A loading debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter vieshot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Can't believe this debate is still ongoing!

I do totally agree with people saying about a horse will load more confidently if the loader is confident and knows what they are doing.

For example there is a pony at my old yard, an absolute 1st pony in all ways, perfect manners on the ground etc. Always loaded straight away no problem would even load herself. Her rider (12yr old girl) tried to load her as she wanted to try and this pony had NEVER shown any signs of refusing. Pony dragged her off in the other direction when approaching the ramp. I took over stright on no problem what so ever. I personally see that as naughty and taking the p1ss! Pony knew at the other end she would have to work saw an opportunity and thought why the hell not!

My mare however is a very difficult case! Any of you who think you can load her (without a cattle prod as this I can assure you would unscrew the final screw which is left in place in a pretty little head!) 1st time please come and try! I took her to a Monty Roberts and Kelly Marks demo (i now do not agree with there methods AT ALL! I was desperate at the time) it took me 2.5 hours to get her on the box, i tried my experienced friend / RI tried, we were all prepared to give up. Her husband said oh let me try (you know the OH that have no clue but think it looks easy) what happens she goes straight in! Now is this because she had given up to and thought oh alright then?

Every horse is different to load, I think your right there are gaps in many horses training but every owner wants a horse to do different things.
Vieshot has said that the pony just stood at the bottom of the ramp half asleep then went on the trailer and stood there eating hay. I don't think this has affected him. To be honest people try anything to get a horse in a trailer - I have heard much worse. Its the whole making it a horrible place outside the trailer so they want to go in to get away from it.
Unless you have a 'no loader' you will never know how that particular horse will respond to any of these methods! It is all luck of the draw. But I think it is very easy to tell between a stubborn - i don't quite fancy going in the trailer today, to a petrified - that trailer really scares the life out of me!

Sorry for the essay!
 
Pony dragged her off in the other direction when approaching the ramp. I took over stright on no problem what so ever.

Because the pony read your intention and respected you, but not her owner. If you can't lead your horse without being dragged all over the place then you're quite possibly going to have problems getting it to go somewhere it doesn't fancy.

Now is this because she had given up to and thought oh alright then?

I've heard of a few of those, sometimes it can be because the new handler isn't tense and worked up, or doesn't inadvertantly use the wrong body language.

Any of you who think you can load her (without a cattle prod as this I can assure you would unscrew the final screw which is left in place in a pretty little head!) 1st time please come and try!

If you can load her at the second or third time of asking does it actually matter in the scheme of things? :)
 
An animal the size/weight of a powerful horse can feel a fly land on its skin.

I would never consider using a cattle prod to 'encourage' a horse to do something.:eek:

When I lunge, the whip NEVER touches the horse. He is aware of it behind him. When I hack, the schooling whip is gently flicked at his side to reinforce my leg aid.

I can read my horse and know that if he is refusing to do something there is a good reason for it. Always something that I am NOT doing or NOT asking right.
 
So if you had a horse who was perfect to handle on the ground in every way, how would you deal with its resistance to load?! There is not a respect issue normally. I can bring him in and out of the field with no headcollar, he will stop and start with me. (no specific training here he just chooses to!)
He does not get anxious, does not sweat, does not breath heavily, he will either throw himself around or stand stock still, doze, but never shows any sign of fear. When actually travelling he often dozes or munches his hay, doesn't move around or get afitated & doesn't sweat.
 
Hmmm

i think its not very good to be honest yes they have got the result they want but there i better ways to do that, however i know some horses/ponies arent scared of the box / lorry yet just cant be assed to get in the box so it probably would work for a horse/ pony like that but i think if you did that to a TB or a genuinely scared horse/pony you would prob make them 100x worse.... but then its like that for everything take a horse from a snaffle to a gag thats slightly strong and sensitive it will get stronger and tell u to **** of where as a horse which is not overly bothered about anything will prob just be the same in both ....
 
Have the people who would use the prod, tried it on themselves?

As recommended by a handful of trainers to practise using pressure on yourself to get the jist of how much can be too much with bits,reins,leg pressure.

