Kaboo - that reply seems a little over the top. The very fact that Jen knows it isnt an ideal fit shows that she has had it checked etc and is aware of it's problems and knows they arent causing Aramis any damage - many people dont have a clue and just stick any saddle on. Im ridiculously over the top about saddle fitting but my last horse's saddle wasnt an ideal fit simply because I couldnt FIND an ideal fit for him - even the one I had custom made wasnt right
. I dont think anyone should ride even once in a saddle that doesnt fit, but there is a difference between something which doesnt fit, and something which is not totally ideal. Also I imagine Jen will tell the new owners that the saddle isnt ideal and possibly it wont even be sold with Aramis (in fact I see she has already mentioned that). Aramis also isnt ridden very regularly; a light schooling session to keep her moving with a saddle that is very slightly low on the withers is very different to a horse who is expected to carry off a full workload with a saddle which is pinching or rubbing. Plus Jen is a twiglet as well so she's not going to be causing the saddle to push down anywhere!
My current saddle isnt an ideal fit. It slips backwards and is not balanced correctly. I will be having it changed soon, but since it is not causing any pain or discomfort I think it is important for my horse to keep riding in it - and I dont think Im sick for doing so
. However, if it were pinching or was too tight or narrow, I would not even sit on it. If we're going to be picky then any saddle which slips - front, back, side to side - isnt an ideal fit. Any saddle which sits
you in the wrong position isnt an ideal fit. Any saddle that you dont have changed between the seasons as your horse changes weight isnt an ideal fit. But how many people have the knowledge (and money) to correct those things? To suggest that they are 'sick' is a bit harsh - we all do the best for our horses with the time, money and knowledge that we have, shooting people down in flames isnt what Newrider is about - everyone here is here because they want advice, help or discussion.
xxx