A loading debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter vieshot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Errr, yes, good point!! Probably more so :D

I don't think I havea gap in my training neither does my horse! He just has his own mind & sometimes it involves doing things he doesn't necessarily want to do. He is also exeptionally easy to handle from the ground, wel mannered & trustworthy.
 
Personally it wouldn't be something I would try for safety reasons alone, reason being that if either of my boys get a shock of the electric fence they take off like a rocket. God knows how they would react to a shock from out of no where.
 
Perhaps it would be an idea to travel him to do something he really enjoys now and again in that case? :)

I have tried that believe me it does not work! I have loaded Angel just to get out the other end and eat some grass, go on a nice hack, go to a show and not do anything, she loves all thoses things and was so chilled and obviously enjoys them. The loading isn't the problem with many horses its the actual travelling. Angel is fine once on and stands calmly the reason she dosn't go on is because she finds the travelling difficult.

I agree who would want to go on a box they are not the most inviting things. I do however disagree with the point about horses not being naughty but we won't go into that! ;)

Good point Soot about the electric fencing, I know many horses that completely ignore electric fencing even at the highest voltage.
 
Hmm... it worked and the pony now loads - I dont see a problem.

I too would rather see that than the disgraceful show of aggression forced on a poor youngster (yes, they told anyone that offered help that the horse was a youngster) at a recent show.:mad:


I too learnt from someone alot wiser than me that loading is one of the most dangerous times with a horse and that you shouldnt faff around. Had I not had someone around like that when we got our first horse we may have been in trouble.

I think the key here is that the horse was not scared to travel or load but just pushing the boundaries, therefore one quick shock and he'll think twice about not loading again!
 
its all about money and lack of time with some people, that is why force is usually used on animals, if the horse or animals could use our language and voice then im sure humans would not get away with this form of torture.


why is inflicting a short sharp shock seen as torture? and what has money got to do with it? All too often people try to put human emotions into horses lives?.Horses kick and bite each other to establish a point. do you ever see the kicked one threatening to report the other to Horseline? No, they take the message on board and move on, thats the horses way of doing things, something they understand.
 
I agree who would want to go on a box they are not the most inviting things. I do however disagree with the point about horses not being naughty but we won't go into that! ;)

Go ahead! There's nothing wrong with debating; it's not about beating each other dwon, only utilising your right to (so-called) freedom of speech! :p

Good point Soot about the electric fencing, I know many horses that completely ignore electric fencing even at the highest voltage.

Yet I'm sure that is someone went to hit a horse with it, it would be a different matter entirely ...

x
 
why is inflicting a short sharp shock seen as torture? and what has money got to do with it? All too often people try to put human emotions into horses lives?.Horses kick and bite each other to establish a point. do you ever see the kicked one threatening to report the other to Horseline? No, they take the message on board and move on, thats the horses way of doing things, something they understand.

But horses understand each other's language and know what it means. Humans hit each other too, so does that make it right for a horse to hti a human as well?

x
 
Perhaps so, but my point is it never gives the owner/handler the right to say/do: "Well, I see no reason for it which means I have every right to force him to do it, in whichever way is 'necessary'".

I also love a good debate! :D:)

I'm afraid I believe the horse is there to do a job (even if that job is pasture ornament!). Now, of course I don't believe in doing "whatever's necessary", because that encompasses all sorts of horrible things, and I absolutely don't advocate cruelty. However, if I've made a reasonable request ("trot" / "pick your foot up" / "don't barge"), and the horse doesn't want to do it ("I can't be arsed to trot" / "I'm too busy eating hay, don't distract me" / "I want to get inside quickly for my dinner") then I most certainly will insist that they do what I ask.

To date, this has resulted in happy horses with good manners!
 
I don't think I havea gap in my training neither does my horse!

Please don't think I was suggesting that was the case with you and your horse, I did use the term sometimes :)

There's no doubt that horses can often be reluctant to do things we want or need them to do, maybe for reasons outside our control, in that case I think we owe it to them to persuade them in as humane and positive a way as we can.
 
I also love a good debate! :D:)

I'm afraid I believe the horse is there to do a job (even if that job is pasture ornament!). Now, of course I don't believe in doing "whatever's necessary", because that encompasses all sorts of horrible things, and I absolutely don't advocate cruelty. However, if I've made a reasonable request ("trot" / "pick your foot up" / "don't barge"), and the horse doesn't want to do it ("I can't be arsed to trot" / "I'm too busy eating hay, don't distract me" / "I want to get inside quickly for my dinner") then I most certainly will insist that they do what I ask.

To date, this has resulted in happy horses with good manners!

As will I, but I will never hit or threaten them to achieve this. :D

That said, horses will be horses and being reluctantm tired and having off days, to my knowledge, isn't a crime ...

x
 
No, they take the message on board and move on, thats the horses way of doing things, something they understand.

Yes, but they read each other perfectly, they know instinctively just how far to take it and their timing is perfect. How many of us are that good when we're dealing with them? The amount of force they do or don't use is only a fraction of the story.
 
Yes, but they read each other perfectly, they know instinctively just how far to take it and their timing is perfect. How many of us are that good when we're dealing with them? The amount of force they do or don't use is only a fraction of the story.

Exactly. Rarely does a horse go to the extremes of having a fight with another, and the other horse is given a choice; comply or stay away. Also, it really is in the horse's best interests in the hred; for safety, security, food and psychological comfort, etc, to comply with the herd's way of doing things. They also benefit from it (by gaining social acceptance, food etc).

x
 
Horses don't fear a fence because they have been zapped by it, do they?
I mean they don't actually FEAR it, they just respect it enough to not quite touch it when they lean over to savage the tarpaulin covering the fresh hay.

A good sharp shock is what many children need when they're being naughty, be it a cattle prod or an electric fence I don't see the difference when a boundary is being deliberately ignored *runs & hides* ...

I agree..**hides with soot**

me too (or would that be three?) ***hides with the other 2***

xXx
 
As will I, but I will never hit or threaten them to achieve this. :D

That said, horses will be horses and being reluctantm tired and having off days, to my knowledge, isn't a crime ...

x

No harm in having an off day! (I'm having one myself, which is why I'm on NR and not making phone calls, ha ha!) Example: if the horse doesn't want to trot, and is clearly having an off-day, I'll insist on trot - but if the off-day continues, I wouldn't ask for canter; I'd just work on getting a good trot. I'll recognise the horse's feelings, but I'm still going to insist that my perfectly reasonable request is met!

But I certainly will "hit" or "threaten" :eek: (shock horror!) if occasion demands it, because as someone else has said, horses communicate in a physical way. If a horse bites me, it gets a swift, sharp smack on the nose! (No arm-waving or yelling - just a hard smack.)
 
Well Puzzles and Yann seem to know an awful lot what do you reckon gordysgirl let them try to load are two?

Hehe, I would actually be up for a try, but you'd be better off getting someone who really knows what they're doing to show you :) Rio went from planting at the bottom of the ramp and running off backwards once on to being a reliable loader with the help of an RA :)
 
But I certainly will "hit" or "threaten" :eek: (shock horror!) if occasion demands it, because as someone else has said, horses communicate in a physical way. If a horse bites me, it gets a swift, sharp smack on the nose! (No arm-waving or yelling - just a hard smack.)

I agree and I get good outcomes from previous 'problem' horses with a firm approach. Horses are a lot more intelligent than people give them credit for and are more than capable of taking the ****! (runs for cover!)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com