a small course, which consisted of planks put as cross poles.

My instructor was absolutely convinced she was going to jump, and said she couldn't believe how she stopped at the very last minute. She felt it was because she was genuinely worried by the fence, so we put it down for her - she still refused, but not as dramatically. Then I trotted her in to it and she jumped it huge, as if it was going to bite her! Then we put it up and cantered in to it and she jumped it without hesitation.

Has anyone got any tips for last minute refusing? I have to say it doesn't do my confidence any favours, because I am just starting to enjoy jumping, but the thought of her stopping and chucking me on the fence definitely makes me edgy. I wasn't nervous before the refusal during my lesson as she had been jumping really well, and I had no inkling she would stop. Usually she runs out a little way before the fence, but it is the last minute stops that really dent my confidence.

Has anyone had this type of problem and what is the best way to overcome it please? For info we are only talking about fences under 2ft 6ins, so nothing big. ;)
 
What does she do when she refuses?

I'd put them down to 2ft and if she just stops when she refuses make her jump it from a stand still.

No chance it could be pain related? If she was expecting it to hurt when she took of or landed she would refuse. Is she behaving oddly in any other ways?
 
Definitely doesn't seem to be pain related - just had the physio out last week who gave her a clean bill of health. In the lesson she had been jumping absolutely fine for 40 minutes, and the refusal came within the very last part of the lesson.

She always ducks out to the left - when we stop, she is never facing a jump, so I always have to circle away. It wouldn't be possible to jump from a standstill as we are not facing the jump. I have tried carrying my whip in my left hand, but that doesn't make a difference. She is very fast, and very strong. She really doesn't give any indication she is going to stop until the last minute - which is what surprised my instructor.
 
Oh dear, that doesn't help confidence at all does it & the more she does the less confident you will be & that in turn will make her less confident which means she will stop more & so the cycle continues.

What's her flatwork like? Does she do lateral work with ease & does she listen to your leg & do you have a weaker side that maybe she's taking advantage of?

As far as jumping goes - are you approaching the fence right in the middle? What if you try jumping at an angle? Do you keep your leg on & a good contact right to the fence?

Also - I'm taking it you circle away to the left when she ducks out to the left? Don't let her do this - if she ducks to the left then you stop her & turn her back to the right, preferable in front of the jump if you get the time
 
Last edited:
I know what your going through. Kia has destroyed my confidence in his jumping with this!!! I'll jump other horses no bother just get nerves with him lol:cool:

I have basically taken him back to basics (me as well lol :o) and got him jumping small consistently then moving gradually up. I did a jumpcross training day and the max height was 2ft3ish. He didnt stop at one, had a bit of a waver at a double but we got over it when i presented him correctly the 2nd time:)

I found that this was helpful for us and now I have a bit of confidence back with him and when we start jumping again in the spring I hope that we wont have to start all over again and can start about 2ft ish instead of 1ft.

I dod lots of little jumps in all directions and over as many obstacles as i could in as many different ways as i could. We had a few hairy moments but we got through them and i havent fallen off jumping in a while now as the dirty stops and the sharp run outs have stopped.

Nikki xxx
 
Mine can do exactly the same, not ideal for confidence building when you're learning to jump, I was never positive enough as I didn't trust him.

Last summer I was 2nd in a 2'3" class, so decided to enter the 2'6" - was going fine until we reached a jump that they had put a water tray under, he slammed the breaks on at the very last second (even my very experienced sj friend said it looked as though he was going to jump). He does the same, stops right at the jump, and swerves so he doesn't go into it, but that means he ends up sideways to the fence and I end up over his shoulder and on the floor! I think I would stay on if he stopped straight, but it's the swerve that gets me :D. So different from my other horse, who if he doesn't like the look of a fence will start to falter or stop a few yards away, so at least you get some warning :rolleyes:

I kept away from 'scary fillers' for a while, just jumping poles, and had lots of lessons with a fab instructor (pro sj'er) who knows exactly how much to push me. Ended up jumping fillers, and in one of my last lessons with her, she was amazed and asked 'what are you doing differently?' - I said I was riding a lot more positively and telling him he was going to jump, not just riding up to the fence and wondering whether he was going to jump it or not, lol :D

Although I have gained confidence with him and got him jumping pretty much anything (even gone clear xc over fences I thought he would look at :rolleyes:) he still has a problem with those large black pipes (used to be funny with tyres, but is fine with those now :confused:). We have a few xc jumps in a field, he jumped them all including the black pipes, I was glad he seemed to be over his phobia, so popped them both ways - THEN he stopped, after he's jumped them several times - aaaghhh :mad: They are really small, so I made him jump them from a standstill, and then we went back and forth over them another few times for good measure!

Sorry for the essay! I just found I needed to ride a lot more positively, and use lots of leg - RI says I just used to sit there and let him decide whether to jump or not, when I was learning they were very small so I think I used to concentrate on me and let him get on with it, I never actually told him to jump. I now use a lot more leg, am more decisive and having lots of positive experiences over jumps I don't worry about has really helped us both.

