ive been thinking about this as ive done my jobs this morning; it might be an idea to get his back checked. ie the fidgeting about when you are trying to mount, and the rearing- could be pain related. (or he could just be trying it on a bit) , but i would get someone to stand at his head and stop him moving off when you mount, for discipline,for manners, and for safety, ( and depending on how you have to swing forward to get on, it would be putting a strain on his back)
He has always fidgeted when mounting and I believe it's just because he hasn't had much done with him and is very green. He was improving so much before going on loan so it's been one step forward, one back- as it usually is with youngsters.
I used to have someone at his head and use a step or chair (and moving it with him until he stood still) to get on- which I believe is what Steph (scottishterrier) has been doing.
He passed a vetting and had a good going over just before I got him (I didn't have him for long before putting him on loan as circumstances changed and I couldn't take him to uni with me). He had his saddle, teeth etc done. I believe his saddle may have changed fit within the last couple of months but from the sounds of things it seems more behavioural due to what I've been told about his behaviour on the ground too.
i think there seems from what you say to be a bit of a jeolousy thing going on regards you, ie rushing to be with you- where is he in the pecking order with the other horses, and is it when he is with particular horses that he freaks out more- is he being bullied by any of them, or is he the dominant one? it could be, as someone else said, that the grass is to rich , but i think you will have to go back to basics again, and just start eliminating possible causes. have you tried, and is he ok in a field farther away from the gate to the yard, if he has someone with him for company. i am also wondering whether , if he is a bit dominant, putting him in with a bossy older mare might help- she would put him in his place if he got too uppity. which might have a knock-on effect generally.
When I had him I found him to very gentle and nervy if anything and never saw him show any aggression.
It's puzzling me as much as Steph and I hope we can get to the bottom of it.
x