Can't believe this debate is still ongoing!
I do totally agree with people saying about a horse will load more confidently if the loader is confident and knows what they are doing.
For example there is a pony at my old yard, an absolute 1st pony in all ways, perfect manners on the ground etc. Always loaded straight away no problem would even load herself. Her rider (12yr old girl) tried to load her as she wanted to try and this pony had NEVER shown any signs of refusing. Pony dragged her off in the other direction when approaching the ramp. I took over stright on no problem what so ever. I personally see that as naughty and taking the p1ss! Pony knew at the other end she would have to work saw an opportunity and thought why the hell not!
My mare however is a very difficult case! Any of you who think you can load her (without a cattle prod as this I can assure you would unscrew the final screw which is left in place in a pretty little head!) 1st time please come and try! I took her to a Monty Roberts and Kelly Marks demo (i now do not agree with there methods AT ALL! I was desperate at the time) it took me 2.5 hours to get her on the box, i tried my experienced friend / RI tried, we were all prepared to give up. Her husband said oh let me try (you know the OH that have no clue but think it looks easy) what happens she goes straight in! Now is this because she had given up to and thought oh alright then?
Every horse is different to load, I think your right there are gaps in many horses training but every owner wants a horse to do different things.
Vieshot has said that the pony just stood at the bottom of the ramp half asleep then went on the trailer and stood there eating hay. I don't think this has affected him. To be honest people try anything to get a horse in a trailer - I have heard much worse. Its the whole making it a horrible place outside the trailer so they want to go in to get away from it.
Unless you have a 'no loader' you will never know how that particular horse will respond to any of these methods! It is all luck of the draw. But I think it is very easy to tell between a stubborn - i don't quite fancy going in the trailer today, to a petrified - that trailer really scares the life out of me!
Sorry for the essay!
I do totally agree with people saying about a horse will load more confidently if the loader is confident and knows what they are doing.
For example there is a pony at my old yard, an absolute 1st pony in all ways, perfect manners on the ground etc. Always loaded straight away no problem would even load herself. Her rider (12yr old girl) tried to load her as she wanted to try and this pony had NEVER shown any signs of refusing. Pony dragged her off in the other direction when approaching the ramp. I took over stright on no problem what so ever. I personally see that as naughty and taking the p1ss! Pony knew at the other end she would have to work saw an opportunity and thought why the hell not!
My mare however is a very difficult case! Any of you who think you can load her (without a cattle prod as this I can assure you would unscrew the final screw which is left in place in a pretty little head!) 1st time please come and try! I took her to a Monty Roberts and Kelly Marks demo (i now do not agree with there methods AT ALL! I was desperate at the time) it took me 2.5 hours to get her on the box, i tried my experienced friend / RI tried, we were all prepared to give up. Her husband said oh let me try (you know the OH that have no clue but think it looks easy) what happens she goes straight in! Now is this because she had given up to and thought oh alright then?
Every horse is different to load, I think your right there are gaps in many horses training but every owner wants a horse to do different things.
Vieshot has said that the pony just stood at the bottom of the ramp half asleep then went on the trailer and stood there eating hay. I don't think this has affected him. To be honest people try anything to get a horse in a trailer - I have heard much worse. Its the whole making it a horrible place outside the trailer so they want to go in to get away from it.
Unless you have a 'no loader' you will never know how that particular horse will respond to any of these methods! It is all luck of the draw. But I think it is very easy to tell between a stubborn - i don't quite fancy going in the trailer today, to a petrified - that trailer really scares the life out of me!
Sorry for the essay!