I also love a good debate!

I'm afraid I believe the horse is there to do a job (even if that job is pasture ornament!). Now, of course I don't believe in doing "whatever's necessary", because that encompasses all sorts of horrible things, and I absolutely don't advocate cruelty. However, if I've made a reasonable request ("trot" / "pick your foot up" / "don't barge"), and the horse doesn't want to do it ("I can't be arsed to trot" / "I'm too busy eating hay, don't distract me" / "I want to get inside quickly for my dinner") then I most certainly will insist that they do what I ask.
To date, this has resulted in happy horses with good manners!