Good luck :)
 
She is very fast, and very strong.
This may well be a clue to your problem. Horse that approach a fence at a fast pace are often insecure about jumping. The fast pace then doesn't allow them to work out and adjust for takeoff. The result is generally a stop at the last second. All the way in the rider believes the horse is going to jump and commits to it.
Best way to cure this problem is approach from the slowest speed possible, keep and upright position, leg on and pushing in to the contact. Feel the rythm and dont allow the horse to speed up, slow down or deviate off line.
Too often the horse is pushed out of a comfortable pace after a stop and the rider believes if the horse is approaching at speed it will jump. The reverse is generally the case.
As you said earlier, when you approached in trot she cleared the fence but with a ping. This is normal from a slow approach in trot as is a useful exercise to get a horse using its back end over a fence. Dont believe the 'have to have impulsion on approach' gurus. This only applies if popping a big oxer above 1.20mtr.
So try approaching as slowly as you can and see what happens. ;)
 
This may well be a clue to your problem. Horse that approach a fence at a fast pace are often insecure about jumping. The fast pace then doesn't allow them to work out and adjust for takeoff. The result is generally a stop at the last second. All the way in the rider believes the horse is going to jump and commits to it.
Best way to cure this problem is approach from the slowest speed possible, keep and upright position, leg on and pushing in to the contact. Feel the rythm and dont allow the horse to speed up, slow down or deviate off line.
Too often the horse is pushed out of a comfortable pace after a stop and the rider believes if the horse is approaching at speed it will jump. The reverse is generally the case.
As you said earlier, when you approached in trot she cleared the fence but with a ping. This is normal from a slow approach in trot as is a useful exercise to get a horse using its back end over a fence. Dont believe the 'have to have impulsion on approach' gurus. This only applies if popping a big oxer above 1.20mtr.
So try approaching as slowly as you can and see what happens. ;)

Thats really useful as I also have one that does rush and occassionally ducks out at the last. I always thought I wasn't doing her any favours making her trot over stuff. What about if they fight to rush at it, would you just circle until they calm down ? Sorry to hijack thread, just interested. I find the rushing as well as the refusing can give the confidence a battering!!
 
Ditto the others.
I also recommend taking your horse out drag unting or similar, to give jumping a greater sense of fun and develop her confidence, especially with there being other horses there to give her a lead if she needs one.
However I think it's important to go back to basics and build up your horse's confidence going over small fences and gridwork. Stay relaxed but focused, keep your contact (are you dropping it or tipping forward just before take-off, unbalancing or worrying your horse?). You could place a pole on either side of the fence, resting one end on the top of the jump pole and the end on the floor, to encourage your horse to stay straight.
It may also help to loose school your horse over jumps to give her greater freedom without the burden of a rider. this will also helpher to think about how best to jump the fence independently, without relying on a riderto tell her what to do.
Never get angry with your horse or punish her for refusing. this will only worry and connfuse her more, denting her confidence further and possible creating worse problems.
You say yourself that your horse tends to trefuse more out at competitions than she does at home. Could you be riding differently at competitions,in your show gear? perhaps you are nervous (which seems likely) - so in effect, in ducking out your horse is only doing what she thinks is protecting you both from danger, if you are worrying about the fence!
Does she behave the same with a differnet/more confident rider on her, such as your instructor?
It may be best to avoid competitions until you have sorted this out and increased your horse's confidence jumping, although just warming up at shows regularly, or just walking around them and getting her used to the atmosphere, may help to avoid competition-itus.

Good luck!

x
 
Last edited:
Thanks everyone - some interesting tips and thoughts there.

When I said she is very fast, I meant at refusing! My friend says to me "why do you let her stop" (as if it is something I am encouraging!!) but the stop is so fast you really can' pre-empt it. Even my instructor said I was not doing anything different/wrong at the fence she refused - she just seemed to be worried by it.

She is not fast in to fences, and we were working on some shortened bouncy strides. I don't feel I am not committed to the fence - I don't worry about refusing most of the time, although I am starting to a bit now.

I have hired an indoor school in a few weeks to jump a full course with my instructor (we can only get 4 jumps in our school), and will see how we get on.

She hasn't stopped with my instructor who's only jumped her few times, but she has started stopping with my sharer who is absolutely 100% not worried about jumping and can jump her over about 3ft 9ins. My instructor said she jumps better for me (making better shape over jump, and better approach) and would now like to give my sharer another lesson just in case there is something there that is causing a problem. :confused:
 
Interesting! Have you had her back, tack and teeth all checked? It seems odd that your horse used to be fine jumping up to all of 3'9". Has anything changed (i.e. feed, tack, routine etc) or has she endured an unpleasant experience?

x
 
Hope I don't alarm you, but sometimes out of character stopping like this can be an early sign of navicular. What are her feet like? I think the advice here has been very good and may well sort the problem, but if you can't seem to iron out the issues by training her, just bear it in mind :rolleyes:
 
Will bear it in mind IM, but hope it's not the case.

She did have a fall with my sharer when jumping on grass. She slipped on take off - not sure if she was refusing at the time, as I wasn't there and never really found out.

Her previous owner told me that she does tend to stop at bigger jumps when competing, mainly due to pressure of the bigger jumps, but that is when they are over 3ft. But perhaps her confidence has been shaken by the fall. We're not jumping her on grass at all now, and sticking to a surface. Trying to make it as easy as possible for her really.
 
Been there, got the t-shirt and a few others too - been christined of course ;) -

Robbie used to stop coming away from the gate but over-jump the jumps coming towards the gate.
I finally got him over the napping stage of stopping in front of the gate and little nigs to me telling me he isn't moving and having a hissy fit.
Could it be she is napping at the gate and not wanting to do anything because she can see the others not doing anything?

I hired out a couple of places over the past 2 months working on moving him forward past the gate and having trotting poles straight after so he had something to focus on.
 
I'm not sure what her previous owner did with her. I'm not punishing her for stopping on the advice of my RI. I have never whipped her for stopping. She gets too anxious.

It's not out and out nappiness. But the slight nappiness definitely doesn't help with the stopping - i.e. she is more inclined to put a stop in in the nappy direction. :rolleyes:
 
newrider.com