A loading debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter vieshot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't get why this has turned into 'you can't emathise with your horse' if you use something other than youself to encourage your horse to do something... I bet you all back up your leg with a whip/spurs use a lunnge whip when lunging...? The handler is simply backing up their request with a prod which actually will have a very minimal shock to animal of a cattle or horse size. It's just so silly when people want to 'ask' their horse to do everything, that when gaps start to appear - as BIrish says I'm the one who can purchase a one-way ticket to France, gawd just get in the ffing lorry, we do enough for them they could at leats comply with our simple requests!
 
I don't really have a problem with any of that. :) I'd even go so far as to agree that some people who post on here treat their horse more like a human in a way that I personally find uncomfortable. However, a) that's the horse world generally, not just NR, and b) there's a big difference between those who use (for want of a better phrase) "alternative" techniques (most of which work very well in the right hands), and those whose refusal to see their horse as a horse is, frankly, dangerous.

But I bet the other forum, and you, were surprised how many people on this thread apparently AREN'T "fwuffy"!

Interesting; because, that said, how is it possible for any person to own and care for a horse if you can't relate to it in some way or have any sort of understanding of each other, if horse and rider and not alike in some way?

x
 
Last edited:
I don't get why this has turned into 'you can't emathise with your horse' if you use something other than youself to encourage your horse to do something... I bet you all back up your leg with a whip/spurs use a lunnge whip when lunging...? The handler is simply backing up their request with a prod which actually will have a very minimal shock to animal of a cattle or horse size. It's just so silly when people want to 'ask' their horse to do everything, that when gaps start to appear - as BIrish says I'm the one who can purchase a one-way ticket to France, gawd just get in the ffing lorry, we do enough for them they could at leats comply with our simple requests!

Be careful of your assumptions of people on this board. :p

An adult is twice the size of a 2-year-old child. Does that make them any less sensitive to touch in comparison?

It isn't in their nature to consider "well, she does get up at 6am every morning and feeds me .. therefore I owe her everything". Horses appreciate sensitive, understanding handling and a good leader etc!

x
 
Just to add, because rereading my last post it could be misconstrued - I fully respect the views of people like Puzzles and Yann, even if we have slightly different viewpoints, and I didn't mean anyone in particular (certainly not anyone who's posted on this thread) ... what I'm talking about is people who'd take the line of "oh dear, my horse won't load, he obviously doesn't like it, therefore I'll let him get away with it and not load him again, and compromise my own enjoyment of a horse by never taking him anywhere ever again." You all know what I mean ... the little-known doormat approach to horse management. I have patience with most alterntive viewpoints, but none at all with that one!
 
Be careful of your assumptions of people on this board. :p

An adult is twice the size of a 2-year-old child. Does that make them any less sensitive to touch in comparison?

x

So you have never ever used wither a whip or spurs to back up your leg, or only even carried it, simply as a 'it's there and I can use it' device?

and as for the adult/2yo reference, that's totally irrelevant and missed my point, what we would find shocking or powerful hardly touches animals like cows/horses due to the difference in skin texture and make-up,
 
It's just so silly when people want to 'ask' their horse to do everything, that when gaps start to appear

I really think there's a big gap between letting your horse walk all over you and using a cattle prod on it though! Just because someone would not contemplate that, does not mean they have a horse with no manners/respect :)
 
Interesting; because, that said, how is it possible to own and care for a horse if you can't relate top it in some way or have any sort of understanding of each other, if horse and rider and not alike in some way?

x

thats not what im saying. Ill give an example.
FWUFFY OWNER THINKS

'he will hate me because i shocked him with a cattle prod'

or

'he will think i dont love him anymore if i force him in the trailer'

That is not relating to a horse, its humanising him, making yourself believe he has that same way with emotion that a human has. He does not think like a human, he thinks like a horse. I understand my ponies completely, ive got one impeccably behaved 17yo and another brilliantly behaved 2yo, i love them dearly but i know they dont 'love' me as they are horses and a horse is not truely capable of love.
 
So you have never ever used wither a whip or spurs to back up your leg, or only even carried it, simply as a 'it's there and I can use it' device?

and as for the adult/2yo reference, that's totally irrelevant and missed my point, what we would find shocking or powerful hardly touches animals like cows/horses due to the difference in skin texture and make-up,

Your point was simply that horses are bigger than us so they can't feel pain like we do ... what makes my analogy any different from yours?

