just want to share another (less painful -shakari thats a grim story ! hope she's getting better) personal experience
I have worked my mare loose - either in a round pen (where available) or arena since I got her. She has a high play drive and knows that it is ok to let off steam in certain ways, but once its work time, its work time.
But she seemed to think it might be "fun" to try the same sort of thing when we went to catch her out in the field. We've had to be very firm about this and NOT go after her as she just thinks its part of the game.
She is a lovely mare and also has a strong drive to please - but just wanted to test the limits a bit.
If we hadn't realised what was going on we'd have had a hard-to-catch mare in no time, AND she stirs the pther two up as well.
So even without the (clear) safety issues, there is some interesting "what are we training our horses to do" questions as well.
However - I would also say that none of us can SEE what subsectionx is doing, and words are often inadequate. I can't say whether subsectionx is teaching her horses clear body language, advanace and retreat, and giving them a chance to play and exercise as well - or not - without either being there or having an awful lot more detail. For example, how you "allow" them back in will have a big effect on the "hard to catch" risks I described above from my own experience.
I do think this is an interesting dialogue - but lets not make too many assumptions about what we can't see !
I have worked my mare loose - either in a round pen (where available) or arena since I got her. She has a high play drive and knows that it is ok to let off steam in certain ways, but once its work time, its work time.
But she seemed to think it might be "fun" to try the same sort of thing when we went to catch her out in the field. We've had to be very firm about this and NOT go after her as she just thinks its part of the game.
She is a lovely mare and also has a strong drive to please - but just wanted to test the limits a bit.
If we hadn't realised what was going on we'd have had a hard-to-catch mare in no time, AND she stirs the pther two up as well.
So even without the (clear) safety issues, there is some interesting "what are we training our horses to do" questions as well.
However - I would also say that none of us can SEE what subsectionx is doing, and words are often inadequate. I can't say whether subsectionx is teaching her horses clear body language, advanace and retreat, and giving them a chance to play and exercise as well - or not - without either being there or having an awful lot more detail. For example, how you "allow" them back in will have a big effect on the "hard to catch" risks I described above from my own experience.
I do think this is an interesting dialogue - but lets not make too many assumptions about what we can't see !