I would much prefer my horse to load through understanding it doesnt involve pain or fear. When people do turn to using methods which include pain it is usually impatient people who do not sympathise to the horse being a sensitve creature.

I mentioned money earlier as cattle have the prod used on them as time is money to businesses who mass produce them.

I beleive it is the owners responsibilty to train a horse to load willingly and happily incase of emergencies.

I try my very hardest to understand my horse and treat her with respect as at the end of the day she is another creature who just speaks a different language.
:) you may have names for people like myself but im very glad iam who iam :)
 
So if you had a horse who was perfect to handle on the ground in every way, how would you deal with its resistance to load?! There is not a respect issue normally. I can bring him in and out of the field with no headcollar, he will stop and start with me. (no specific training here he just chooses to!)
He does not get anxious, does not sweat, does not breath heavily, he will either throw himself around or stand stock still, doze, but never shows any sign of fear. When actually travelling he often dozes or munches his hay, doesn't move around or get afitated & doesn't sweat.

Snap - mine is the same, just refuses point blank to load but once in is as happy as Larry.
 
So if you had a horse who was perfect to handle on the ground in every way, how would you deal with its resistance to load?!

Personally I think the easiest and kindest way is with a correctly used pressure or training halter. And it isn't about dragging them on with it before someone suggests it ;)
 
An interesting debate indeed. :)

Echoing Kirby's thoughts here...

In my opinion, using a cattle prod to motivate a horse to load is, at best, distinctly less than ideal and, at worst, downright reckless - reckless because you really want to avoid provoking a potentially violent physical reaction in a large and powerful animal. (See http://break.com/index/angry-horse-fights-back.html for an example of such provocation and its result.)

In any case, it is surely better to train horses to overcome their fear of, or misgivings about, the inside of a trailer or horsebox than to force them to load in spite of them!

If a horse doesn't find loading or travelling unpleasant (i.e. something potentially to avoid), using a device that is liable to create fear is a risky tactic because the horse may then associate loading with something unpleasant. The handler's task may then become harder rather than easier. If something causes a horse pain - even momentary pain - there's a good chance the circumstances in which it occurred will be remembered. (This is an important survival mechanism, of course.)

That's exactly how electric fences work. However, the difference between an electric fence and a cattle prod or electric shock collar is that the fence is 100% predictable. So the horse very quickly learns (literally) how far it can go while still avoiding a shock. It doesn't seem fearful of the fence because it knows that it is not going to get a shock. On the other hand, you will see fearful behaviour if the horse thinks something painful or unpleasant is going to happen to it imminently (unless it has completely shut down and in a state of "learned helplessness"). Once a horse learns that a person is capable of administering a shock, any hint that one may be forthcoming is likely to raise fear levels. It's even worse if the horse is unable to predict when the shock might come or how to avoid it - it may be obvious to us, but isn't always obvious to the horse!

(Incidentally, I consider electric shock collars to be a sanitized form of aggression that have no place in horse training. They are currently more popular in the US than over here. Even though we often adopt practices from the States, usually after a 5-10 year lag, I sincerely hope that doesn't happen in this case.)

Why is fear such a bad thing? The main reason is that it interferes with the learning process, and makes it much harder for you to teach a horse the things you want it to learn because its mind is focused on the source of fear, rather than on you or the task at hand. It's also bad because a fearful horse is more unpredictable and therefore less safe.

Arguing that it's alright to hit a horse because that's what they do to each other is rather facile. Horses mate with each other, but that doesn't mean we are justified in doing that too! While horses may understand violence coming from other horses, and it may be the horse's way of doing things in some situations (in well-ordered equine society it is hardly ever necessary), we are perfectly capable of getting horses to do what we want without resorting to violence - if we use intelligence, imagination and foresight. Routine use of brute force or aggression is stupid, ugly and entirely unnecessary. That's not to say that we may need to "get physical" or even be violent on rare occasions when safety depends on it. However, everyday activities such as loading do not come into that category.