I really think there's a big gap between letting your horse walk all over you and using a cattle prod on it though! Just because someone would not contemplate that, does not mean they have a horse with no manners/respect :)

Ditto! :D

x
 
thats not what im saying. Ill give an example.
FWUFFY OWNER THINKS

'he will hate me because i shocked him with a cattle prod'

or

'he will think i dont love him anymore if i force him in the trailer'

That is not relating to a horse, its humanising him, making yourself believe he has that same way with emotion that a human has. He does not think like a human, he thinks like a horse. I understand my ponies completely, ive got one impeccably behaved 17yo and another brilliantly behaved 2yo, i love them dearly but i know they dont 'love' me as they are horses and a horse is not truely capable of love.

I do totally see your point :) I was just saying that to a degree you need that as the point you made may have been a bit general, 'tis all.

x
 
Your point was simply that horses are bigger than us so they can't feel pain like we do ... what makes my analogy any different from yours?



Ditto! :D

x

That was not my point, my point was those who think it's cruel or wrong only think like that because you imagine what that shock would feel like to you - how humans feel and view things - my point was a horses make-up (inc size/skin thickness etc) and brain works entirely differently. Not just cause they are bigger than us - the size part of my reference was that their body mass absorbes the shock easier (less impact) due to their size hence why the impact of the prod on an animal is less than would be on a human, so us thinking a horse would feel the same degree of shock to us is incorrect. Which is why some people would view it as a forceful way when infact it's not that strong at all when thought and viewd in context.
 
Interesting; because, that said, how is it possible for any person to own and care for a horse if you can't relate to it in some way or have any sort of understanding of each other, if horse and rider and not alike in some way?

x


Of course you need to have an understanding of your horse, and relate to it. The problem comes when people DON'T understand or acknowledge 1) that the horse may see things differently to them, 2) that the horse may react differently to them and 3) that most horses are half a ton of muscle with metal nailed to their feet, sharp bitey teeth at one end, and the ability to make their opinions known!

I didn't mean you shouldn't try to understand your horse; what I was trying to express (obviously badly!) was that you should try to understand your horse as a horse, not interpret every little action as though a human had done it.

An example:

Situation 1) Horse is eating its dinner. Owner loves the horse, and loves that it is happy eating. Owner wants to share in the special moment. Owner pats horse, horse sticks its ears back and lunges at owner with its teeth. Owner bursts into tears, convinced the horse hates them.

Situation 2) Horse is eating its dinner. Owner loves the horse, and loves that it is happy eating. Owner wants to share in the special moment. Owner pats horse, horse sticks its ears back and lunges at owner with its teeth. Owner gives an appropriate reprimand ("Don't you dare!" and make yourself look big:D), then leaves the horse to it, making a mental note as follows: "my horse likes to be left alone to eat. That's probably because horses instinctively compete for the best food. In future, I'll leave him to finish his dinner in peace, and I'll give him some attention afterwards."

Do you see my point? ;)
 
Of course you need to have an understanding of your horse, and relate to it. The problem comes when people DON'T understand or acknowledge 1) that the horse may see things differently to them, 2) that the horse may react differently to them and 3) that most horses are half a ton of muscle with metal nailed to their feet, sharp bitey teeth at one end, and the ability to make their opinions known!

I didn't mean you shouldn't try to understand your horse; what I was trying to express (obviously badly!) was that you should try to understand your horse as a horse, not interpret every little action as though a human had done it.

An example:

Situation 1) Horse is eating its dinner. Owner loves the horse, and loves that it is happy eating. Owner wants to share in the special moment. Owner pats horse, horse sticks its ears back and lunges at owner with its teeth. Owner bursts into tears, convinced the horse hates them.

Situation 2) Horse is eating its dinner. Owner loves the horse, and loves that it is happy eating. Owner wants to share in the special moment. Owner pats horse, horse sticks its ears back and lunges at owner with its teeth. Owner gives an appropriate reprimand ("Don't you dare!" and make yourself look big:D), then leaves the horse to it, making a mental note as follows: "my horse likes to be left alone to eat. That's probably because horses instinctively compete for the best food. In future, I'll leave him to finish his dinner in peace, and I'll give him some attention afterwards."

Do you see my point? ;)


I see it completely but if it were me i would not leave the horse alone to eat his dinner. I would groom him or something all the time while eating and reprimant any aggresive behaviour as food aggression i will not tolerate with any animal whether it be my dog or my horse.
 
