Welfare issue?

Orenoko

Well-Known Member
Feb 13, 2017
200
273
63
So I've been volunteering at a charity that does riding for disabled children for about 2 years now. Initially I did it to learn more about groundwork and being around horses etc, but have kept up with it as I enjoy it. Recently I've had some concerns about the welfare of the horses there. One was being stabled for a while but not having their straw changed so was using urine-soaked straw as a bed. Another was being kept in a field with ragwort. Another was being kept in a field that was ridiculously waterlogged. All of these issues have now been resolved, but there's a new issue.

Someone has decided that some of the horses need to be shut in the indoor school for 20 hours a day to avoid them eating too much grass because they're at risk of laminitis. The school is large but it's dark and dusty. It's also made from corrugated sheets so, while it's not an issue now, will become an issue when the weather gets warmer.

I've held off on saying anything formally about these issues as they all seem to get resolved eventually, but I'm starting to wonder now whether this is a step too far. I don't know loads about managing a horse at risk of laminitis but I'm pretty sure shutting them in a dark box for most of the day isn't an acceptable solution. Is this worth reporting to someone like World Horse Welfare or the BHS Welfare Team? I can see why the decision makers might have thought this was a good idea as it keeps them off grass but gives them space to move around, but it's dark and dusty and potentially hot. Any ideas?
 
@Jessey it is darker than a stable for sure. It does have lights but they're not switched on, and no natural daylight or option for them to pop their head over a door as they could in a stable.

@Prjsmk they do have hay and water so their needs are being met in that respect. I don't think any of the issues have been caused by maliciousness or anything like that, but these things just keep happening and I don't think it's fair (although maybe I'm wrong, I don't know, that's why I posted!)
 
If they are at serious risk of lami then leaving them out is possibly cruelest, it can be such a horrific condition. Perhaps ask if a gate can be put across the door to let some natural light in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers and Prjsmk
Ring world horse welfare for advice and I think they will put your mind at ease.

I might know where you mean, not sure. But if it's where I'm thinking of they could easily put a gate or fence over the doors so they would get fresh air and light.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
What happens for the other 4 hours per day? Do they get turned out? Keeping them in an indoor school sounds like a good and responsible solution to me. It is much better than a stable and they have more space to move. I presume that the school lets in daylight somehow? Or is it pitch black even in the middle of the day?
 
I don't think anything you are describing is a welfare issue. Lots of people are struggling with waterlogged fields after the worst winter I can remember. Temporarily getting behind on mucking out/ ragworting may not be ideal but is far from hitting welfare thresholds. And indoor turnout with hay and water sounds like a good compromise with vulnerable ponies. Rather that than the waterlogged fields!

Imo formally reporting the yard is not indicated, will achieve nothing useful and will cause immense upset. And while you can do it anonymously it's usually not hard for people to work out who has reported then so it may be the end of your involvement there too.
 
Thanks all, I genuinely wasn't sure if it would constitute a welfare issue or not or if there were other suitable solutions. Just feel a bit sorry for them. There are other areas they could be in with restricted grazing but they're being shut in there instead, I just think come summer the conditions in there will be horrendous, especially with the door closed. It's a strange place, very political and once the decision makers make up their mind on something they won't be told anything else even if it's just a minor suggestion. Each time I'm there (which is only fortnightly) there seems to be a new way of managing the horses. I'm rambling a bit now, I think I just wanted to put my mind at ease. I'll see how they go, once things warm up I would hope they'll see sense and move them elsewhere with restricted grazing.
 
I don't think anything you are describing is a welfare issue. Lots of people are struggling with waterlogged fields after the worst winter I can remember. Temporarily getting behind on mucking out/ ragworting may not be ideal but is far from hitting welfare thresholds. And indoor turnout with hay and water sounds like a good compromise with vulnerable ponies. Rather that than the waterlogged fields!

Imo formally reporting the yard is not indicated, will achieve nothing useful and will cause immense upset. And while you can do it anonymously it's usually not hard for people to work out who has reported then so it may be the end of your involvement there too.

Sorry I should've clarified in my initial post. With the urine soaked straw, we were told we weren't allowed to change it as it was only to be changed on a specific day. For a horse that was on box rest 24/7. This is despite me seeing black, rotting straw underneath fresher straw (I changed it regardless as there was about a foot of rotting straw). I debated reporting it but I'd essentially got rid of the evidence myself by acting, and then the horse came good so was back out.

I recognise everybody has been struggling with their fields with this awful run of weather, but again there were other fields these guys could've been in but they were just thrown back in the same one. If it was just an oversight or mishap with either of these things I could understand but it's not, that's why I was concerned about this new move.
 
Last edited:
It doesn't sound ideal with the straw issue, and it probably isn't how most of us keep ours - but, maybe the specific day thing has to be due to costs? And also to keep things in a routine? I know that might sound silly but just thinking if they have quite a few horses then they must have to stick to some kind of schedule. The indoor school although dusty - does sound better than them standing in all day. Least they can have a roll and stretch their legs. I know what you mean about the dust tho, some are terrible, when we were on a yard after I'd used their indoor I always felt it catching the back of my throat - and black when I blew my nose (tmi sorry:rolleyes::oops::p).
 
I have to say this sounds unacceptable to me and I wouldn't be happy with any of the situations you have mentioned and chucking them all in a dark dusty school because of a lami risk smacks of laziness and an unwillingness to put the effort to combat it in a more appropriate way. The fact that this is a charity shouldn't mean excuses should be made but that they should be held to an even higher standard because if they did end up being investigated the damage to there reputation could be crippling.
 
I have to say this sounds unacceptable to me and I wouldn't be happy with any of the situations you have mentioned and chucking them all in a dark dusty school because of a lami risk smacks of laziness and an unwillingness to put the effort to combat it in a more appropriate way. The fact that this is a charity shouldn't mean excuses should be made but that they should be held to an even higher standard because if they did end up being investigated the damage to there reputation could be crippling.

But what alternatives are there? You either turn out the ponies onto spring grass and risk them getting lami, or you turn them out onto fields which have no grass which will basically be knee deep in mud after all this rain. Fields with no grass are fine for summer turnout when they are dry and great for laminitis prone ponies, but not in this weather. Or you can stable them all individually. With the ponies in the indoor school they are all together, can touch and interact with each other, and are safe from both the grass and the mud. I really can't see how this is being lazy and this is far preferable to them being stabled on their own. The staff will have to muck out the indoor school and give them hay and water. I really don't understand how this is unacceptable. It would be far worse if they chucked them out onto the spring grass and watched them come down with laminitis.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
The straw sound like they take a deep litter approach. I don't think that it works that well with straw but I deep litter on shavings and it suits me. In my experience straw beds work better if they are fully mucked out everyday.
 
They could hose down the school to make it less dusty and put fencing across the doorway so the horses have light and fresh air?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
@Ale that might be the best solution. There is way of rigging up the electric fence so that a horse can have access to a stable, part of the yard and the outdoor school, but that might not work with all three e.g. If they all decided they wanted to use the stable at the same time it could cause arguments. A fence or gate or some sort could be a suitable alternative. I will try and suggest it. I also think @SmallHunter has a point re them being a charity, I think some of their actions are down to laziness or not knowing better and charities can't afford to run like that. I won't even start on some of the support helpers give to the riders :eek: not the right place.
 
newrider.com