As for putting human emotions on horses, insisting that horses are truly capable of being "naughty" or "taking the mick" is misguided, in my opinion. I don't think think they possess this degree of higher cognitive ability, and I find it is almost always possible to explain horses' behaviour without assuming that they do. To be brutally frank, I consider such a view to be verging on the "fwuffy".

I am not saying that i agree with the cattle prod BUT when inferior horse doesnt obey superior horse he gets kicked or bitten and quickly learns to do as he/she is asked.

I'd like to know what kinds of things a "superior" horse is able to get an "inferior" one to do, apart from moving away. Could a dominant horse ask a subordinate to load itself, for example? Has that ever happened? If not, it might be instructive to ponder on the reasons why not, and maybe even draw a lesson for how we ask horses to load.

So if you had a horse who was perfect to handle on the ground in every way, how would you deal with its resistance to load?! There is not a respect issue normally. I can bring him in and out of the field with no headcollar, he will stop and start with me. (no specific training here he just chooses to!)
One suggestion: make loading a positively pleasant experience for him, rather than something that is merely neutral and that he can't be a**ed about.

Finally, posting a link to this thread on another forum "so they can see what the fwuffy pwony lot think" and for "having a good giggle" was, let's face it, rather sneaky and childish. Let's hope lessons are learned and we can move on in a productive way.
 
Last edited:
Interesting debate :) coming from an open minded perspective as I would be considered neither "fwuffy" as you so eloquently put it; nor violent.

I think Francis Burton gave a very concise, educated reply. I have studied psychology and much of this echoes what I have learnt and as far as I see it's a pretty spot on answer.

Something I'd like to add, not to agree or disagree with anybody, as both "sides" so to speak, have given often interesting and valid responses, is that with horses biting each other in the wild etc but not being scared of each other, why then are some horses 'head shy'? That's presumably from being tapped/smacked on the face which could be viewed as similar to a dominant horse biting an inferior horse on the face, and yet that presumably wouldn't led to a 'head shy' horse.

Personally, I wouldn't be comfortable using a cattle prod on a horse, but as previous posters have alluded to, I have never had to load a difficult horse. When I had to load mine, not knowing what he'd be like, I walked calmly and confidently into the trailer after making it known I had apples, and with only a moment's hesitation he followed me in, no problem (much to my relief! :D)
 
One suggestion: make loading a positively pleasant experience for him, rather than something that is merely neutral and that he can't be a**ed about.


What would you suggest as a positive experience? We have taken him to hack, taken him & just let him eat, as soon as you bring working back into the equation he says no!
 
If you use a cattle prod once and you never have any problems loading ever again, then great. But I would never advocate using it. There are quite a few issues with using it, to my mind anyway. Firstly, it isn't guarenteed to work, infact I think in a lot of cases it might not work at all. Sure for that first time it might but after that you could create a whole host of problems- you could cause your fearless, prat of a horse to turn into a fearful horse who will then truely become a problem loader through your actions; he may start to fear loading because of that one incident with the cattle prod. Or you could have a potentially dangerous situation where the flight/fight response kicks in. I'm sure there will be some horses that would kick out or become even more resistant on using it. And what do you do then? For me, using the cattle prod would be an extreme thing to do and it seems to be something to resort to when things have escalated and nothing else has worked. So where next? Is there an end to the amount of pressure/force/pain you will exert?

And what if you got the timing wrong? That would take a lot of work to correct I'm sure.

I think the thing is , using the cattle prod may well stop a behaviour - i.e. standing stock still on the ramp- but it won't improve behaviour (it might not even work at all!). The horse's motivation may change- they will want to avoid the punishment but they won't instantly become a good loader (or what I would consider a good loader).

And if you do get the results you want then sure the immediate effects might be great but will it be longlasting? I personally would rather use positive reinforcement and work to improve the horse's behaviour. How would I do that? With my horse I'd probably use the clicker but it'd be something I'd have to research into.
 
Last edited:
Gordysgirl, have you tried using a halter? If not it might enable you to get him on calmly and quietly even if he's not convinced :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com