This is a really interesting discussion :)! I side more in general with fwuffy owners; but i try my utmost never to humanise a horse because they aren't human :D! They aren't going to be offended if i tell them off for doing something bad, they're just going to think:

Do *insert undesireable action here* = Get told off - do *action* again = Get told off again - and they're intelligent enough to figure out that it's not a good idea to do it again as they'll get told off for it - that's how all animals (including humans!) work. I'm not an expert on loading; in fact i'm a total novice; but i've seen a pony in actual fear being forced into a box by a hefty bit, a large dose of a whip, lots of shouting and lots of people yanking them up the ramp with a lungerope round it's backside - it took hours and wasn't pleasant. I'm not really sure where i stand on 'taking the mick' (i believe some horses can take the mick - it's not a human characteristic, it's just one that humans and horses share) but i try to keep physical stuff to a minimum. Ummmm. . . not really sure what i'm saying :o:D - i suppose that i wouldn't use a cattle prod myself and i would feel uncomfortable seeing it done, but it's one of those things where if someone says 'well what would you do, then?' i shrink off in a corner red-faced because i'm not experienced enough to know (i will admit that one of my failings as a handler is that i'm TOO soft on horses and some take advantage - but the same happens with people so it's just my nature i'm afraid :o!). So i guess what i'm saying is i wouldn't do it myself, but i would be totally stuck for what to do.
Ooops rambled a bit and made almost no sense but i know what i mean :D!
 
I'm sorry i responded to this thread now, i must be thick, just to say i'm glad i own my horses fluffy or likewise.:confused:
 
Well I think its a better option than hauling them in on lungle lines, burning them with loader ropes, beating them in with sticks the list goes on and on.

Some horses load great, they have no fear of the box then once in a blue moon they go nah not doing. So if a click and a rap with the leadrope wont work then a zap on the butt might. Just to remind them of whay direction they ahve to go in ie forward;):)

I am one for working with problems, I managed to get Kia back in a box after he hung himself and that took 4weeks worth of effort and feeds, so I am not stranger to having to work on something.

Once saw a horse who would stand for hours on the ramp, once all four feet were on the ramp he stood like a rock, quite calmly and would eat what ever you gave him not turning a hair but not moving either, no fear of the box just deciding not to go into it. Every time they represented him at it he would do the same thing. How would you sort that?? Eventually someone gave him a sharp kick on the hock and he was soo shocked that he strode right in. They never had a bother loading him after that. Would you condone that???

What ever works as long as the horse isnt suffering.:)

Nikki xxxx
 
I see it completely but if it were me i would not leave the horse alone to eat his dinner. I would groom him or something all the time while eating and reprimant any aggresive behaviour as food aggression i will not tolerate with any animal whether it be my dog or my horse.


Fair enough. :D Leaving him alone to eat isn't one that bothers me, funnily enough (although I can see exactly what you mean)... I'd rather just use the time to clean my tack!

OTOH, give me a horse that won't stand quietly while you hold it, and we shall merrily walk backwards in circles until the point is made - I wouldn't solve the "not standing" problem by just simply minimising the time it has to stand and wait! I suppose we all have our personal bugbears :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry i responded to this thread now, i must be thick, just to say i'm glad i own my horses fluffy or likewise.:confused:

Absolutely nothing wrong with saying you disagree with it - your opinion is just as valid as everyone else's, and you have your equaly valid reasons for holding it.
 
I don't get why this has turned into 'you can't emathise with your horse' if you use something other than youself to encourage your horse to do something... I bet you all back up your leg with a whip/spurs use a lunnge whip when lunging...?

This discussion isn't about not using pressure, it's about how its used and whether the horse learns something positive from it. Just because you're revolted by the idea of using a cattleprod to load a horse doesn't make you some kind of horse handling wallflower.

thats not what im saying. Ill give an example.
FWUFFY OWNER THINKS

'he will hate me because i shocked him with a cattle prod'

I don't think that's particularly fluffy, it wouldn't be surprising if a horse became nervous of their owner or being loaded and trailers as a result of being shocked, I strongly suspect mine would.

'he will think i dont love him anymore if i force him in the trailer'

There probably are owners who think like that, but I haven't noticed any of them posting on this thread. But then again it depends on how you get them in there, and whether you can make it a positive experience despite the element of coercion involved.

Well I think its a better option than hauling them in on lungle lines, burning them with loader ropes, beating them in with sticks the list goes on and on.

But not nearly as good as teaching them using pressure and release and a bit of positive reinforcement for good measure IMHO.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com