Three - bad mix?

Trewsers

Well-Known Member
Oct 13, 2004
57,412
18,841
113
57
On an island
I know I may have asked this before so please be patient with me. As you may know we have two lovely mares but would like another horse to ride (Chloe is a companion and Storm is edging towards semi retirement). We really cannot afford two more - but we can manage just one more. When you keep them at home people tend to think it costs very little, but they still need teeth, vaccinations, feet etc - so it looks like a third one is an option but not a fourth. Do you think it will be a problem? Will they just sort themselves out? Should I be put off a gelding? I don't want to limit my options because of the horses sex - if a gelding comes along - ie, the right one for us then I don't want to miss the opportunity. Will the girls accept him? Will they fight over him? Sorry for all the numb questions but I'd love to hear any thoughts or similar set ups. Thanks for reading.:smile:
 
I've always mixed mares and geldings and not really had an issue, apart from my boys are pigs and eat all the food and chase the girls off, but them again my 2 big girls who have now passed also chased the lower pecking order girl off the food.

I would think as long as the new addition was ok going off on their own when you wanted to ride, or if you could leave one on it's own at home whilst you rode the other 2, then it shouldn't really be a problem.

Also if you have enough room and don't mind someone else being around, you could possibly offer someone livery as long as you can ride the horse, or a similar arrangement, then you both get a horse to ride without the maintenance costs?
 
I think it really depends on the horses. Ziggy and Mattie have shared with other geldings and now with two mares quite amicably. In our field the mares are very much the top horses and chase the boys all over the place! I certainly wouldn't rule out a gelding.
 
our mares mix with either of the geldings - we have to split the geldings up as they are a danger to each other - not nasty just injure each other with what they seem to call playing:giggle: wheras run either of them with the girls no problems at all .
 
I have three, 2 mares and a handsome gelding.. it does depend on the horses themselves but I would say a gelding would be a better fit. My mares do not fight over him but I do have an older mare and a young mare so they are less interested I think.
 
I think what worries me is Storm getting knocked off her pedestal as top banana! Either that or Chloe getting even further down the pecking order... I guess you can't predict reactions. There won't be a problem hack wise I hope as I plan to try and get him or her used to hacking alone - it may take time but even Storm will go alone, just that Chloe quite understandably gets upset when left.
 
My boy is currently in with 2 mares, he is well and truely kept in his place (and has recently acquired the bruises to prove it :frown:). The girls don't fight over him, but they also don't accept him.

I think it depends on the field dynamics though, Kev is bottom of the pecking order in a geldings herd anyway, so I didn't expect anything less from the girls. He actually gets on fine with the bossy mare, it's the other one who has taken a bit of a dislike to him. I think it's worth considering where they would fit into the herd regardless of sex and take it from there. I know of gelding who have been nightmares when they are in with mares, but they tend to be more dominant horses.

I am assuming Chloe is fine on her own while you ride Storm, so I think the only things you have to worry about is how storm would be if you took the new horse out the field and how the new horse would feel about getting taken away from his mates. I think 3 is a pretty good number though, better than 2.
 
Chloe is fine if I ride Storm in the school and she can still hear us - the problem starts when she can no longer see us. We used to do mini hacks before Storm got ill this year and Chloe did used to call out for her quite a bit. Not that I am brave enough to go far!!! I do like schooling.
 
I personally think just chucking them in straight away (and making sure they have plenty space to run around) is the best way. I would hate to fence it off with leccy tape and one of them get caught in it.
 
I personally think just chucking them in straight away (and making sure they have plenty space to run around) is the best way. I would hate to fence it off with leccy tape and one of them get caught in it.

Yes I did wonder about that. The biggest field we have is just under 3 acres so that would be enough for them to get away if they needed to?
 
We always seperate off any new stock coming in - not so much to get used to each other but more to make sure not introducing anything health wise into the mix.
 
I am a throw them in kind of person usually but with your set up I would put him/her next door to Storm and Chole for a day or so first (so they meet over the fence). I am sure you will not be bringing home anything to energetic anyway but make sure the new one is fine on their own, good with mares etc. You might find if the new one is good on their own you could keep it that while you get to know it too..
 
I have to say I would divide the field at first, even if only overnight. Once they have got acquainted there is much less chance of them being daft and doing each other an injury.
 
Thanks for all the replies. I wonder if this would work: put Chloe n Storm in the arena with a net each and newby in the adjoining paddock? Tis post and rail so secure and unless he or she is completely nuts they ought to be okay and not injure themselves? I bring the girls in at night - so was thinking they'd be able to see each other - and maybe it would help get them used to each other - and into a routine? I can't wait tbh - OH has really missed riding and now we can start to look in earnest. Going to go see lovely charity Happa and see if they have anything - or at least put feelers out. We can offer a good home to something maybe not that energetic and looking for a slower pace of life.
 
We always seperate off any new stock coming in - not so much to get used to each other but more to make sure not introducing anything health wise into the mix.

That is a good point. When Joe died tho, I was so distressed and worried about Storm being alone I took the chance of just popping Chloe right in there with her. But maybe this time I ought to apply a bit of caution...
I will have the vet come and give he or she the once-over anyway - we did that with Chloe after a couple of days, just to make sure teeth etc were okay. As it turns out she was just fine.
 
I'm another that just let's them get on with it - put out multiple piles of hay if not much grass and let them get on with it. Ensure that it is daylight and that you are about for a few hours :)
 
Kev was isolated in the field next door for 2 weeks before he was allowed to go into the field for infection purposes. But he was ~15 meters away so although he could see them he couldn't say hello.

If you are going to isolate for infection purposes (a sensible thing to do) you have to do it for 2 weeks (about the time it would take for something to show up), and make sure they are completely isolated....can't touch each other, couldn't spread any mucus, no sharing of tools, clothing, etc. We were told to have them at least 10m apart from each other.
 
We have two mares in together and when we briefly had three a couple of times we have had a gelding before he got a new friend and seperated off again and later a mare... Well i know it depends on the horse but think I would definately go for a gelding if we got a third again as there seemed to be far too much hormones in the field with the three girls and it didn't seem to help their separation just added another one to the problem, where as when they were briefly with the gelding they seemed happier about being left etc... He was fairly laid back though compared to the third mare so it might just have been that..

Very exciting though.. Good luck with the hunt.
 
I have three: 2 mares and a gelding.
The mares are way cleverer than the gelding but they humor him and let him pretend he is boss. He likes that. ;)
So everybody is happy. He sometimes forgets he's a gelding and can be quite protective of 'his' girls so I would be hesitant getting another gelding. Plus I love mares. If we added a 4th horse it would be another mare.
 
newrider.com